ANALYSTS' VIEW-North Korea nuclear deal
Following are comments on the nuclear disarmament deal reached with North Korea at six-party talks on Tuesday.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
13 Feb 2007, 01:30 PM
Updated :
17 Aug 2022, 02:25 PM
BEIJING, Feb 13 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - Following are comments on the nuclear disarmament deal reached with North Korea at six-party talks on Tuesday.
Zhang Liangui, expert on North Korea at the Chinese Communist Party's Central Party School, a key thinktank: "This is a step forward. But freezing, suspending, disabling isn't necessarily the same as abandonment. So we still need to discount the possibility that North Korea will really abandon nuclear weapons. That's a much more difficult and long-term issue."
- - - -
Peter Beck, Seoul-based Korea analyst with the International Crisis Group:
"I'm a bit underwhelmed. But it's one small step forward. I'm disappointed if this is all they agreed to. We're in for many more long and painful negotiations before this becomes more than a piece of paper."
Though he welcomed a proposed freeze of the nuclear plant he said it remained far from the demand that North Korea completely dismantle its nuclear programme.
- - - -
Shunji Hiraiwa, Korea expert at Japan's Shizuoka Prefectural University:
"North Korea won't get anything unless they take concrete steps, then it will get something in return. In that sense, it is positive. And it is a good thing that a time limit (for initial steps) has been set.
"But the Bush administration had been saying that it would not reward North Korea for misbehaviour. But this time they got something in return for bad behaviour (the nuclear test). Perhaps that can't be helped but I don't think they have reflected on their bad behaviour. So next time things don't go as North Korea likes, there is a danger that they may raise the stakes again.
"There is also the problem of whether the agreement will actually be implemented."
- - - -
Xu Guangyu, former Chinese military officer and now researcher in China Arms Control and Disarmament Association:
"I think North Korea is sincere this time. Their ultimate goal is not nuclear weapons, but two things -- normalising relations with the United States, especially economic and security ties, and becoming a normal state accepted in international society. That's their true goals. They have used hardline tactics to get there, but nuclear weapons are not their ultimate goal."
bdnews24.com/srs/1849 hrs