November 20, 2026

What’s shame got to do with it?

What’s shame got to do with it?
People walk across the Edmund Pettus Bridge in Selma, Ala., on March 6, 2022, to commemorate the civil rights protest march across the bridge in 1965. (Lynsey Weatherspoon/The New York Times)

Tressie McMillan Cottom

Published : 17 Apr 2022, 05:25 PM

Updated : 22 Jul 2022, 03:02 AM

In the old comic strip "The Family Circus," four precocious children blamed invisible goblins — "Not me," "Nobody" and "Ida Know" — for their messes. In the real world, adults who should be too old for invisible friends are doing the same deflection with a goblin named "Shame!"

The shame goblin has friends in places both high and low. Last month, Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene told a conservative podcast audience that Democrats "tried to shame" her for supporting the Jan. 6 insurrection. The New York Times editorial board recently implicated fear of shame as cause for Americans' "losing hold of a fundamental right as citizens of a free country."

That's not to minimise how bad shame feels. Shame can be excessive — toxic shame, it is called — but it can also be functionally good, like when it keeps your pants on in public. Despite the bad rap that shame gets in our over psychoanalysed culture, it is merely a feedback loop that tells you something about your behaviour as well as the expectations of others. Psychologists often refer to shame as a secondary emotion, one that can be positive or negative, depending on the primary emotions that generate it. Those primary emotions are more dangerous to public life. Anger or contempt, for example. Yet we have chosen to turn shame into a social problem. It is bizarre to think that we should legislate, regulate or condition away an emotion or that we should do so for shame when contemptuous, irrational anger is right there.

Shame. Shamed. Ashamed. Shunned. We use these interchangeably to describe myriad fears, but shunning comes closest to the public problem that we are actually trying to name. Shunning is a close cousin to stigma in that they are both about what we do to people rather than how people feel about themselves. It isn't shame but stigma that jeopardises our constitutional rights, our human agency and our collective well-being. Stigma sorts and stratifies people, assigning them to categories against their will. Powerful forces then attach moral and political value to those categories that cut some people out of public life. If we ask not who is ashamed to speak but who is stigmatised for speech, it is easier to diagnose what is a crisis and what is fearmongering.

Greene is an example of why it matters that we get that diagnosis right. She operates like a classic disinformation artist. She elides feelings of shame with the moral clarion of stigmatisation. She suggests that being a pro-white American conservative politician makes others treat her like an immoral or unserious person. She calls that being "shamed," but her rhetoric argues that she has been pushed from feeling shame and into the realm of stigmatisation. Of course, Greene navigates public life with a trail of shame in her wake, but if she were to change her behaviour tomorrow or next year, history suggests that her life would not be ruined. Bad-faith actors want the moral superiority of being stigmatised. But some behaviour is, well, shameful. Being ashamed is not cause for alarm in these circumstances.

Not everyone is a bad actor when it comes to concerns about shame. There absolutely is an online outrage machine that targets people, exploits the way internet platforms work and causes psychological terror in the process. Much has been said about Justine Sacco, arguably the first person to lose her job because of the internet outrage machine, in 2013. She told a bad joke on Twitter, boarded an international flight and was fired soon after she landed. It was harsh. Sacco took a hit professionally. But today she is working in the profession for which she trained. If she was ever truly stigmatised, her very public shaming does not appear to have erased her from society.

Meanwhile, Black professionals without a hint of shame chemtrails are stigmatised for their hair, their names, their complexions and their speech patterns. Stigma — appropriately levied or not — may cause shame, but shame is not the reason Black professionals experience discrimination in the labour market. Sacco was shamed. Black workers are stigmatised. Both of those situations may feel like a public problem, but no one can credibly argue that they involve the same stakes. When we elevate shame from psychological state to social problem, we value systems of oppression that stigmatise those with the least power.

No matter what some would say about shame, public life is more plural and diverse and democratic than it has ever been. What we took for consensus in a smaller public square was really domination of those who could not afford the price of entry by those who could. The internet has lowered the cost of participation and weakened institutions' control over what constitutes legitimate discourse. This comes with some trade-offs that are not always worth it. But shame, alone, is not evidence of a bad trade. As a secondary emotion, it matters what accompanies the shame. If a bigger public square with more equal access is the primary condition, then shame is evidence of a democratic society operating democratically.

Times Opinion and Siena College commissioned a poll in February in an appeal to consider shame a public problem. The poll found that 55% of people have "held their tongue" at least once over the past year for fear of retaliation or harsh criticism. I am a social scientist. I respect what surveys and polls can tell us about the world — and what they cannot. An older poll from a different time comes to mind. It is from 1964. By all historical accounts, public life in 1964 was fraught, dangerous and ultimately important to every debate we have today. The feminist movement was meeting the Black civil rights movement and the progressive left movement against a dangerous global geopolitical backdrop. White backlash to the end of legal segregation was violent, coercive … and normal. The fight to maintain those norms, no matter how violently oppressive they were for some, made a lot of people feel shamed.

A Times survey that year found that 54% of white New Yorkers said the civil rights movement was going too fast. The argument went that Black enfranchisement caused white resentment. It was a Catch-22, since white resentment was the reason the civil rights movement was necessary. Polls and surveys are snapshots. As with a photograph, we can see only what is in the frame. At their best, most systematic and most mathy, polls can only ever capture who we are and not who we should be.

I take the difference seriously. I must also now take it personally. After partnering with The New York Times for a newsletter, I have joined the paper as a regular columnist. It is an unqualified achievement that is not without challenges. As a sociologist, I am far more comfortable critiquing power than wielding it. Many would convincingly argue that you cannot do both. I hear that. I have said that. I am keeping that in mind, always.

But I am not only a sociologist. I tell my first-generation university students that I was not born getting a doctorate. For much of my life, I laboured with the idea that my life would not be much different from my parents'. I am a Black woman from the American South born into a working-class rural family who marched in the civil rights movement, organised with the Black Panther Party and raised me on the middle-class respectability of "The Cosby Show." Mine is a complex mélange of influences. That complexity taught me that context changes everything. It also taught me that public discourse is where we hash out our values. It can be a contentious fight but is one worth having.

I hope it matters that I am in that fight, with careful arguments and the best of intentions. I trend more left than some of my new colleagues and not far enough left for some of my intellectual comrades. At my core, I am a pragmatist — the Fannie Lou Hamer kind, not the John Dewey kind. I bring that pragmatic perspective to bear on a wide range of issues: higher education, labour, inequality, the internet and popular culture. My Times newsletter covered cryptocurrency and political fashion in the space of several weeks. I am a cultural omnivore with a dogged interest in a common thread: how we enact the everyday theatre of an unequal society.

In 1964 when that poll of attitudes about the civil rights movement was taken, there was no commonly held notion of a Black female columnist at the nation's paper of record. From the civil rights movement to the feminist movements, a lot of people expanded the public's imagination at great personal cost. They made me possible as an idea and as a person. That involved a little shame, yes, and for that I am in their debt.

©2022 The New York Times Company

Related Stories