Missing engineers are a spanner in Germany's works
When German firm MWL Apparatebau advertised for an extra engineer to meet booming demand, it did not expect nine months later to be still waiting for an applicant.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
23 May 2007, 07:24 AM
Updated :
17 Aug 2022, 03:13 PM
GRIMMA, Germany, May 23 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - When German firm MWL Apparatebau advertised for an extra engineer to meet booming demand, it did not expect nine months later to be still waiting for an applicant.
MWL, a maker of pressure containers for the petrochemical industry, is one of a rising number of companies hit by a shortage of engineers and other skilled workers which economists say is costing the resurgent German economy billions of euros.
Even in a country synonymous with technical prowess, engineering is not as sexy as some service-driven trades in today's job market.
The shortage means firms which have led the German economic revival risk falling foul of their own success, unable to meet the demand for know-how and machinery which has helped propel exporters to the top of the global charts.
"We can't afford not to fill these jobs," said Andreas Barg, managing director of MWL, an eastern firm based in Grimma.
With an annual turnover of nearly 20 million euros ($27 million), MWL is one of many manufacturers to have profited from this demand, expanding its workforce some 30 percent since 2004.
So when brimming order books forced Barg to advertise locally for a new specialist in mechanical measurement in 2006, he did not expect to draw a complete blank.
"Then we ran adverts in other parts of the country. We went to the VDMA (plant and equipment maker's association). We talked to universities. But we couldn't find a suitable candidate," he said. "And we didn't get any response to the adverts."
Finally, the company drafted in an employee from its parent group: "It wasn't the solution we'd hoped for at the start. In the end, we had to lower our requirements step by step."
In nearby Chemnitz, machine tools maker Niles-Simmons Industrieanlagen GmbH says it is short of around four engineers at present, or roughly five percent of its overall complement.
The firm's human resources chief Fred Meinhold said all his rivals in the region had the same problem.
"Basically all firms can do is steal engineers from each other at the moment," he said. "The numbers just aren't there."
The German engineers' association (VDI) said in April that vacancies for engineers had risen over the past year by nearly 30 percent to around 23,000.
These missing personnel cost Germany about 3.5 billion euros a year, according to a study by the Institute for the German Economy, a business-funded think-tank based in Cologne.
The phenomenon is partly due to a lack of engineers coming through universities, said Volker Treier, an education expert at Germany's chambers of industry and commerce (DIHK) in Berlin.
"It's part of the pig cycle: that is, the time lag between the oversupply of skilled workers created when demand is high, and the subsequent shortfall that results from this," he said.
Sven Renkel, a VDI spokesman, said closer co-operation between universities and industry would help ease the problem.
"It's improving, but I'd say we're still behind the United States here. Universities there seem to have fewer inhibitions working together with firms than in Germany," he said.
Although there are now more university students, the percentage of undergraduates taking engineering had by the start of 2005 declined from the mid-1990s by about 15 percent -- a sharper fall than in any other field, Federal Statistics Office data show.
Jan Kuper, 41, a project manager working in education in Berlin, once had dreams of becoming an aeronautical engineer.
But he broke off his engineering degree to major in business and politics after deciding it took too long to qualify and didn't offer enough interesting opportunities.
"Most engineering graduates didn't get involved in building things, they had to work in personnel and the like," he said. "Plus, when I finished in 1994, a lot of my contemporaries spent two years without a job. It was a tough time for engineers."
In the late 90s, the dot.com boom made engineering seem "unsexy" compared to many newer industries in Germany, said Ralph Wiechers, chief economist at the VDMA in Frankfurt.
"The focus has been on the service economy the past decade," he said. "People forget manufacturing is Germany's strength."
The problem has been exacerbated by surging demand for plant and machinery in Asia and oil producing nations, and the German economy's unexpectedly strong revival over the past 18 months.
"We're experiencing a boom in many sectors simultaneously. That's what's causing this lack of engineers," said MWL's Barg.
Growth in Europe's largest economy reached a six-year high of 2.7 percent last year, and the country's leading think-tanks expect barely any let-up through 2008.
Meanwhile, capacity utilisation among engineering firms in Germany, the world's biggest exporter of goods since 2003, is running at 92 percent, its highest level since the early 1990s.
With thousands of manufacturers producing at their limits, Barg said firms and politicians had to devote more energy to courting potential engineers before they finish education.
"At the moment, I think that a lot of graduates really don't know what's supposed to come next," he said.
While stressing MWL's commitment to "social responsibility" -- keeping jobs in Germany -- Barg said that if the supply of engineers did not pick up, some companies may just opt to expand abroad in countries like China where demand growth is strongest.
"I'm not worried," he said. "But I do look upon it as a very significant challenge which we need to resolve soon."
There are signs that the tide may be turning.
Although the number of people starting an engineering degree is still well below the record levels of the early 90s, the total has risen every year since 2001, with the number of female students now 20 percent higher than in the peak year of 1993.
bdnews24.com/srs/1321 hrs