November 20, 2026

NATO dodges bullet on Sweden, identifies new divisions

While Turkey could yet roll back once more on its pledge to sign off on Sweden’s entry into NATO, the working assumption of most officials is that it won’t

NATO dodges bullet on Sweden, identifies new divisions
A NATO flag flutters at the Tapa military base, Estonia Apr 30, 2023.

Peter Apps Peter Apps

Published : 15 Jul 2023, 12:36 PM

Updated : 15 Jul 2023, 12:24 PM

It's unusual for much to be left to chance at NATO summits. When decisions come at the last minute, as in 2008 when George W Bush pushed to get Ukraine and Georgia on track to join, the outcomes can be messy.

As NATO leaders arrived in Vilnius this week, it looked as though the Western defence alliance might yet be on the brink of a last-minute humiliation.

Having endorsed the entry of both Finland and Sweden in Madrid a year ago, Sweden was still being blocked by Turkey. Even as late as Monday, Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan was suggesting yet another condition, tying Sweden’s admission to Turkish entry into the European Union.

That evening, however, the mood music changed, with Turkish acquiescence, in principle at least, to let Sweden in. How swiftly the government and parliament follow through is another question.

But it avoided an embarrassing failure to agree that could have significantly undermined the wider summit.

Overall, alliance leaders seem more than happy with the outcome in Vilnius, with NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg describing the alliance as more unified than at any point in its recent history.

But the summit showcased several new emerging divisions and power bases within the 74-year-old alliance, which has been given new life following Russia's 2022 invasion of Ukraine.

The most obvious difference is over Ukraine's path to membership.

In 2008, NATO agreed to put both Ukraine and Georgia in a no-man’s-land in which they were theoretically headed towards membership but with no immediate prospect of joining. In Vilnius, some of those hurdles were removed for Ukraine, in principle making it easier for it to join once the fighting stops.

It was another halfway house that Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky described on social media on Tuesday as “absurd”, although he was able to summon more diplomatic enthusiasm to welcome the announcement the following day.

Georgia still isn't a member.

Eastern and Central European states – particularly Baltic states and Poland – that have lobbied hard for Ukraine's faster accession were also largely diplomatic in their response, disappointed but keeping their criticism relatively light.

Ukraine did, however, get further promises for weapons and for firming up the training of F-16 pilots in Romania as well as economic and security guarantees from the G7.

The outcome was more of a victory for the United States and Germany, which had both suggested that it was too soon and dangerous to bring Ukraine into the alliance while still at war. With Germany announcing it will step up its defence spending to meet the alliance target of 2% of GDP, it will likely be among the largest military spenders in Europe, if not the largest.

While the government of Chancellor Olaf Scholz has been criticised for its perceived soft response to Russia and slow moves on Ukraine, German power within the alliance appears steadily on the rise. Shortly before the meeting, Berlin announced it was tripling its forces in Lithuania to a full combat brigade, something Canada has also pledged to match in nearby Latvia.

TO REINFORCE OR NOT?

That puts both Britain and France in an awkward situation. Estonia, which is seen as one of the most vulnerable eastern European nations to possible Russian attack, hosts a British-led battle group that it would also like to see similarly reinforced, as would Romania with the French battle group there.

Neither London nor Paris, however, has felt able to make that pledge, prompting some analysts to question whether either has the military resources available to maintain such a force. In Vilnius, Britain signed an understanding with Estonia to build up ability to reinforce to a full brigade in time of crisis, but Baltic diplomats say that lacks the same deterrent effect.

The summit saw NATO leaders agree on a series of defence plans for northern, eastern and central Europe, by far the most sophisticated planning for a potential war with Russia that the alliance has conducted since the Berlin Wall came down.

In Madrid last year, the alliance agreed to put 300,000 troops on standby for deployment within six months – although whether such forces genuinely exist and could be moved at that speed remains unclear.

In the short term, alliance officials say that Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has significantly reduced the risk to NATO states – Russia’s military is now considerably weakened, and would likely struggle to attack other European nations without abandoning its Ukraine attack entirely.

But once the war ends, NATO’s military chairman, Admiral Rob Bauer, has made it clear the alliance expects Russia’s military to rebuild.

In the Baltic states and Poland, there are also mounting worries over the threat from Belarus, which Putin announced last month was now hosting short-range Russian tactical nuclear weapons and which is also set to become the home of Wagner Group mercenaries moved out of Russia following their failed march on Moscow at the start of June.

TURKISH F-16s, TOKYO OFFICE

While Turkey could yet roll back once more on its pledge to sign off on Sweden’s entry into NATO, the working assumption of most officials is that it won’t. After months of speculation over what it would take to persuade Turkey to agree, Stockholm has now almost certainly gone as far as it is willing in terms of jailing Kurdish separatists and cracking down on protests.

As Sweden made clear, there were limits to what it would do to gain NATO accession – particularly when it came to deporting particular prisoners back to Turkey. The focus changed to arms sales: US F-16s, offered as part of a complex deal that US officials told lawmakers was in part explicitly designed to win over Ankara on Sweden.

After flirting with Russia for much of the last decade – including sparking a major row with other NATO allies by buying Russian-built S-300 anti-aircraft missiles – Erdogan appears to be moving back towards the West, endorsing Ukraine’s request to join NATO and also looking to cosy up once more to the European Union (although membership there still seems way out of reach).

France too raised some eyebrows by endorsing eventual Ukrainian NATO membership this week – but grabbed more headlines for blocking the opening of a NATO office in Japan. French officials say NATO should maintain its European focus.

That was something of a slap in the face for Stoltenberg, whose efforts to secure a place for the alliance in Asia have seen South Korean, Japanese, Australian and New Zealand ministers and leaders become a regular fixture at NATO meetings.

It’s also a reminder of divisions within Europe over China.

* Peter Apps is a Reuters columnist writing on defence and security issues. He joined Reuters in 2003, reporting from southern Africa and Sri Lanka and on global defence issues. He has been a columnist since 2016. He is also the founder of a think tank, the Project for Study of the 21st Century, and, since 2016, has been a Labour Party activist and British Army reservist.

Related Stories