Published : 23 Feb 2014, 11:54 AM
Updated : 08 Aug 2022, 06:31 PM
“This is first time the FDA has ordered a product to be removed from the market for broad public health concerns,” said Matthew L. Myers, the president of the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids, an advocacy group.
The FDA was bestowed the legal authority in 2009.
“It’s also significant that they did so because the manufacturer was unable or unwilling to provide sufficient evidence that the product didn’t raise new or different concerns for public health,” Myers added.
The products are Sutra Bidis Red, Sutra Bidis Menthol, Sutra Bidis Red Cone and Sutra Bidis Menthol Cone. The FDA will begin seizing these bidi packets if they are not taken off the shelves within 30 days.
The four cigarette brands made by Indian company Jash International may no longer be domestically sold, distributed or imported, said FDA officials.
The FDA has rejected 13 new tobacco products since June 2013 because scientists believe they posed greater health risks than comparable products already on the market.
Bidis are thin, hand-rolled cigarettes wrapped in leaves and sometimes tied with a colorful string.
Unlike India, Bidis aren’t popular in US, but their novelty appeals to some adolescents.
A total 1.7 percent of American middle school students and 2 percent of high school students smoke bidis, according to a report by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in 2012.
Mitchell Zeller, director of the Center for Tobacco Products at the FDA, called the action “historic” and said, “It shows the role and the power of regulation.”
Various tobacco researchers have hailed the move by FDA which arrives shortly after the latest surgeon general’s report, published last month, which noted that modern cigarettes have increased the risk of the most common type of lung cancer, because of changes in design and composition since the 1950s.
It noted that levels of some carcinogens in cigarette smoke have increased as manufacturing processes have changed.
“Some additives and flavorings at low levels enhance appeal, taste and addictiveness, but when they burn they are carcinogens,” said Dr. Abrams, a professor at Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.
The FDA move will to stop undocumented ingredient changes, he said.
The Sutra brands were removed not because of their flavorings, but because of the company’s failure to provide ingredient information.
The removal of two menthol brands leads to a larger question about whether menthol in cigarettes should be banned.
According to Dr. Abrams, “It’s long overdue.”
The removal of the Sutra brands was mostly a “symbolic victory,” said Kenneth E. Warner, a professor of public health at the University of Michigan.
It however is “very encouraging” to see the FDA exerting its authority.
Bidis are not widely used in United States, he said, and Jash International is “an easy target, because it’s not a major tobacco company.”
The FDA cannot ban nicotine, but it does have the authority to lower nicotine to non-addicting levels.