Published : 22 Mar 2016, 04:20 PM
Updated : 21 Jun 2022, 08:27 PM
Individuals in high office sometimes must resign, through being compelled to do so by circumstances or by heading for the exit of their own volition. Not very long ago, Dominique Strauss-Kahn, chief of the International Monetary Fund and the man who appeared headed for election as the next French president, was forced to quit amid a case of groping in a New York hotel. A few days ago, Iain Duncan Smith, secretary of state for work and pensions in the British government, resigned over his grievances at what he perceived to be cuts in benefits in the new budget.
These two instances are indicative of the various conditions which often drive people to the edge, where, either unable to withstand pressure or morally disinclined to continue, they call it a day. In Bangladesh a couple of weeks ago, Atiur Rahman, governor of the country's central bank, was compelled to bid farewell to office by handing in his resignation to Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina. To what extent Atiur Rahman, as chief of Bangladesh Bank, is responsible for the cyber heist of nearly a hundred million dollars from the bank's foreign exchange reserves at the US Federal Reserve Bank is a critical issue, something for the on-going inquiry to decide. To what degree he failed to provide leadership to Bangladesh Bank in the seven years he was at its helm remains a huge question. Why he failed to keep the government informed of the cyber heist once he came to know of it — until a Philippines newspaper spilled the beans on the scandal — is something that remains inexplicable. One may not quite agree with Finance Minister AMA Muhith on a lot of things. But on the Bangladesh Bank issue, especially the role of its departed governor, he may have some points for us to reflect on.
Some resignations are truly sad affairs, sometimes leading to overwhelming tragedy for nations. Tajuddin Ahmad should not have been asked to resign by Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, but he was, through a terse letter in October 1974. The man chiefly responsible for the conduct of the War of Liberation in 1971 made his way out of government even as an arch conspirator like Khondokar Moshtaque was kept on. Over the next thirteen months, Bangabandhu, Tajuddin and three other principal figures in the making of our history would be dead. You tend to wonder if the course of history would have been different if Tajuddin Ahmad had not been shown the door by the Father of the Nation. In China, there was a Mao-Zhou team. In the early years of the Soviet Union, Lenin and Stalin together solidified the communist revolution. Gandhi and Nehru got along well in their struggle for a free India. In independent Bangladesh, the Mujib-Tajuddin team, having worked to magical effect between 1966 and 1971, developed cracks in 1972 and broke down completely in 1974.
In the course of his three-and-a-half years in office, Bangabandhu sacked Mizanur Rahman Chowdhury from the information and broadcasting ministry in 1973. An important phase in the history of resignations in this country was reached when President Abu Sayeed Chowdhury decided, on his own, to vacate the office of head of state in December 1973. Years later, it would be President Badruddoza Chowdhury who would emulate him, though not in voluntary manner. He was forced to quit when his party, the BNP, expressed its indignation at his failure to pay homage to General Ziaur Rahman at the latter's grave. President Abdus Sattar, faced with a coup led by General Hussein Muhammad Ershad, had unceremoniously to leave Bangabhaban in March 1982. It remains an irony that President Ershad himself was forced to resign in December 1990 in the face of massive public demonstrations against his regime. He transferred power to Justice Shahabuddin Ahmed and went off into the woods.
Dictators of course hardly ever leave power on their own. Pakistan's history is replete with instances of how men who have seized power illegally were at one point forced from office. Field Marshal Ayub Khan forced President Iskandar Mirza to resign in late October 1958 and, more than a decade later, was himself compelled to quit in March 1969. His successor Yahya Khan had little choice, after Pakistan lost the Bangladesh war in 1971, other than handing over power to Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. Years later, it would be General Pervez Musharraf who was unable to sustain himself in power. He handed the baton of office to an elected president, the president being Asif Ali Zardari. It was an unhappy Bhutto who, having begun to grumble about the Tashkent Declaration in 1966, went on leave. At one point, President Ayub Khan asked him to resign or face the ignominy of a sacking. A nervous Bhutto resigned. He was succeeded as foreign minister by Syed Sharifuddin Pirzada.
Resignations are not happy affairs, not always anyway. West German Chancellor Willy Brandt, one of the most remarkable of statesmen in modern times, was too embarrassed by the discovery of a communist East German mole in his office in 1974 to stay on in power. He resigned and was succeeded by Helmut Schmidt. French President Charles de Gaulle, having pledged to leave office if a referendum on his constitutional reforms in April 1969 did not win public approval, swiftly resigned once it became clear that a majority of voters had said 'No' to his proposals. And, of course, US President Richard Nixon's resignation in the wake of Watergate in 1974 remains a classic instance of how leaders sometimes cause a haemorrhaging in their own powers. A year before Watergate, Nixon's vice president, Spiro Agnew, found himself embroiled in a milk scandal. He resigned, to be succeeded by Gerald Ford, who would go on to succeed Nixon as president and then lose the 1976 election to Jimmy Carter.
These days, with the world buffeted by a multiplicity of crises, Brazil happens to be going through the excruciating pain of seeing many of its citizens demanding that President Dilma Rousseff resign over alleged corruption. She is yet hanging on, though her predecessor Luis Ignacio Lula da Silva is in trouble over similar charges of corruption. In the western world, politicians have developed a fine tradition of resigning from the leadership of their parties once they lose elections or when it becomes known that they have lost support within their parties. The most recent of examples is that of Ed Milliband. When the Labour Party was beaten at last year's general election, he lost little time in resigning. Jeremy Corbyn succeeded him as the party's new leader.
Resignations are a rarity in the Arab world. Powerful men have of course quit office in such countries as Egypt, Libya and Tunisia, but only when they have found all doors to their survival securely shut. The one instance of a resignation, a short-lived one of course, remains that of Egyptian President Gamal Abdel Nasser in June 1967 once the Israelis had thoroughly defeated Egypt, Jordan and Syria in the Six-Day war. A depressed Nasser took responsibility for the defeat, told his people he was hanging up his boots. But then huge crowds spilled out on to the streets of Cairo to demand that he stay. He stayed, until September 1970 when he died. Anwar Sadat succeeded him as president.
Atiur Rahman has resigned or been made to go, for good reason. Food Minister Quamrul Islam, despite the rotten wheat scandal and despite his recent assault on the Chief Justice, has chosen to stay on. Disaster Management Minister Mofazzal Chowdhury Maya, whose son-in-law stands accused of murder, has hung on to his job. Liberation War Affairs Minister AKM Mozammel Haque denigrated the Chief Justice in public over the war crimes trials. The resultant public outcry has not persuaded him into giving up his ministerial position.
Amartya Sen resigned as vice chancellor of Nalanda University when it became obvious the government of Narendra Modi was reluctant to renew his term in office. In January 1975, MAG Osmany preferred to give up his membership of Bangladesh's parliament rather than see the state turn into a single-party political affair. Ironically, Osmany would a mere seven months later throw in his lot with the illegal Moshtaque regime by becoming the usurper president's defence advisor.
The story goes on, for resignations are sometimes curious affairs. All too often, though, they turn out to be cathartic for societies.