November 20, 2026

IMF avoids specific proposal as quota talks start

Talks on rebalancing voting power in the International Monetary Fund start on Monday with some major emerging economies already complaining that an opening proposal fails to clearly spell out changes needed to give them more say in the institution.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 10 Dec 2006, 06:00 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 07:00 PM

WASHINGTON, December 11 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - Talks on rebalancing voting power in the International Monetary Fund start on Monday with some major emerging economies already complaining that an opening proposal fails to clearly spell out changes needed to give them more say in the institution. The proposal is the beginning of what is likely to be a protracted negotiation over a new voting formula that would reflect the rise of emerging economies powers in Asia, Latin America and elsewhere. An IMF staff paper circulated ahead of Monday's meeting and obtained by Reuters avoided the thorny issue of a specific proposal for a new formula. Instead, the paper described itself as the "starting point" for discussions. "It is hoped ... the issues under discussion can begin to be narrowed down, leading in coming months to a convergence of views around a specific proposal or narrow range of proposals," the paper said. However, officials from developing countries said they were disappointed by the paper, which some said lacked the needed leadership by IMF staff to force the politically-tough debate forward. Without leadership, they said, the talks could simply re-hash previous discussions without reflecting that emerging economies like China and India have become important drivers of global growth, making a rebalance of IMF voting power critical. The current "quota" formula is based on the world's economic order when the Fund was formed after World War Two with the United States and Europe as the dominant economic powers. The Group of Seven nations - the United States, Japan, Germany, Britain, France, Italy and Canada - currently wield around 45 percent of the Fund's quotas, or membership subscriptions, which largely determine voting power. Under the current formula large emerging markets have fewer votes than small European countries. The IMF's 184 member countries in September endorsed a plan that increased the voting power of China, Mexico, Turkey and South Korea, and agreed to a second round of adjustments, to be completed by 2008, based on a new formula. Some big emerging economies like India, Brazil, Argentina, Egypt and Iran voted against the plan saying it did not go far enough. The objecting nations doubt whether European countries are willing to relinquish voting power to emerging economies. Emerging countries have warned that the IMF's standing could be eroded in the developing world, where critics already resent what they see as the Fund's high-handed policy advice. The IMF staff paper acknowledged that discussions would require compromise and warned that the outcome was broadly accepted by the membership, the IMF's credibility and effectiveness could be compromised. The paper asked the membership to weigh various aspects of a new formula, which has long been based on gross domestic product, a country's openness to such things as trade, its vulnerability to balance of payments shocks, and the size of its reserves. While members agree that GDP should continue to be a dominant factor in a new formula, countries are divided over whether it should be converted for the purpose of IMF quotas at market exchange rates, which is traditionally the case, or on purchasing power parity rates. Emerging economies like India are pushing for more emphasis on pushing power parity, while others, like Russia, say the best would be a combination of both. bdnews24.com/ma/mhb/1936 hrs
Related Stories