November 20, 2026

Prosecutor on error spree

Not even a judge's name was spared

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 08 Mar 2012, 01:32 PM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 03:31 PM

Dhaka, Mar 8 (bdnewsw4.com) — With his formal charge against Jamaat-e-Islami leader Abdul Quader Molla "full of mistakes", prosecutor Mohammad Ali was told on Thursday to provide the defence and the tribunal with the corrected versions. The war crimes tribunal chairman, Justice Nizamul Huq, had expressed his displeasure with the historical facts saying that he found some of them rather strange on Wednesday. The International Crimes Tribunal, set up on the 39th anniversary of Bangladesh's Independence Day to deal with crimes against humanity during the 1971 Liberation War, had just initiated proceedings against Jamaat assistant secretary general Molla. Justice Huq even asked the prosecutor whether he had consulted books and journals for his research or simply wrote whatever came to his mind. There was another round of dissatisfaction from the tribunal after the lunch recess on Wednesday when prosecutor Sultan Mahmud had resumed reading the formal charge being the lone member of the prosecution present in the court room. It was during this time that the names ofair marshal Asghar Khan and major general Rao Farman Ali, both senior officers of the Pakistan Army during the War, came up in the formal charge. However, one was referred to as Ali Asghar Khan. When Justice Huq reacted saying, "Where do you get these names?" the prosecutor at the podium meekly said, "They are Pakistanis," suggesting that adding the 'Khan' was a natural decision. Tribunal member A K M Zaheer Ahmed could not hold back any more. "You mean to say you will add Khan to Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, just because he is a Pakistani?" Both the judges kept shaking their head at the incredulous suggestion while the prosecutor went on with his reading. But Mohammad Ali's embarrassment with names continued Thursday. He began the day saying that he had prepared two extra copies of a certain document so that all three judges of the tribunal had a copy each. He submitted one the day before. He said he had one for "his lordship, Mr Justice Faizul Kabir and another one for his lordship Mr Justice Zaheer Ahmed." One is Justice A T M Fazle Kabir while the other, who has never been a High Court judge, is Judge A K M Zaheer Ahmed. The tribunal chief, Justice Huq, took a moment and said, "Mr Mohammad Ali, you should be pronouncing it correctly." Huq said whatever the prosecutor had just said was wrong. Ali made a couple more attempts but could not get it right. Seeing his counterpart's desperation, Molla's defence counsel Fariduddin Khan came forward and whispered in his ear. The prosecutor then burst out into an apology saying that he was mistaken and sought the tribunal's pardon but he was a little distracted. "It should have been Mr Justice Fazlul Kabir." Justice Huq told him, "No, still wrong." Judge Zaheer Ahmed corrected him, "It is Fazle Kabir." The judge then told the prosecutor, "If you can't say the names of the tribunal judges, you will become a laughing stock. People will say you don't even know the names of the judges." Mohammad Ali kept apologising profusely saying, "I beg of your lordship's kind apology." bdnews24.com/ta/bd/1924h
Related Stories