November 20, 2026

Indian Left divided over Modi, Mamata

Just when the Left Front , ousted from power in West Bengal in 2011 after ruling the state for three decades, was looking to recover some lost ground in 2014 parliament polls, it has been rocked by suggestions made by a veteran leader of the Communist Party of India (CPI).

Reazul Bashar

from Kolkata

bdnews24.com

Published : 07 May 2014, 11:27 AM

Updated : 08 Aug 2022, 06:44 PM

Veteran CPI leader AB Bardhan has said he is not averse to joining hands with arch-rival Mamata Banerji-led Trinamool Congress to defeat the so-called Modi wave and keep the BJP out of power.

"Mamata is secular and has strongly opposed Modi's tirade against so-called Bangladesh migrants. I think she can be considered for inclusion in a Third Front that we need to stop the BJP," Bardhan is quoted as saying.

Image
AB Bardhan

AB Bardhan

The CPI has previously opposed Banerji's idea of a Federal Front and said all anti-BJP and anti-Congress forces need to be mobilised under the banner of the Third Front for 'maximum consolidation of secular forces'.

But immediately after TV channels aired Bardhan's comments, Left circles were found to be in a tizzy.

The CPI issued a strongly-worded statement calling reports of Bardhan's comments "unfounded statements".

In its statement, the CPI central secretariat said, "CPI wishes to make it clear that as far as the Trinamool led by West Bengal Chief Minister Ms Mamta Banerjee is concerned, she is actually helping the BJP by polarizing the West Bengal voters on communal lines. Her attack on the BJP is a got-up game."

Image
Prakash Karat

Prakash Karat

CPM general secretary Prakash Karat outright rejected Bardhan's idea : "The Trinamool has contributed to the rise of communal politics in West Bengal and Mamata Banerjee has an opportunistic record of joining hands with the BJP. No guarantee she won't do it again after election results are out."

Senior CPI leader Gurudas Dasgupta said Bardhan has been 'misquoted'.

" There is no question of any tie-up with Mamata Banerjee in West Bengal or entering into any combination with her at the Centre."

Left leaders from Bengal, locked in a bitter battle with the Trinamool, said Banerjee was promoting communal politics in the state.

Former chief minister Buddhadev Bhattacharya told an election rally that 'everything must be done to stop both the BJP and the Trinamul Congress because they are trying to divide West Bengal on communal lines."

But there was no question of misquoting Bardhan because TV channels clearly had him on camera saying what he did.

Image
Gurudas Gupta

Gurudas Gupta

This sparked off the 'main enemy' debate which had dogged the Left in the early 1990s when the BJP's fortunes started to rise in Indian politics.

CPI(M) MP and the party top youth leader Saifuddin Choudhury wanted a direct alliance between the Congress and the Left saying the real threat to Indian unity is BJP's Hindutva politics based on the Ram Temple movement.

But CPI(M) leaders like present general secretary Prakash Karat shot down the formulation and described Congress as an equally big enemy for its 'anti-poor bourgeoisie politics' and pitched for a Third Front.

The collapse of the Devegowda-led Third Front government in Delhi and the assumption of power by the Vajpayee-led BJP government tended to prove Saifuddin was right and led to a change in the party's policy when it backed Manmohan Singh's first UPA government.

But Karat's push to withdraw support from the Singh government on the Indo-US nuclear deal , that was also opposed by the Bengal CPI(M) leaders, led to a rupture with the Congress, which then turned to Mamata Banerji's Trinamul to shore up an alliance that ousted the Left from power in 2011.

Now though, Karat and the Bengal leaders are on the same page on Mamata Banerji , not willing to consider any patch-up with her . But there are those in the Left who feel Modi is a biger danger for the Left than Mamata , ideologically speaking , and that will tend to divide them.

"The Indian Left is clearly unclear on the question who is their main enemy in India. They don't doubt the BJP is the main enemy ideologically but while some tend to bracket the Congress as equally unacceptable for being anti-poor , others feel the Congress support may be accepted to keep the BJP out. This lack of political clarity explains the fall in Left's acceptability in India including in their former bastions like West Bengal," said analyst Ashis Biswas.

Related Stories