November 20, 2026

PSC ignores InfoCom directives

The Public Service Commission (PSC) is refusing information about examinations it conducted to an examinee despite directives from the Information Commission (InfoCom), it has been alleged.

Reazul Bashar

bdnews24.com

Published : 03 Jun 2014, 12:25 AM

Updated : 19 Oct 2022, 07:31 PM

According to the examinee, Biplob Kumar Karmaker, the InfoCom asked the PSC to give him three pieces of information relating to the 29th Bangladesh Civil Service (BCS) test, as he moved the commission after the PSC ignored his application.

The InfoCom issued the directives six months ago after hearing the two sides.

The PSC’s disregard for the InfoCom directives has raised question about the enforcement of the Right to Information Act, a law enacted in 2009 aimed at reducing corruption.

Karmaker, a BUET student who sat the 29th BCS exams, was not recommended for job in any cadre despite passing the written test and viva voce.

He had applied to the PSC on May 5, 2013 seeking to know the marks he got in the viva voce and the scores of candidates at the bottom of lists recommended for jobs in foreign, administration, customs, police and taxation cadres in the written test and viva voce.

He also wanted to know if the examiner of the ‘science and technology’ paper had the required academic qualification.

Karmaker sent his application through the postal service and moved IncoCom as his application was ignored. Acting on his complaint, the commission summoned him and the PSC for a hearing.

The PSC representative contended at the hearing: “... Of the information sought, the complainant has already been informed of marks he got in the written test.”

He said the information on the marks of viva voce was not provided as PSC Secretariat rule did not permit it.

He argued that the PSC’s constitutional neutrality and secrecy would be compromised, its accomplishment of responsibilities hindered, and personal security of the constitutional position holders at PSC board and the examiners concerned threatened if two other pieces of information were provided.

Not satisfied at contention, the InfoCom on Nov 17, 2013 asked the PSC to let the examinee know his viva voce score and state the academic background of the ‘science and technology’ examiner without revealing his name by Nov 26 that year.

Karmaker again applied to the PSC in February this year as per InfoCom’s directive to find out the marks obtained by the candidates at the bottom of lists recommended for jobs in different cadres, but the PSC remained unmoved.

At a hearing later on April 30, the PSC representative made a written pledge that they would inform the examinee of the marks he got in the viva voce.

Information Commissioner Sadeka Halim alleged that the PSC was flouting Section 7 of the Act by not providing the information.

The Section names 20 subjects for which information may be withheld.

“They (PSC) are misusing the Section-7 and it’s not fair,” Halim said.

When asked about the matter, Chief Information Commissioner Mohammed Farooq told bdnews24.com: “They (PSC) may have any reservation or they may take time to understand this law or they don’t understand (the law).”

PSC Chairman Ekram Ahmed could not be contacted for his version on the phone.

Related Stories