Sayedee witness questioning put off
The war crimes tribunal has adjourned cross-examination of the first prosecution witness in a case against Jamaat-e-Islami leader Delwar Hossain Sayedee.Full story
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
11 Dec 2011, 07:43 AM
Updated :
10 Aug 2022, 05:56 PM
Dhaka, Dec 11 (bdnews24.com) - The war crimes tribunal has adjourned cross-examination of the first prosecution witness in a case against Jamaat-e-Islami leader Delwar Hossain Sayedee.
The cross-examination will resume on Monday after submission of certain documents by the Jamaat executive council member's defence.
The adjournment came in the face of opposition from the prosecution when defence counsellor Mizanul Islam introduced a document and proceeded to question the witness regarding its contents.
A mild argument broke out between prosecutor Saidur Rahman, who had deposed the witness, with defence counsellor Tajul Islam regarding a certain question on seizure list.
Saidur said the defence was asking unfounded questions, to which Tajul said, "But that is how we want to proceed with this witness."
Upon further insistence from Saidur Rahman that "the defence cannot ask such questions", Tajul retorted, "Are you going to tell us which questions to ask now?"
Both camps of the lawyers broke out in laughter at this banter. The tribunal directed that a certain document, which the prosecution had provided, be produced before it.
Tajul Islam was quick to object saying, "But my lord, you cannot intervene to check a certain document and then allow us to proceed."
He said, right or wrong, the tribunal can decide on the question afterwards and not in the middle of the grilling. "You cannot clear the witness without him having to answer a question."
The tribunal chairman, Justice Nizamul Huq told him, "Wait and see what we do. We are not doing anything."
At a later point, counsellor Mizanul Islam referred to a certain document - a memorandum that witness Mahbubul Alam Howladar, a freedom fighter, had submitted to the prime minister, through the Pirojpur deputy commissioner seeking relief for a certain freedom fighter in 2004.
The prosecution immediately objected when the defence asked whether the witness had submitted such a memo, showing Howladar that document. The prosecution's position was that the defence had not submitted the documents that it wished to rely upon.
Syed Haider Ali was on his feet trying to reinforce the point that the prosecution had a right to see the documents before they were introduced in the court.
Tajul Islam said, "But we have been given up to Dec 14 for submitting our witness list and documents."
The defence was expected to submit all relevant documents and witness list by Dec 7 but requested further extension of deadline citing their inability.
The tribunal granted them one more week.
Tajul Islam continued, "We had also asked for adjournment of the proceedings until the date we submitted the witness list and documents foreseeing that such problems might arise."
The tribunal said that the defence could ask about the document but nothing about its contents since the prosecution had not seen it before. When the defence, once again pointed to the tribunal's deadline, Huq said he had fixed the deadline much earlier which the defence had not been able to abide by.
Upon defence lawyer Mizanul Islam's repeated pleas seeking a single day's adjournment, judge ATM Fazle Kabir queried if the defence would submit all documents as regards the first witness within the day.
The defence said it would do so. Judge Huq then adjourned for the day but cautioned that there would not be further adjournments in similar circumstances and the defence would have to do without that benefit. "Law will take its course."
Tajul objected saying, "But my lord, how can you foresee what might happen in future and decide beforehand?"
The tribunal has directed the defence to submit all relevant documents by the end of the day so that the cross-examination may resume on Monday.
Sayedee has been charged with 20 counts of crimes against humanity he allegedly committed during Bangladesh's Liberation War of 1971. The charges include murder, rape, arson and loot.
The prosecution had initially proposed that Sayedee be charged on 31 counts, but the tribunal on Oct 3 indicted the former Pirojpur MP on 20 counts. Sayedee's is the first case to go into the trial phase under this tribunal.
The tribunal will also hear six petitions of BNP MP Salauddin Quader Chowhdury, one of which requests live broadcast of the court's proceedings.
bdnews24.com/ta/bd/1521h