November 20, 2026

Neanderthal me!

Ahmed Shafee

Published : 08 Jun 2014, 05:07 PM

Updated : 21 Jun 2022, 08:30 PM

A new revolution in mass education is MOOC (Massive Open Online Course), given by top professors at many of the most well-known universities of the world. Some might use it to refresh their dimming knowledge of a subject they had studied long ago, including all the new developments since leaving school. Somebody may want to learn everything they had always wanted to know about certain topics, but were afraid to ask, and young people at school can get a head-start before they go to university. It is completely free and thousands of students enrol themselves for each course. The contents include video lectures with sub-titles in many languages and English transcripts, fairly tough weekly quizzes graded by computers, or written assignments graded by peers, discussion forums, and suggestions for further reading. At the end one gets a well-designed colourful certificate signed by the teacher, with a "with distinction" stamp when the score exceeds 90%.

My daughter, who is working at Harvard, recently told me that she had a complete genome analysis for fun. There is a private enterprise named 23andMe (we all have a doublet of 23 chromosomes) who are doing it for only $100 per person (must have cost much more to get the Jute genome). They get the genes from saliva samples sent to them by anybody interested. One thing she found amusing was that some of her ancestry seems to be Neanderthal. Coincidentally, I was taking a MOOC course on Genomes at the time and we both agreed that even her Irish-German American husband had probably the same amount (2.5%, i.e. equivalent to having one great-great-great-great parent) of Neanderthal DNA. Only East Africans, who are the purebred modern human beings, do not have any Neanderthal blood, because those who stayed around their birthplace never met the tougher, rougher, hunting cousin species. The migrants to other parts of the world, whether Europe, Asia, America or Australia, despite the small cross-breeding giving the 2.5%, may have been one of the causes of the extinction of the Neanderthals, presented now as loveable, cute simple-minded creatures in some popular TV cartoon serials.

My daughter sent me her report, and we noted with surprise that 23andMe had a sufficiently large data-base to locate her more recent origin as the Indian subcontinent. I suppose the lack of genes for blue eyes, or blonde hair or European-style fair skin, and the presence of DNA segments for large eyes, straight hair, and delicate bones, and many other regionally prevalent factors, could have helped identify her contemporary pedigree. Such distinctions do not depend on single inherited DNA mutations characteristic of well-defined and predictable rules of Gregor Mendel. He had discovered with his pea cross-breeding experiments simple laws that gave birth to the field of genetics. Complex interactions of many dozens of genes are responsible for the somewhat unpredictable inherited features such as height. Plenty of mathematical tricks and sophisticated statistics have to be used in the analysis.

At this price 23andMe have no dearth of customers. The data-base gets larger everyday, allowing more combinations and variations to be investigated and correlated, and the precision becomes increasingly awesome. With missionary zeal the biotech company keeps sending regular updates to the customers. The last assessment sent to my daughter contained a flag of Bangladesh. Though she does not always look like a typical Bangladeshi, and in the USA has been mistaken occasionally as Spanish, South American or of other nationalities, they have no doubts now that she is not just Indian, but also a Bangladeshi. Actually 'Bangali' probably would have been a more appropriate tag, and I am not siding with any political ideology or rhetoric, because I have a feeling that at least some of our tribal people's genes would have confused the cataloguers. Not too sure about that, because my daughter's mother claimed somewhat esoteric roots from Kashmir, but that must have diluted down after some generations. However, she is unlikely to end up in Fulgazi or Chhagalnaiya, because the other half of her inheritance definitely was never there.

Apart from nationality, the genome profile contains more important data about genes that are associated with certain inheritable diseases. Angelina Jolie made headlines by having a mastectomy because a gene test found one mutated gene often seen to be associated with breast cancer. I learned in another MOOC Genomics course that the probability of cancer does increase when the gene mutates, but the increase is not all that significant compared to the usual risk of breast cancer of even a normal person, and if there is constant monitoring, a breast cancer is quite treatable in the early stages. Anyway, the choice was Ms Jolie's.

In Richard Dawkin's The Selfish Gene, published in 1976, rather out-of-date considering the recent surge of research in genetics, he proposed the concept of symbolically 'selfish' genes more interested in propagating their own copies, than in planning for better survival of their individual carriers. Family, tribal and national bonds may be consequences of that principle – similar genes making carriers stick together as a group, so that they, and hence the genes, could survive more comfortably. So, love and hate, loyalty or enmity, may simply be complex macro-manifestations of microscopic genetic interactions. The last refuge of scoundrels emerges in this paradigm as a genetic trick.

Some multidisciplinary studies are trying to show correlations between inherited genes and political ideologies, there are even claims that one can predict from genomes who will be a liberal and who a conservative. I am dreading what next 23andMe will send my daughter – "You are genetically predisposed to support Awami League/BNP"? Since they do not have my genome, there is no possibility of a 'nominal' error – "Young woman, seek help, you seem to be closely related to a controversial religious leader." Fortunately, in this country there seems to be plenty of marriages between the well-off children of opposing camps, despite the official malevolence. Two sides of the same coin [qed].

—————————–
Ahmed Shafee is a columnist.

Related Stories