November 20, 2026

US says India must honour nuclear deal commitments

The United States pressed India on Thursday to honour its commitments to open a heralded new era of nuclear cooperation after talks this week again failed to resolve serious differences.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 30 Mar 2007, 05:03 AM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 02:48 PM

WASHINGTON, March 30 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - The United States pressed India on Thursday to honour its commitments to open a heralded new era of nuclear cooperation after talks this week again failed to resolve serious differences. US and Indian negotiators are trying to complete an agreement affirming landmark political commitments announced by the two governments in 2005 and 2006 that would let India buy US nuclear fuel and reactors for the first time in 30 years. But New Delhi has balked at provisions Washington considers essential, including a US requirement to halt nuclear cooperation if India tests another nuclear weapon, US government officials say. "We were hopeful that we would be able to make progress to close out all of the issues on the 123 (agreement) talks. Some progress was made but in our view, not enough," Undersecretary of State Nicholas Burns said. Burns, lead strategist on the deal and outspoken proponent of improving ties with the world's largest democracy, acknowledged frustration over the stalemate. "The United States has done its part. We've met every commitment we said we would meet. ... Right now I would say the ball is in India's court," he told reporters. Both sides have hailed nuclear cooperation as the centerpiece of a new US-India strategic relationship. India has been barred from nuclear cooperation because it refused to sign the nuclear Non-proliferation Treaty and produced nuclear arms in contravention of international law. In a first major step toward allowing New Delhi to buy US nuclear technology, Congress late last year made changes in the US Atomic Energy Act despite criticism it would undermine efforts to curb the spread of nuclear weapons. The 123 agreement, named after a section of the act, is supposed to be the second step in a complicated process that also requires India to negotiate with the UN nuclear watchdog -- the International Atomic Energy Agency -- on a system for inspecting India's civilian nuclear facilities. Also, India has to persuade the 45-nation Nuclear Suppliers Group, which oversees nuclear trade, to change its rules. India has done little to advance an inspections agreement with the IAEA and the Nuclear Suppliers Group is unlikely to act until the IAEA and US 123 agreements are done. Burns declined to discuss specific differences over the 123 agreement, saying the US negotiating team only just returned from New Delhi and he would not receive a full report from them until a meeting on Friday. But he said he would be in contact with his Indian counterparts and added: "Frankly, we negotiated two very good agreements in July '05 and March '06 with the Indian government. ... Now it's time for India to expedite the 123 talks as well as expedite talks with the IAEA towards a safeguards agreement." Experts and US officials said India had rejected several constraints, including US control over the use India makes of uranium or reactor fuel supplied by the United States. This is intended to prevent India from enriching uranium or reprocessing spent fuel rods to extract plutonium for weapons. Also, India has demanded that if future nuclear fuel supplies are disrupted for any reason -- such as an Indian nuclear test -- the United States must ensure India's fuel needs are met. US government sources said the nuclear deal likely will be salvaged because both sides have so much invested in it. "The Bush administration cannot afford to compromise once again because US law and Congress do not allow for further compromise on the U.S. side," said Daryl Kimball of the non-profit Arms Control Association. bdnews24.com/mi/1052 hrs.
Related Stories