November 21, 2026

The Shakib saga and some other issues

Published : 12 Jul 2014, 12:22 AM

Updated : 21 Jun 2022, 08:30 PM

Image
Photo: Reuters

On the very few occasions, I have ventured to write an op-ed, I cannot recollect when has been the last time (if at all ever) I wrote a piece with so many unanswered questions or with a hesitant stand on an issue. After all, op-ed is a place for taking a position; it is not a place for academic nuances or trying to strike a balance competing stances. However, the hefty and dramatic way Shakib-Al-Hasan, the star all-rounder, the poster boy of Bangladesh Cricket has been punished for his alleged misconduct is confounding for most of us except those few who are insiders or are close observers of the unfolding events. While there are many in Bangladesh who has already taken a firm stance on this incident, I guess there are also many like me who are struggling to ascertain whose version of events they would take. In my view, this is also an issue that reflects the sort of disdains with which rich and famous in Bangladesh take laws and rules.

Of course, Shakib is no stranger to controversy. Through his words, actions, and gestures, Shakib has hurt many of his fans. Some of his misconduct, however disgraceful they may be (the ugly gesture during the recent Sri Lanka series); can arguably be attributable to human vulnerabilities or indiscretion caused by the spur of the moment. But many others such as the troubles with officials in Hazrat Shahjalal Airport, alleged beating or manhandling of a spectator during an international match, the threat of stopping to play for the national team, disrespectful and totally unwarranted comments about the patriotism of Bangladeshi Cricket lovers (after all, it is precisely these fans whose following is the basis of much of his earning) are plainly unacceptable and cannot be brushed aside. Presumably, the star could do all of  these things because he felt that he would get away with anything and BCB's lack of proportionate and timely response to these events have cemented a feeling in him that he is Bangladesh Cricket and stands above the normal rules of acceptable behaviour. Indeed, it is quite telling of BCB's poor management that all his antics have been displayed while he was playing for Bangladesh and none while he was playing for international franchises.

However, it would have been easy for us, the fans to accept Shakib's punishment, if we could put our faith in BCB and their version of the events. The BCB administration has never been known for professionalism and prompt action. Hence, the hasty manner, in which he has been dealt with by BCB, smells a rat. The hasty way the board asked Shakib to return home, tender his version of the events and then punished him for not attending a training camp and failing to get proper written approval for participating in the Caribbean League speak of promptness — something for which BCB is rarely known for. It is also a matter of taking Shakib's words against that of Akram Khan and the coach and it is quite hazy whether their versions have been put through as much scrutiny as Shakib's words have been.

In particular, the open ended nature of the accusations made by the President of BCB is utterly objectionable and an innuendo that can presumably be much more harmful than the complete revelation of Shakib's alleged wrongs. In that case, at least we, the members of the public would have known why our treasured hero has been punished so severely. If we take Mr. Papon's words, then Shakib has committed "inhuman crimes"; then surely the matter is out of BCB's hands and should be dealt with by our judicial system. Surely those so called "inhuman crimes" would merit severe criminal sanction; mere disciplinary action would be an awfully inadequate punishment for such crimes. But in fact, the heavy-handed approach and extravagant words of the BCB President and the members of BCB would give rise to credible suspicion among many in Bangladesh that this punishment may have more to do with settling a score with Shakib than based on professed disciplinary grounds or attitude issues.

When a parent or guardian runs out of patience and wants to deal with an unruly kid, probably it is okay to punish the kid for a long and open ended list of past and present misdeeds. The same rule can never apply to the relation between BCB and Shakib. When the BCB administration as the employer, is dealing with Shakib 'an employee' and punishing him, it must punish him for a definite list of alleged indiscretion/s. In fact, if Shakib now wants to pursue legal avenues for testing the validity of BCB's action, it is very likely that Mr. Papon and BCB would have to satisfy the court with much more than this type of strong but vague accusations.

Despite all his attitude issues, Shakib is also known as a straight talker and not known for caring for the powerful. So one can be excused for thinking that Shakib may have been punished because the Board President and many others in BCB were baying for his blood and would have utilized whatever little window Shakib would provide them. Perhaps it would not be far-fetched to think that by "our future will be destroyed" Mr. Papon meant "our (BCB administrator's, not Bangladesh Cricket's) future will be destroyed." and wanted to send a message that flattery is preferred to competence.

Even if the accusations are true, the method followed for inflicting the punishment leaves much to be desired. Thus, it can be said that the whole affair is an unequivocal display of mismanagement and unprofessional modus operandi of BCB. We know that power shows, power speaks, and power corrupts. Thus, it is understandable why all powerful administrators or larger than life stars would feel that normal rules and norms of behaviour do not apply to them. There is often a common perception that real greats in Bangladesh do not deserve their due respect but perhaps it is no less true.

Surprisingly, I fail to come to terms with many of the fans and masses simply treating many unacceptable display of power rooted in deep arrogance as a norm befitting the status of those with power. This may be a question for our sociologists that why we have so much tolerance or perhaps even admiration for the abuse of power by the powerful personalities. If this whole affair with Shakib has any resonance beyond Cricket and the Cricket administration in Bangladesh that would be like this: some in power would realize that even the most powerful personality would often have to fall back on the respect, admiration, and acceptance of the powerless. After all, it is the power of cricket fans of Bangladesh which can exert the most significant pressure on BCB, if they perceive that their hero has not received his due. For us, the lesser mortals, it is also a reminder that special treatment of some is not only a disgrace for us but also proves to be a burden for those from whom we have taken such treatment for granted.

———————————–
Md. Rizwanul Islam is an Assistant Professor of Law at BRAC University and an avid cricket fan.

Related Stories