Sayedee allowed attendant
The first war crimes tribunal allows a full-time attendant for Jamaat-e-Islami leader considering his ailment.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
27 Jun 2012, 01:37 PM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 03:57 PM
Tanim Ahmed
Dhaka, Jun 27 (bdnews24.com)—The first war crimes tribunal of Bangladesh on Wednesday allowed a full-time attendant for Jamaat-e-Islami leader Delwar Hossain Sayedee considering his ailment.
Indicted on 20 counts of crimes against humanity, the Jamaat executive council member had had a heart attack when he was returning to jail from his son's funeral on Jun 14 evening.
Subsequently, the Jamaat leader was hospitalised and underwent a heart procedure when the doctors successfully stented three blocks and cleared another.
Now that Sayedee is out of intensive care, his defence lawyer M Tajul Islam told the court during his submission the 73-year old man needed constant attendance.
The tribunal noted the defence counsel's point in its order that as a prisoner with division, Sayedee was entitled to an attendant anyway.
The three-judge International Crimes Tribunal-1, set up to deal with crimes against humanity during the 1971 Liberaton War, indicted the Jamaat leader for such crimes as murder, rape, arson and loot on Oct 3, 2011. The crimes were allegedly committed in Sayedee's native Pirojpur.
The tribunal Chairman, Justice Mohammad Nizamul Huq, asked Tajul Islam whether he had perused the relevant laws and rules and what they said about the matter.
The lawyer said that the laws were silent regarding an attendant.
Prosecutor Zead-Al-Malum pointed out that there were rules and regulations at the hospital as well as at the jail. Without opposing the defence application directly, Malum said the matter should be decided within the laws and pointed to a number of decisions of the tribunal that were unprecedented but the media remained silent about them.
When it was Tajul Islam's turn to counter, the tribunal chair explained that the prosecutor had not really opposed the application and mentioned a few of the tribual's orders.
The defence counsel said the judges' job was a thankless one. "I do not think the tribunal should even expect appreciation in which case it would only affect the cause of justice."
Justice Huq agreed instantly. "Yes, that is right."
Tajul continued to say that the defence application was simple. He said that Sayedee, whose life "swings like a pendulum between life and death", needed constant assistance for even his daily chores like answering the call of nature.
"He has five rings in his heart. The man cannot even stand steadily on his feet without support. These could very well be the last days of his life. And we only ask this privilege in the interest humanity."
The tribunal chairman proceeded to give the order after the short hearing with tribunal member A K M Zaheer Ahmed absent on the day.
The order noted Sayedee's condition as presented by the defence and noted that he needed assistance. The order also noted, that "although it is the duty of doctors and nurses, we know the situation of hospitals in our country". The order said that it becomes easier to maintain regular life with the help of an attendant.
The order said the defence counsel's point about Sayedee being entitled to an attendant as a prisoner with division, which provided certain privileges. Justice Huq noted in the order that prosecution could not present anything contrary to the point.
But at the same time, the tribunal chief said in his order noting Malum's point that the court should not pass any order contrary to the laws and rules.
"Considering all this, we are inclined to allow an attendant with the accused at the hospital subject to some conditions."
At this point, the tribunal asked Tajul to provide a name of the attendant to which the defence counsel said it best be the one who has been a personal aide of Sayedee for long instead of one his sons.
"But the petition says 'a family member'," said the judge. Tajul Islam requested that it should be the personal aide and if the court were thus inclined, perhaps a son.
Prosecutor Malum stood up to register his opposition in case the attendant were anyone other than a family member. "That we shall see," said the tribunal chair.
He told Tajul to add something like "or a person suitable as an attendant" following the part where it mentioned family member. "So we can take that direction when we pass the order," said the judge smiling. He suggested that Tajul put in the words by hand and return the application instantly.
The tribunal then allowed one Abul Kalam to attend Sayedee round the clock.
The judge went on to add his conditions and said that this attendant would be allowed only if it did not violate the rules and laws of the hospital and the jail. Furthermore, if the attendant violated any of the hospital rules then the order would cease to subsist.
The judge further stated that the hospital concerned had the authority to decide the necessity of Abul Kalam's assistance and the length of his service.
As regards other visitors, Justice Huq said it would have to follow regular prison rules and hospital conditions.
Prosecutor Malum stood up to ask what would happen in case the jail authorities found that they could not comply with the order and adhere to the prevailing laws. Justice Huq pointed out that the order clearly said the provision must not violate any of the rules and laws.
Malum wanted to know what the jail officials would do in case it did violate the rules. "Then they can come to the court and apprise us of the problem."
bdnews24.com/ta/bd/1910h