Published : 01 Aug 2024, 09:47 AM
Updated : 21 Aug 2026, 11:43 AM
Despite being aware of Best Holdings Limited's financial instability, Sonali Bank invested in the company's placement shares, putting Tk 5 billion of the state-owned commercial bank's funds at risk.
The bank has bled Tk 4.23 billion from purchasing shares at a high price, with an additional Tk 2.8 billion loss due to the declining share price.
Furthermore, the decision to apply interest only on the Tk 10 face value instead of the total investment, including the premium, has resulted in a further loss of Tk 1.73 billion.
The Comptroller and Auditor General's or CAG office holds Bangladesh Bank accountable for approving Sonali Bank's investment in a financially weak company.
This observation was part of the audit report submitted to parliament, which reviewed Sonali Bank's loan information from 2019 to June 2021.
Best Holdings, the owner of the five-star hotel Le Méridien Dhaka, took in the investment to build and operate the hotel, as well as several other projects, including Marriott Bhaluka and The Muslin, a luxury collection resort in Bhaluka.
Sonali Bank's investment in the parent company's shares extends to other ventures, putting the bank's deposits at risk, according to the audit report.
Md Obayed Ullah Al Masud, the managing director of Sonali Bank at the time of the investment approval, could not be reached for comment.
Current Managing Director Md Afzal Karim declined to comment on the auditor general's report, calling it a government report, and evaded questions about new investment decisions.
HIGH-PRICED PLACEMENT SHARES CAUSES TK 4.23BN LOSS
In December 2019, Sonali Bank's board decided to purchase Best Holdings' placement shares at Tk 65 each, with a face value of Tk 10 and a premium of Tk 55.
Sonali Bank invested Tk 5 billion in 76.92 million shares.
Best Holdings sold shares at Tk 10 each to its subsidiary companies, Iconx Hotels Limited and Dhamshur Economic Zone Limited, where Best Holdings owns more than 51 percent of the shares.
The audit report indicates that Sonali Bank's loss due to paying a Tk 55 premium per share amounted to Tk 4.23 billion.
At that time, Best Holdings had a paid-up capital of only Tk 88.3 million and liabilities of over Tk 20.49 billion, though its authorised capital was Tk 10 billion.
When asked about the disparity in share prices, Sajjadul Kabir, the executive officer of Best Holdings’s share division, said: "Placement shares were priced at Tk 65 each for all buyers. The share price for initial shareholders was Tk 10 earlier."
IRREGULARITIES DELAY LISTING UNTIL 2024
Best Holdings, which began its journey in 2006 as a subsidiary of the Metro Group, aimed to list directly on the stock market in 2020 despite allegations of inflating asset values.
The company operates in sectors such as construction, real estate, agriculture-based industries, hospitality, and advertising.
The ownership of Best Holdings is split, with 52.01 percent held by individuals and private limited companies, while 47.99 percent is owned by placement shareholders.
Among these shareholders, state-owned banks—Sonali, Janata, Agrani, and Rupali—hold 29.58 percent of the shares.
Best Holdings sought a direct listing on the stock exchange in 2020, citing its shareholding by state-owned entities.
Under the existing legal framework, the direct listing privilege is only afforded to government firms.
Best Holdings Ltd applied to the Dhaka Stock Exchange and the Securities and Exchange Commission for 'special permission' for direct listing to bypass this restriction, citing a recommendation from then Finance Minister AHM Mustafa Kamal.
It also called for the rules for fixing share prices to be relaxed.
RACE Asset Management, owned by Chowdhury Nafeez Sarafat, and state-run Investment Corporation of Bangladesh were the issue managers of Best Holdings, which was trying to raise more than Tk 2.38 billion through a direct listing.
The commission, wary of the letter's veracity, ordered the DSE to halt the process of direct listing sought by Best Holdings to raise capital in the market.
The market watchdog also decided to dig deep to avert overseeing a probable shady deal. It raised several other questions and sought explanations from the premier bourse.
