Published : 17 Jan 2014, 08:29 PM
Updated : 21 Jun 2022, 08:31 PM
Bangladesh had crossed on 5th of January 2014 the great Rubicon of national election for the tenth time in its 43 years of existence. An election in Bangladesh is always a very stressful event, not because of its unpredictability – far from it – but because its very presence arouses such strong emotional reactions among the politicians and the public alike that it shatters any semblance of normalcy and decency. Human beings, even the decent variety among the Bangladeshis, lose their composure and rationality. Decency goes out of the window and up comes the bare knuckles.
But why is the election so ostentatiously important in Bangladesh? The reason may simply be – it epitomises the single most important event in the national life that promises fame and fortune to the winners and utter dejection and deprivation to the losers. As there are no checks and balances on the governing party and their cohorts, or to put it in the pedantic way, no transparency and accountability, the election is a licence to the winning members to unleash their unrestraint greed. Election is also the lifeblood to political parties for their survival in the rough and tough political games.
But this election, the tenth in number since independence in 1971, had a particularly extra relevance and resonance to the nation. It was relevant because it came after months of blood-curling bickering and animosity between the leader of the ruling party and the leader of the opposition. When the innocent people were caught in the middle, they hoped that this election would bring to an end their misery and nightmare of violence. This election also resonated to their subdued emotions to seek justice against those who perpetrated torture and cruelty to them back in 1971. These two seemingly unrelated traits when conjoined created a vortex of uncontrolled emotions among the general public that swept away decency and moral rectitude.
But when Sheikh Hasina blamed the opposition for being unconstitutional and insisted that it is incumbent upon her to hold the national election as per constitutional requirement, it was nothing more than a mendacious presumption. When Khaleda Zia insisted on re-instituting a caretaker government as per precedence, and in pursuance of that goal she advocated physical violence on the national scale, it was an expression of her sheer brutal instinct and visceral antipathy towards the other lady. These two sanctimonious women grandstanding on their respective positions pushed and polarised the nation so badly that they could not bear to tolerate each other even on the telephone.
It must also be noted that these two political parties and their leaders were not just jostling for positions and spewing out their tribal political jibes, but they were also somewhat dancing to the tunes of puppeteers from abroad. Indian strategists probably handed out the full details of election strategy to Sheikh Hasina and showed her the ways to proceed to victory. On the other hand, Khaleda Zia became solely reliant on Islamists and was captive to the Jamaati strategy and its physical and financial might. These Islamic groups themselves were puppets to the foreign Islamic powers, particularly Saudi Wahhabism.
But what lies beyond the election is more important than what happened in the election. Of course, the outcome of the last election would have the lasting impression on the national stage. India had shown its hand quite clearly – Sheikh Hasina was India's choice to lead the country. In fact, India's preference for Hasina was so strong that to shore up Hasina's desperate position, India did not even hesitate to risk a spat with America. When after the two-day intense discussions and deliberations between Dan W Mozena, the American Ambassador to Bangladesh, and Indian Foreign Affairs Ministry officials including Sujatha Singh, Indian Secretary for External Affairs, in Delhi in mid Nov 2013, America announced that these two countries were on the same page on Bangladesh and India flatly contradicted that statement immediately – they were not on the same page.
This is not for the first time that India and America spat at each other to exert influence on Bangladesh and surely it would not be the last. Back in the turbulent days of 1971, when Indira Gandhi went to the American capital to seek support for her military action against the Pakstani forces in the then East Pakistan, Nixon and Kissinger rejected India's position with disdain and even called her a witch as soon as she left the room. Despite America's vicious opposition, Bangladesh came into being and India claimed to have triumphed over America on this matter. The outcome of this election may be counted as India's 2nd triumph over America. America may be very powerful internationally, but right in the midst of Indian sub-continent, it is well-nigh impossible to nudge India out of the Bangladeshi equation.
But what does 'staying on the same page' mean? America "wanted" Khaleda Zia to take over the helm of the country, given Sheikh Hasina's intransigence on Grameen Bank and her instigation to remove Muhammad Yunus from the Bank, the Padma bridge fiasco and recriminations with the World Bank, the hanging of Quader Mollah and many more issues. Moreover, supporting Khaleda Zia was like showing an olive branch to Pakistan and the financially powerful Arab States. But America failed to understand that by siding with Arab States, America was pushing the little Bangladesh into the hands of Wahhabis and Islamic fundamentalists. This may not matter too much at the moment to America's geo-political grand strategy, but even a small State incubating and exporting terrorism can cause havoc throughout the whole world. Short sighted American policy always creates problems not only for her but also for the whole world. For example, when America decided to support rebels fighting Bashar al-Assad in Syria, they did so by completely shutting their eyes to the fact that the rebels were mostly jihadists and al-Qaeda fighters. Only by taking note of the British Parliamentary constraint did the American regulators restrain their administration from going to an all-out attack on Syria on behalf of the jihadists!
The Bangladeshi election was obviously flawed and fell far short of basic democratic norm. America, Britain, EU or even Commonwealth Countries shunned the election and refused to send any observer to oversee the election as it was dubbed as undemocratic and non-inclusive. These powerful countries may even question the legitimacy of the elected government and hence refrain from giving all out support to the regime. This would create a dilemma for the government — should it slog on without the 'legitimacy of the West' or should the country go through another bout of hysteric election. If so, what would be the new demands of the BNP that need to be met before that party agrees to the election, realising that the country is now their oyster? If BNP can dictate terms, how would Jamaat-e-Islami, BNP's bedfellow, turn the screw on the common people who hold nationalism and secularity so dearly in their hearts? Conversely, will BNP be able to ditch Jamaat-e-Islami and go to the election alone without Jamaat's backing?
India has already supported Sheikh Hasina and her party, Awami League. If now a new election is called upon on attractive terms to BNP, then obviously BNP and its affiliated Islamist parties (Jamaat-e-Islami, Hifazat-e-Islam, JMB etc.) will whip up sentiments against India and supporting Pakistan. The Jamaat, JMB etc. have in their contacts deep pocketed overseas sponsors, who would obviously like to see Islamic messages are spread and the country moves towards an Islamic State. So the whole struggle for Bengali nationalism, Bengali language and culture, for which the country fought and won, would come to nothing.
Bangladeshi politics is a very dirty game. Sheikh Hasina may be the champion of secularism now, but her party never stood firmly in favour of secularism or against the religion interference. At the same time, the AL members were the worst perpetrators of crimes based on religion – they were the biggest land grabbers of minority properties since the Bangladeshi independence in 1971. Did Sheikh Hasina, or for that matter, her father, Mujibur Rahman try to stop those heinous acts and offered protection to the minorities? The same goes for other civilian and military governments. Secularism was never practised ever since the country became independent. Democracy and socialism were lofty words and ideals that remained confined to the pages of the constitution. What was practised by all governments was unbridled corruption. Sheikh Hasina's ministers in the last government boasted that their regime was less corrupt than the previous Khaleda Zia's regime and hence it should be admired and praised!
Whatever controversial and illegitimate way Sheikh Hasina may have come to power, it is her last opportunity to redeem herself. Her previous regime was bereft with corruption, cronyism and nepotism. Accountability and transparency were unheard of in the political circles of Bangladesh. If Hasina can sweep away those dirty linens and learn appropriate lessons from the last election, then Bangladesh can look forward with renewed hopes. Otherwise, the country is literally doomed, as there will be no repeat, no second chance for secular progressive government and the people will fall helplessly into the laps of Islamic fundamentalists.
—————————————-
A Rahman is an author and a columnist.