November 20, 2026

EU does not rule out omitting India WMD clause

The European Commission hinted on Monday that a clause on combating weapons of mass destruction (WMD) could be left out of a new pact with nuclear-armed India, despite worries this could set a risky precedent.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 05 Mar 2007, 02:13 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 02:35 PM

BRUSSELS, March 5 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - The European Commission hinted on Monday that a clause on combating weapons of mass destruction (WMD) could be left out of a new pact with nuclear-armed India, despite worries this could set a risky precedent. Annalisa Giannella, EU foreign policy chief Javier Solana's representative for non-proliferation and WMD, voiced concern last week about calls to drop the clause by some EU states discussing a negotiating mandate for a trade and investment pact with the fast-growing emerging economy. Asked if the EU executive supported the position of these states, External Relations Commissioner Benita Ferrero-Waldner did not rule out the possibility of the clause being left out. "Weapons of mass destruction is normally a standard clause in mixed agreements and it's a trade plus agreement," she told a news briefing. "This has to be seen, but normally it's a standard clause." A Commission spokeswoman said member states were still debating whether the accord with India would be a "mixed agreement", containing political as well as technical elements, or a purely technical pact, which would not require the clause. The European Union already has two agreements with India which contain the WMD clause, she said. The United States last year controversially agreed to civil nuclear cooperation with India despite that country's atomic weapons and its refusal to sign the Non-Proliferation Treaty. Giannella told a European Parliament committee last Thursday that omitting the clause would set "a terrible double standard". "If we were to adopt for India an approach different from the approach we adopt with other countries, I think we would abandon altogether the idea of having a WMD clause with third countries," she said. EU officials say some member states are anxious to avoid offending India, which the European Union sees as potentially a huge market for trade and investment if it can lower relatively high levels of protection with a bilateral trade agreement. An EU official said India did not want a WMD clause included in a new agreement even though the only binding part would be for New Delhi to comply with its existing international obligations relating to weapons of mass destruction. These would include conventions on chemical and biological weapons, but not the NPT, to which India was not party. However, a second element requires a commitment from a country to take steps towards accession to other multilateral treaties in the area of non-proliferation and disarmament, suggesting India should start a process towards the NPT. A third element requires an effective system of export controls related to WMDs. bdnews24.com/srs/2004 hrs
Related Stories