The office of then finance minister Kamal also suspended a letter recommending changes to the requirements for infrastructure development companies’ direct listing plans after the media reported the content of the letter and SEC’s subsequent move.
In 2019, Best Holdings announced a swift stock market listing after receiving an investment from Sonali Bank.
At the time, RACE Portfolio & Issue Management Limited, led by its chairman Nafeez, was appointed as the issue manager to oversee the listing.
However, the company's listing was delayed due to controversies and financial irregularities surrounding the placement share sales.
After fulfilling regulatory conditions, Best Holdings began trading on the stock market on Feb 6, 2024.
The delay has resulted in significant financial losses for Sonali Bank, according to the CAG’s audit report.
Later, Best Holdings raised Tk 35 billion through an initial public offering or IPO using the book-building method.
Shares were sold to general investors at Tk 24 each, while institutional investors acquired them at Tk 35 each.
On its first day of trading on the DSE, the share price increased by 10 percent to Tk 26.40. The latest price is Tk 26.30.
Sonali Bank, which purchased placement shares at Tk 65 each, is now facing a loss of Tk 38.70 per share. As a result, the bank's investment in nearly 77 million shares has led to a total loss of around Tk 3 billion.
PROPOSAL REJECTED IN 2017, APPROVED IN 2019
Best Holdings requested a Tk 12 billion investment from Sonali Bank in January 2017.
The company had submitted financial reports up to June 2016 and future plans.
In exchange for the investment, Best Holdings proposed offering bonds as collateral.
However, the board of Sonali Bank rejected the proposal in early March of the same year, citing The project's negative profitability and unconvincing financial reports.
At the time, the company's paid-up capital was only Tk 10 million.
In the initial proposal, the current asset value of the Le Méridien Dhaka hotel was revalued from Tk 11.26 billion to Tk 30.35 billion.
The audit report noted that the increase in asset value by nearly three times did not consider the time factor.
By June 2016, the company's revalued reserves stood at Tk 16.22 billion.
Without the revalued reserves, the hotel’s revenue would have been negative.
Besides, the company's debt was higher than its capital, contributing to the rejection of the investment proposal.
Regarding profit calculation, the hotel said in their proposal that the revenue would be used to pay off bond principal and interest.
However, the audit report highlighted that the proposal did not mention the sector's inherent risks due to seasonal and political factors.
The hotel’s space is leased from the Rajdhani Unnayan Kartripakkha or RAJUK.
Best Holdings took loans from various banks and financial institutions by mortgaging the leased properties.
A re-mortgage proposal for 180 days against the bond to release the mortgage with RAJUK's permission was given but the bank's board of directors considered the proposal risky.
Despite these risks, Sonali Bank’s board approved the purchase of placement shares from Best Holdings in 2019.
The bank paid the entire amount on Dec 15, 2019, just five days after the approval.
‘INFLATED’ FINANCIAL REPORTS
In the initial investment request, Le Méridien’s losses were reported as Tk 775.5 million, with negative retained earnings of Tk 439.9 million.
Two years later, by June 2019, the reported profit was Tk 21.7 million, with retained earnings of Tk 361 million.
“The financial reports have been inflated to present the company’s financial condition more favourably,” according to the audit report.
The Comptroller and Auditor General's Office has observed that there is 'no justification' to buy shares at Tk 65 each, including the premium, considering the asset value and debt-to-capital ratio.
Any loan or investment proposal must be evaluated by the bank's credit committee before being presented to the board.
Sonali Bank’s credit committee had also deemed the investment ‘risky’.
CENTRAL BANK CANNOT EVADE LIABILITY
Sonali Bank obtained approval from the financial sector regulator, Bangladesh Bank, for investing in Best Holdings' shares.
On Dec 10, 2019, the Sonali bank's board approved the investment proposal.
The very next day, on Dec 11, Bangladesh Bank issued a no-objection certificate.
“Despite being aware of the investment risks, the Bangladesh Bank cannot absolve itself of responsibility for issuing the no-objection,” according to the government’s audit report.
Two years have passed, and Sonali Bank has yet to earn any return from this investment.
