Published : 09 Jan 2011, 05:53 PM
Updated : 21 Jun 2022, 08:37 PM
Total revenue from exports increased from less than $300 million in 1973-74 to over $16 billion in 2009-10. Despite this 53-fold nominal increase in exports, the commodity concentration of exports did not improve much, if at all it worsened. During the '70ss more than three-fourths of the exports comprised jute and jute goods. Over the years jute declined in importance and its place was taken over by readymade garments (RMG). The coming into force of the Multifibre Arrangement (MFA) in 1974 was instrumental in spurting the growth of the RMG industry. MFA provided a secure quota-guaranteed access of RMG products to the developed markets. Unrestricted duty-free access to most of the developed countries in the new millennium ensured that the spectacular success already achieved by RMG exports continued after the termination of MFA at the end of 2004.
As a least developed country, Bangladesh enjoys duty free access to EU, Canada, New Zealand, Australia, Norway and Switzerland for almost all commodities. Japan and India also provide duty-free access to most of the tariff lines. Despite these advantages, Bangladesh has failed to diversify its export basket. RMG now comprise more than three-quarters of the total export earnings of the country. Concern has been expressed over such extreme dependence on a single product group. Government leaders routinely state their resolve to diversify exports. And yet, the export concentration keeps on increasing.
It is perhaps not well known that Bangladesh actually exports products under all but one commodity specific tariff headings at two-digit level (96 headings). Thus the nation demonstrably has the capacity to produce, and also export, virtually all of the products in the HS schedule. However, the incipient potential for export has not been fully exploited such that the contribution of most of these products to total export remains insignificant. Only five tariff headings contribute nearly nine-tenths of the total export revenue. How does one explain this puzzling outcome?
As a matter of general principle, any market outcome has a solid economic rationale. If export of a particular product is rising, one could conclude that the economy must have a comparative advantage (natural or artificial) in the production of that product. A nation usually has a comparative advantage in such products as use intensively the factors that are abundantly available in the country. Since Bangladesh is a labour surplus country with very low wage rates and RMG is a very labour-intensive industry, the country has a natural advantage in the production of RMG. While the argument explains the growth of RMG, it does not explain why other labour-intensive industries are not flourishing and also why Bangladesh is not graduating to more sophisticated commodities.
Notwithstanding appearances, economic policies of Bangladesh are on balance anti-export biased. What it means is that export industries in general face greater restrictions than import-competing and non-traded goods such that resources tend to move toward the latter. The success of RMG lies in the fact that RMG entrepreneurs were able to create a non-export biased or less biased environment for their products by extracting various concessions from the government.
One of the principal hurdles that any export industry faces is the high cost of raw materials due to tariffs and para-tariffs. The textile products needed as raw materials for RMG carried the highest import duties and some were prohibited outright in order to protect domestic textile industries. There was simply no question of the RMG industry competing in the world market if they had to pay these duties. The RMG sector obtained exemptions from duties first through a duty drawback scheme and later through bonded warehousing. The sector also obtained easy financing by means of back-to-back letter of credit facilities. These innovations created an enclave free trade environment for the RMG sector that allowed it to effectively compete with the outside world. And compete it did.
These facilities are not provided to industries that do not have a good track record on exports. The duty drawback system is rather inefficient and do not fully compensate for what have been paid. Small firms in non-metropolitan areas are particularly disadvantaged. Fledgling firms operate under onerous tariff-ridden conditions that make many of them uncompetitive against foreign producers who produce in a lower or zero duty environment.
It is very difficult to predict which firms or sectors would be successful in international competition. The government is ill-suited to predict winners and losers. For example, for a long time now the government periodically declares certain sectors as thrust sectors in its Industrial Policy. These sectors are believed by the government to have 'high growth potential'. They are marked for preferential policy support in order to harness the potential. The list of the thrust sectors is quite long, it contained 33 sectors in Industrial Policy 2005 and 32 in Industrial Policy 2010. However, the authors of the Policy did not explain how they picked these sectors.
Some of the industries have been in the list for a long time without exhibiting much dynamism or growth potential. Some industries have been dropped from the latest list presumably because their predicted potential did not materialise. However, the list never contained the ship-building industry until 2010. And yet, this is the emerging industry with a realistic potential to rival the RMG industry. Only after it had proved its potential by bagging several large European orders, the government, and others, took notice. It was included as a thrust sector in the Industrial Policy 2010.
Obviously, the Ship-building industry did not achieve the current performance overnight. Indeed, it is one of the oldest industries of the country. And yet no one noticed its slow growth until the European buyers discovered it and placed large orders with two leading firms. There must be many such industries slogging it out under multifarious constraints with little institutional help. Some assistance at the fledgling stage could help them overcome some of the binding constraints and take off to sustained growth. Since there is no particular method of identifying these industries beforehand, the best policy is to provide a level playing field for everyone. This requires a tariff and tax policy that does not drive down the relative profitability of some industries so much so that they are driven out of the market or entrepreneurs lose interest. In particular, the tariff structure needs to be neutral and industry-friendly in general. Once the potential of an industry is clearly evident, the government may devise policy packages to support its rapid growth. However, such support should not hinder the growth of other potential sectors. A non-existent industry of today could become the booming industry of tomorrow.
While the abundance of a particular factor provides the conditions for the products intensive in that factor to attain comparative advantage, there is no guarantee that these will automatically do so. A large number of labour-abundant countries did not succeed in apparel manufacturing, while Bangladesh, very successful in apparel, did not succeed in other labour-intensive goods. Two conditions that must be satisfied for an industry to succeed in today's globalised world are the existence of a pool of entrepreneurial talent and an adequately skilled workforce. The emergence of Bangladesh as a sovereign country and the coming into force of the Multifibre Arrangement in world textile trade in 1974 created the conditions for a fast growth of entrepreneurial talent in the new country. The nimble and hardworking womenfolk of the country quickly acquired the modest skill needed to run the growing RMG industry. It is precisely because a skilled workforce for the ICT industry did not develop it failed to take off even in two decades despite being a thrust sector and despite all the pious resolves of successive governments.
There is a large body of theoretical and empirical literature in economics that show that economic growth owes much to the level of education attained by the people. Education provides the workforce with the skill needed to succeed in the workplace. Many of our industries including textiles and apparel are suffering from shortages of highly skilled workers. Some of them have resorted to hiring foreign skilled workers in order to run their industries efficiently. Many industries, especially apparel, are known to operate inefficiently because of inadequate mid-management and technical workforce. Bangladesh cannot expect to move out of the LDC status with such bottlenecks. Local youth must be provided with such education as helps them to acquire the skills that the market demands.
Export industries are engaged in fierce competition with the rest of the world. They need to exploit every bit of advantage they can muster, and should not be encumbered by any distortions in the local market that raise costs of doing business above that of the rest of the world. Infrastructure and governance are well known sources of weakness of our industries. The government must do more to ameliorate the situation. While the government can also do a lot for skill development, the private sector must bear a greater share of the responsibility to train their workforce in appropriate skills. They should not depend on government largesse all the time.
————————-
Professor M A Taslim is the CEO, Bangladesh Foreign Trade Institute