November 20, 2026

Sen-Bhagwati tussle over Modi

As he cast his vote at Bolpur (near Santiniketan) on Wednesday, Nobel laureate Amartya Sen repeated what he has done so often -- Narendra Modi is unfit to be India's Prime Minister.

bdnews24.com

Kolkata correspondent

bdnews24.com

Published : 30 Apr 2014, 10:21 AM

Updated : 08 Aug 2022, 06:43 PM

"He has failed to create confidence amongst the minorities. He needed to be more secular," Sen told journalists waiting to speak to him.

But as Sen attacked the man many Indians see as their future Prime Minister, the Nobel laureate's bete noire in the world of economics, Jagdish Bhagwati came out in strong defence of Modi.

"Modi has a vision where he wants to take India. No other Indian leader has that. His own life dedicated to public service, his solid track record in providing quality governance in Gujarat, his clear thinking on economy and polity makes Narendra Modi the most exciting leader in India now," Bhagwati told the Times of India in an e-mail interview from his current residence in US.

Bhagwati and Sen have long sparred on economics.

The US-based professor is a strong advocate of market-friendly reforms that Modi promises while the Nobel laureate believes in strong state involvement for poverty alleviation and higher state funding in education and health.

"It is their economics that is influencing their politics. Bhagwati feels only strong market friendly reforms can unleash India's true growth potential and help it lift millions out of poverty. Sen feels the market is not enough and the state has a role in poverty alleviation," says analyst Ashis Biswas.

"That is reflected in their political choices."

Sen places much importance on social sector spending and is known to trumpet Bangladesh's many achievements in these areas as examples for India to follow.

So while Bhagwati wants to advice Modi (not regularly because of his advancing years, but on key policies off-and-on), Sen wants a Prime Minister who is secular and believes in distributive justice.

Related Stories