November 20, 2026

Dutch vote may vindicate economic reforms

When Dutch politicians laid out painful economic reforms in 2002, Social Affairs Minister Aart Jan de Geus worried that the timing was wrong, coming just as the economy was turning sour.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 15 Nov 2006, 06:00 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 06:51 PM

AMSTERDAM, November 16 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - When Dutch politicians laid out painful economic reforms in 2002, Social Affairs Minister Aart Jan de Geus worried that the timing was wrong, coming just as the economy was turning sour. "I (initially) thought 'This is a great risk that we take now, and I would prefer to reform in a period of economic upswing'," De Geus told Reuters. But later he concluded that the time was right because the measures would need time to take effect and gave his support. The reforms drew fierce protests in 2004, and just months ago few would have bet on centre-right Prime Minister Jan Peter Balkenende being re-elected, but the risk seems to have paid off in time for elections on Nov. 22. Opinion polls show no clear majority for either the right or the left camp. But Balkenende has a good chance of remaining prime minister, avoiding the fate of German Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder, who lost his job last year following unpopular welfare state reforms. The Dutch government may have cracked the European problem, as De Geus put it, of how "to reform and get re-elected." The reduction of early retirement, unemployment and work disability benefits -- intended to make the economy more competitive as the population ages -- has won praise from the International Monetary Fund, the OECD and the European Commission. Balkenende's fellow Christian Democrat, German Chancellor Angela Merkel noted the Dutch unemployment rate, at about 5.5 percent among the lowest in Europe, and the country's expected above-average economic growth, seen at about 3 percent this year and next. "I have no doubt that the courage for reform and for changes have created the basis for this," she said on a visit to the Netherlands last month, adding that Germany had taken some lessons from its neighbour, particularly on cutting bureaucracy. Analysts and commentators say the government shrewdly timed its reforms, getting harsh measures and budget cuts out of the way early in its term to leave room for extra spending later, closer to the elections. "After the reforms of recent years, we can now offer people calm and security," Balkenende said in a recent radio debate. The individual reforms of the Balkenende cabinet were mostly specific to Dutch problems, such as stricter rules for work disability benefits, which some 860,000 people currently receive, about 8 percent of the working-age population. Other European countries can nevertheless glean useful lessons from the Dutch. De Geus said it was crucial to show results within a government's term, not years later. "What is really necessary is the political courage," Finance Minister Gerrit Zalm told Reuters. Zalm is a leading figure in the VVD Liberals, who have ruled in coalition with the Christian Democrats (CDA) since 2003. "We were very unpopular, but we were very sure that it was in the interest of the country. Then you have to stick to your proposals, not withdraw them when people go on the street." Rabobank economist Menno Middeldorp said the rest of Europe was, by and large, a whole reform cycle behind the Netherlands. "We have had a reform phase in which we have tried to get people back into the labour force, get them back to work, and the rest of Europe is really only starting to do that," he said. "Now what we have to do is figure out how to get productivity higher ... The rest of Europe can probably realise growth to a large extent simply by activating their passive population, by getting people to start working. We don't have that option anymore." Economists, including the government's own macroeconomic think tank CPB, say much remains to be done to put government finances on a stable footing as baby boomers are about to retire en masse, straining health care and pension systems. Without additional measures, the Netherlands would have to pay down all its debt by 2020 and continue to run budget surpluses until about 2040 to have enough reserves to pay the costs of ageing, the CPB concluded in March. Zalm, in a thinly veiled criticism of the Christian Democrats, who have promised voters quiet on the reform front, said that "some political parties" appeared to be tired of reforms. Keeping the reform agenda alive will be the biggest challenge, he said. "What worries me most is that most politicians are just sticking their head in the sand," said Bas Jacobs, lecturer for macroeconomics and public finance at the Universities of Tilburg and Amsterdam. "The next elections will be in 2010, then most of the baby boomers will start retiring or will be retired," he said. "Then it's effectively too late to ask them for a contribution. I fear that burden will be shifted to the younger generations anyhow." bdnews24.com/mhb/1916 hrs
Related Stories