November 20, 2026

Panel suggests open-pit mining for Phulbari

The committee has taken over a year to finalise the report and expected to submit it to the government soon. Reazul Bashar reports. Full report

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 20 Oct 2012, 04:48 PM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 04:23 PM

Reazul Bashar Senior Correspondent Dhaka, Oct 20 (bdnews24.com)—Amid controversies over the coal mine in Dinajpur's Phulbari, a government formed expert panel has suggested extracting coals from the mine using open-pit system. The committee took over a year to finalise the report and expected to submit it to the government soon. "It seemed to us that it is possible to extract coal using the open-pit mining system from the Phulbari coal mine and the north side of the Barhapukuria mine," the panel's head Mosharraf Hossain told bdnews24.com on Saturday. Meanwhile, the left-leaning National Committee on Protection of Oil and Gas, Mineral Resources, Power and Ports has threatened to wage demonstrations over the decision. The government has failed to finalise a coal policy over the past decade. At present, small quantity of coal is extracted from one of the existing five mines in absence a decision. The extracted coal is insufficient for producing power. Under the circumstances, businessmen have been pressurising the government to increase the number of coal-based power plants like those in neighbouring India and China for industrial development. Meanwhile, the government on June 27 inked deals for setting up three power plants based on the imported coal in the private sector for producing 1,088 megawatt. Earlier on Jan 29, the government also signed a deal with India to setup a coal-based 1320 MW plant at Rampal in Bagerhat near the Sundarbans. After signing agreement with UK-based Asia Energy, the firm had proposed to extract coal from Phulbari using open-pit mining in 2005. Amid widespread demonstration against Asia Energy and their proposed mining system, the company wrapped up its operation in Phulbari in 2006. At least five people were killed and many injured during the demonstration. However, campaign against open-pit mining continuing in Phulbari alleging it would damage the environment, homes and livelihood. In this context, the government constituted the expert panel on September last year to give its opinion over extracting coal from Phulbari using a 'suitable system, impact on socio-economic development, water management and environment issues'. The committee chief thought that extracting coals from the other three mines – Khalashpir, Dighiparha and Jamalganj – would have to be done through the underground mining system. "Open-pit mining is good to extract coals where it is near the surface of the land. There is coal 175 metres under the ground at Phulbari and north side of the Barhapukuria mine," said Mosharraf Hossain, former chief of Petrobangla. "At least 90-95 percent of the total reserve can be extracted by open-pit mining while only 65-70 percent can be extracted through underground mining." According to Asia Energy, the coal reserve in Phulbari is 572 million tonnes, which can increase if the mining moves up to the south. The estimated production capability for each year is 15 million tonnes. The open-pit mining, however, has been facing harsh criticisms for perceived threat to environment. Responding to query regarding this, Hossain said, "The water of the well can be drained through separate outlet. How that is be done is an issue to look into as well as finding the place to put the soil from the above the level of coal during the open-pit mining." He said nearly 28 square kilometres of land at the mining area would become unusable for 30 years if open-pit mining is used in Phulbari mine. "The environmental issue must be taken into consideration. At the same time, the economic benefit must also be considered. But the losses can be minimised if the rehabilitation is done properly," Hossain added. On this issue, former Member Secretary of the Oil-Gas Committee Professor MM Akash said, "The government had an agreement with our committee after the Phulbari movement that open-pit mining won't be allowed there. And also that Asia Energy will not be given the work." "The then opposition chief and incumbent Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina had given her consent in favour of the deal. So there is no way to move away from the agreement," said Akash, now a member of the leftist citizen group and also a teacher at the Economics Department at Dhaka University. The Oil-Gas Committee's member Zonaed Saki told bdnews24.com: "The water and soil layers at Phulbari are in such a state that open-pit mining is impossible. The people demonstrated against this." Meanwhile, former President of the Federation of Bangladesh Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FBCCI) Annisul Haq told bdnews24.com "We are unable to use coal despite having enough reserve." "Open-pit mining is being used around the world to extract coal. If we get more coal through this system and it accelerates our economic development, then what's the problem?" Haq also said, "People still have to be rehabilitated even after the coal is extracted using the underground mining system. Then, what is wrong with the open-pit mining system?" bdnews24.com/rb/gna/zk/trb/2237h
Related Stories