November 20, 2026

US House approves India nuclear bill

The US House of Representatives on Friday approved legislation that is a major step toward allowing the sale of American-made nuclear reactors and fuel to India.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 08 Dec 2006, 06:00 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 07:00 PM

WASHINGTON, December 9 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - The US House of Representatives on Friday approved legislation that is a major step toward allowing the sale of American-made nuclear reactors and fuel to India. The measure passed on a vote of 330-59. The Senate was expected to give the bill final congressional approval in the next day or so, which would allow President George W. Bush to sign it into law. Critics decried the bill as a historic mistake that undermines US efforts to curb the spread of nuclear weapons. But the Bush administration and its allies insisted civil nuclear commerce to expand electricity generation in India will foster a broad range of ties with the world's largest democracy -- a rising South Asian power -- and open up billions of dollars in trade for US companies. The deal reverses 30 years of US policy that, until July 2005, opposed nuclear cooperation with India because the country developed nuclear weapons in contravention of international standards and never signed the Non-proliferation Treaty, or NPT. A multi-million dollar lobbying campaign by India and the US Chamber of Commerce was largely successful in preventing Congress from adding non-proliferation requirements Delhi found too burdensome or unfair. But chief congressional sponsors said the legislation -- a compromise between competing House and Senate versions -- does include some restraints. For one thing, it ensures that if India tests another nuclear device as in 1998, Bush "must terminate all export and re-export of US-origin nuclear materials" to India, they said in a written report. Other critical approvals -- by Congress a second time, the International Atomic Energy Agency and the 45-nation Nuclear Suppliers Group -- are needed before the agreement can take effect. That will not happen before sometime next year. The deal is a "historic mistake which will come back to haunt the United States and the world" and underscores the hypocrisy of American policy, said Democratic Rep. Edward Markey of Massachusetts. He noted that even as Washington seeks to sell nuclear technology to India -- which never signed the NPT -- it is working to halt the nuclear program of Iran, which did sign the NPT. "The United States expects the rest of the world to listen to us (on Iran) while we selectively grant exceptions to countries that never signed the NPT," Markey added. As lead signatory of the NPT, the United States has been obligated to forswear assistance to the nuclear programs of states that did not sign the treaty. Experts say India has already produced about 50 nuclear weapons and plans to reach up to 400 in a decade. Many fear selling India US-origin fuel for civilian energy use will free up New Delhi's indigenous uranium stocks for weapons. The compromise retained a Senate ban on enrichment, reprocessing and heavy water production cooperation with India. Under strong pressure from New Delhi, negotiators softened a requirement that US president certify India is actively cooperating in restraining Iran's nuclear program as a condition nuclear cooperation with the United States. The new provision requires presidents to report annually to Congress on India's performance on this matter but would not end nuclear cooperation if India fails to meet expectations. bdnews24.com/mhb/1112 hrs
Related Stories