EU lobby register proposal gets mixed reception
The European Commission will ask lobbyists to list their clients and fees voluntarily to improve transparency, but top firms said this goes too far while campaigners for clarity argued for a tougher system.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
21 Mar 2007, 10:18 PM
Updated :
17 Aug 2022, 02:43 PM
BRUSSELS, March 22 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - The European Commission will ask lobbyists to list their clients and fees voluntarily to improve transparency, but top firms said this goes too far while campaigners for clarity argued for a tougher system.
It is estimated there are up to 15,000 lobbyists in Brussels, where the Commission proposes new laws for adoption by the EU assembly and member states that affect 490 million people living in the 27-nation bloc.
Many are public relations firms and it is not always clear who their clients are and how much money they spend. Large technology and chemical firms have poured money into campaigns to shape EU rules governing the industries in recent years.
US campaigners have said their mandatory system of disclosure creates a public trail to track payments and gifts.
EU Anti-Fraud Commissioner Siim Kallas told reporters on Wednesday a voluntary approach should be tried first. "I am still convinced this is is a more welcome solution than a mandatory solution," Kallas said.
Public affairs consultancies, think tanks, corporate lobbyists, non-governmental organisations and law firms will be invited in 2008 to register publicly who they represent, their objectives and fees.
Life could be 'unpleasant' for those who don't sign up or give misleading information, Kallas said.
Non-registrants will be treated as individuals, having less influence than those who register to represent an industry or sector, Kallas said.
Putting misleading information on the register would lead to the lobbyist being effectively shunned by officials and clients.
"You will lose credibility," Kallas said.
If a review of the system in 2009 shows it is not working, compulsory registration will be considered, but Kallas said it would be legally tricky and time-consuming to achieve.
ALTER-EU, representing transparency campaigners, welcomed the initiative but said a mandatory system would be better.
"It is unlikely that all lobbyists will participate and supply accurate information," ALTER-EU said in a statement.
The European Public Affairs Consultancies' Association said there was a difference between transparency and voyeurism.
"There are certain things happening in commercial relationships that have nothing to do with transparency," Association Chairman Jose Lalloum said in a statement.
"There is no direct correlation between money and influence. This is not Washington," Lalloum added.
The manager of a top Brussels consultancy was even more scathing: "This will be a failure before it starts. It's come out in a form that is wholly unacceptable, ensuring it does not work and raises support for a mandatory system later."
bdnews24.com/srs/0300 hrs