November 20, 2026

Mamata’s Netaji gaffe

Always game for populist gestures, this one has got West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerji into immediate trouble.

bdnews24.com

Kolkata correspondent

bdnews24.com

Published : 24 Jan 2013, 04:22 AM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 10:08 AM

On Wednesday, she said her government wants to build a memorial to the memory of India’s independence war hero ‘Netaji’ Subhas Chandra Bose on the southern outskirts of Kolkata.

The announcement was timed with Netaji’s birthday anniversary on 23rd January.

Mamata Banerji said she wants to build the memorial before the hero’s birth anniversary next year at Subhasgram, south of Kolkata, where the Bose family owned a plot of land.

Image
Mamata rapped for Teesta fiasco

Mamata rapped for Teesta fiasco

"There is nothing except the Netaji Bhavan in Kolkata , so I looked at this spot on Monday and decided to build a memorial in honour of Netaji,” Mamata said. Within a few hours, the Bose family and the Forward Bloc party founded by Netaji reacted sharply to the proposal, dismissing it as 'cheap gimmickry.' They said there is no clarity on the death of Subhas Chandra Bose and therefore building a memorial will only reinforce the unsubstantiated version of his dying in a plane crash in Taipeh in 1945. “We would much rather expect Mamata to lend her weight to our demand that the Indian government opens all secret files related to Netaji. That will reveal much and set the records straight on many issues including Netaji’s mysterious disappreance,” said Bose’s grand-nephew Chandra Kumar Bose. Bose’s niece Chitra Ghosh echoed similar sentiments. “We don’t want a memorial until we are clear about his last days. Mamata should push the Indian government to reveal all secret files on Subhas Bose and bring to light the truth about his last days. Or else this controversy will never die,” she said. Forward Bloc senior leader Ashok Kumar Ghosh was quick to join the attack. “When West Bengal chief minister Bidhan Roy tried to raise a memorial to Netaji in the 1960s, we protested. We will do that again. It is important to be clear what happened to Netaji before we start building memorials in his honour. We don’t like these cheap gimmicks,” Ghosh said. After Bidhan Roy, it was Pranab Mukherji, now India’s president, who had to duck for cover when in 1996 he said Netaji might have died. The remark provoked public outrage in West Bengal, not because anyone believes Netaji would be alive so late in life but because there is anger that the Indian government was never transparent in investigating his last days. Very few buy the Taipeh plane crash story after a host of authors like Purabi Roy and Anuj Dhar have revealed credible information that Netaji had escaped to the Soviet Union with Japanese help in the last days of the Second World War. Dhar’s book 'India’s Biggest Cover-Up' has been very critical of the Congress governments for keeping Netaji’s last days under the wraps. Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose, born on 23rd January 1897, was twice elected president of the Congress before he left the party in frustration and formed the left wing Forward Bloc. He later escaped from India to Germany and then reached Japan to raise the Indian National Army to fight the British.
Related Stories