AG argues for CG system
The attorney general argues in favour of continuance of the caretaker government system. FULL STORY
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
06 Apr 2011, 07:12 AM
Updated :
10 Aug 2022, 04:36 PM
Dhaka, Apr 6 (bdnews24.com) — The attorney general has urged the Supreme Court not to declare illegal the 13th amendment to the constitution.
Mahbubey Alam was on Wednesday presenting his arguments during the hearing on the appeal against the High Court verdict on the 13th amendment through which caretaker government system was introduced.
"It was done as necessitated by a historic demand [of time] and the parliament will bring about any changes to it, if required."
As per the provision, towards the end of the tenure of an elected government, a non-elected caretaker government would hold elections.
A seven-member full bench, headed by chief justice A B M Khairul Haque, heard the arguments on Wednesday.
Hearing would continue on the petition, though the court did not fix any date for further hearing.
Mahbubey Alam, advocate Mohsin Rahid and lawyer for the petitioner M I Faruquee presented their arguments on Wednesday.
On Mar 10 hearing, Faruquee had said the caretaker government system was destroying the republican character of the state and therefore should be declared illegal.
Alam opined that since it was a three-month government, the caretaker system would not harm the state's republican character.
"Monarchy remains in Bhutan and Japan as a symbol of unity, but it does not hurt their republican character.
"The caretaker government is not headed by some new king, it is the elected president who comes to power," he said.
Alam also cited article 52(2) of the constitution, saying, "Our law minister, industries minister and several others have made it to the cabinet in spite of not being elected."
"There is provision for 10 percent non-elected members in the cabinet. Women MPs are also not elected."
The attorney general tried to drive home the point that such phenomena do not hamper the republican character of a nation.
Presenting his arguments, Faruquee said, "Both T H Khan and Kamal Hossain have said caretaker government might stay for the sake of necessity.
"In Pakistan, a chief justice, Monem, had ruled a military government legal, saying it was necessary."
"It brought about great crisis for the country. Same will happen to Bangladesh if caretaker government remains," he argued.
"After 1/11, they even tried to control the judiciary," Faruquee added.
At this point, the court asked him though it was theoretically illegal, what could be an alternative for the possible real crises ensuing if this system was scrapped.
To that, Faruquee said, "You have sworn to protect the constitution. You must see what is conflictive with it."
bdnews24.com/sn/corr/ach/sh/nir/1945h