November 20, 2026

Mamata will not concede

A day after media exposed her support for the land boundary agreement with Bangladesh in August 2011, West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee has said she was determined to stop the proposed land transfer and the Teesta River water sharing deal with Bangladesh.

bdnews24.com

Kolkata Correspondent

bdnews24.com

Published : 25 Aug 2013, 09:52 AM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 11:03 AM

Banerjee brushed aside the contents of a letter her Chief Secretary had written to the Indian Foreign Secretary in August 2011 — three months after she had assumed power — and questioned the motive behind the land boundary agreement India and Bangladesh had signed when Prime Minister Manmohan Singh visited Dhaka in September 2011.

The agreement was signed a month after both Mamata Banerjee and Assam Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi had accepted the deal, following the Indian government's persuasion that though India would have to give away more territory than it got, this was a small price to pay for the boost it would provide to bilateral relations.

“It is indeed difficult to accept the present proposal of giving away land to Bangladesh without agreement from the state government,” the Chief Minister said in a Facebook post.

Mamata’s post came days after Trinamul and Asom Gana Parishad MPs had blocked the introduction of a bill to ratify the agreement in the Rajya Sabha (Upper House).

The BJP which had earlier opposed the bill however did not oppose the bill's introduction.

External Affairs Minister Salman Khurshid later called up Mamata and it was decided that three Trinamul MPs — Mukul Roy, Sudip Bandyopadhyay and Derek O’Brien — would meet him. Trinamul sources say the meeting is unlikely to be held now. The bill has to be cleared by two-thirds majority in both Houses of Parliament as the agreement involves exchange of territories. “...our state of West Bengal will get only about 7,000 acres of land but will have to recede (sic) nearly 17,000 acres of land to Bangladesh. This cannot be accepted without taking into confidence and consent of the local people who live in the transferable areas,” Mamata said in her post. She cited the stalled Teesta water-sharing treaty with Bangladesh. “The case of Teesta Water Agreement may be recalled where, during the draft stage, the Government of India had said something, but proposed something totally different in the final stage,” she said. “What is the hurry of the Central government to give away our land and our water without the consent of the state government? What type of politics the Central government is trying to play? Recently, they have disturbed the peaceful situation in Darjeeling,” she alleged. In 2011, Mamata was still an ally of Congress and therefore had not opposed the land boundary agreement. Analysts say she would have allowed the Teesta waters deal as well if the Indian government had fulfilled her demand of a special grant of Rs 25,000 crores to revive Bengal's economy. But the-then Finance Minister (now President) Pranab Mukherjee said no single state can be given such a grant out of turn for 'political considerations' as this would surely lead to huge opposition from other states. "That upset Mamata and she decided to torpedo the Teesta deal and now the land boundary agreement with Bangladesh," says leading political commentator Sukhoranjan Dasgupta. Dasgupta describes Mamata's stance as "cheap blackmail" and says that if the Awami league government is toppled because of the 'India factor', Mamata will be the 'biggest villain in the piece'. "She will owe us a huge explanation if Bangladesh has a new government that goes back to the 2001-06 phase of patronising Islamic militancy which affects India and West Bengal. She is being short-sighted," Dasgupta said.

Also Read:

The great somersault
Related Stories