According to the agreement, a representative from the bank was to be appointed to the board of Le Méridien, but no such appointment has been made even after two and a half years.
In this regard, a Best Holdings’ Sajjadul claimed that after receiving the bank's letter, Sonali Bank's Deputy Managing Director Subhash Chandra Das is serving as a company director.
However, Das’s name does not appear on the company’s website among the listed directors.
Sajjadul could not provide further information on this matter.
At the time, the governor of Bangladesh Bank was Fazle Kabir, who did not respond to multiple phone calls from bdnews24.com.
On Jul 15, an SMS was sent to the former governor to discuss the matter.
The latest call on Jul 17 resulted in his request for a written query.
The current governor or spokesperson of Bangladesh Bank did not provide a statement on the issue.
INTERESTS NOT ON ENTIRE INVESTMENT
The condition in the investment permit was that 10 percent interest would be applicable on the entire investment of Tk 5 billion. But Sonali Bank did not get any interest against it until 2021 after discount.
Later, Best Holdings offered to pay interest only on the face value despite receiving premium. Its proposal meant interest on investment of only around Tk 777 million, but the Sonali Bank board accepted it.
In this regard, the audit report says, "In the 748th meeting of the board of directors in the interest of the bank, the board of directors of Sonali Bank decided to collect interest at the rate of 10 percent on the face value instead of charging interest at the rate of 10 percent until the lock-in period (until the time when shares cannot be sold)."
Taking the interest rate on the total investment, the interest of the bank is expected to be Tk 500 million. Sonali Bank will be able to collect only Tk 66 million in the new proposal.
This decision led Sonali Bank to lose over Tk 434 million in interest in two and a half years.
Currently, Sonali Bank is fixing interest at the same rate. This will add more than Tk 1.3 billion to Sonali's loss on account of interest in the three years after June 2021.
The government audit office observed that the changes to the terms of investment violated the 2017 board decision and loans sanctioned in 2019.
When asked about this, Best Holdings’ Sajjadul said, “Due to the outbreak of COVID-19, the hotel business collapsed in 2020. It took a long time to wear off its impact. Because of this, the interest expenses mounted. Interest is proposed to be charged on the face value to avoid a default.
"Sonali Bank has approved it. We have not done any irregularities. The bank board knows everything. I have explained it to everyone."
He said the hotel is doing “good business” now. “We have a few more projects nearing completion. There are more hotels in it. If these are introduced, the income will increase further.”
When asked why they are not restoring the interest terms despite doing “good business”, Sajjadul said: "Now the decision taken by the bank and company board together will be implemented."
AUDITOR GENERAL REJECTS RESPONSE
The auditor general sought an explanation from Sonali Bank's audit firm regarding this investment.
In response, the bank's audit institute said the share price stands at Tk 82.97 following the Bangladesh Bank rules, but the price was set at Tk 65 following the conservative approach.
The paid-up capital of the company was Tk 88.3 million in 2016, but it increased to Tk 5.5 billion when the application was being reviewed, the auditor said
Best Holdings has been instructed to create documentation and include the bank's representative on the board to comply with the terms of the loans.
The auditor general's report said the institution's reply was "not helpful" in resolving objections, so it has been rejected.
“At the time of purchase of placement shares, its paid up capital and external liabilities should have been considered. Subsequent changes in financial condition on the balance sheet necessitated fresh valuation. The company's shares have been purchased by other companies at a face value of Rs 10."
"The bank's deposits have been put at risk due to non-compliance with the terms of the sanction," the report said, highlighting issues such as buying shares at 'exorbitant' rates, taking into account 'abnormal' revaluation reserves, and failing to be included in the capital market on time.
Describing this financial irregularity as 'serious', the auditor general issued an Audit Inspection Report against the auditors of Sonali Bank.
On Jan 16, 2022, the financial institutions secretary was informed about the matter. Later on Feb 7 the same year, the auditor general issued a reminder, but there was no response from the audit firm.
According to the audit report, it is necessary to "fix the liability and recover the objectionable amount from the borrower with interest".