November 20, 2026

Experts differ on ex-im paperwork time

IFC says regulatory procedures in Bangladesh eat away 80 percent time but local businesses and regulators dismiss the claim.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 21 May 2012, 12:56 PM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 03:48 PM

Dhaka, May 21 (bdnews24.com)—A World Bank Group report contends regulatory procedures in Bangladesh eat away 80 percent time of import and export within SAARC but experts and business leaders contested the claim. International Finance Corporation's (IFC) Senior Trade Specialist William J Gain said Bangladesh took 31 days to import and 25 days to export which was at least one and a half times more than India. Eighty percent of the time is consumed by documents for regulatory formalities, the trade specialist ofthe private sector lending arm of the World Bank Group said at a roundtable in Dhaka on Monday. However, business leaders and regulators who attended roundtable organised by the Policy Research Institute of Bangladesh (PRI) and IFC differed with the claim. They also identified inconsistency in the analysis of the statistics. According to the findings, Bangladesh needs six documents to export while India needs eight documents. But it said Bangladesh takes 25 days to export while India needs 16 days. It says Bangladesh needs eight documents for import in 31 days while India needs nine documents and does the job in 20 days. "If I analyse the data, I think the problem is not here (preparing documents), it lies elsewhere, maybe in infrastructure or other things," Ashikur Rahman, Senior Economist at PRI, said at the roundtable. A customs commissioner, Saiful Islam, said it took one to two days for import and only a day for export clearance provided all valid papers were available. He questioned the method of estimating the time lapse. Chairman of Bangladesh Tariff Commission Dr Md Moziubur Rahman said in his last three years in office, he had attended at least a dozen similar seminars where same set of data were analysed and same set of recommendations were made, but in different ways. "I think you should revisit the data." An advisor to the apex business body FBCCI, Monjur Ahmed, also criticised the recommendations made by the IFC specialist. f "They should produce research-based analysis," he suggested. While presenting the data, Gain put forward 17 recommendations to ease access to regional markets. One of the recommendations was creating an appropriate group to lead the reform programme with support from the Trade Logistics Advisory Team and IFC country office in Dhaka. He said a 10 percent reduction in export time would increase export of South Asia by 5.8 percent. As intraregional trade among SAARC countries is less than 2 percent of GDP compared to more than 20 percent in East Asia, he said South Asia is one of the 'least integrated' regions in the world. "But there are potentials to improve the trade." When approached by bdnews24.com, Gain declined comment on the data analysis. "It's World Bank Group's findings. I'll not comment," he said. The World Bank Group's trade logistics team is implementing a regional trade facilitation project to reduce time and cost to trade and increase regional cooperation to improve cross-border movement of goods in the South Asia Region, focusing on Nepal, Bangladesh and eastern India. The project aims to help simplify and harmonise of border clearance procedures, introduce risk management, enhance automation, and conduct regional peer-to-peer events to promote regional cooperation. Jatiya Party MP Anisul Islam Mahmud, who was present as chief guest, said barring food products, other goods usually do not need much time to import and export. "Food products take time for different certifications," he said. Look within Mahmud, a former foreign minister, however, advocated bolstering relationship with neighbouring India. He took a swipe at the India critiques and said: "We import from India as we get products cheaper there. It's not because we favour them. At the same time, I cannot force export, if our products do not have demand in India." "Don't blame India. We can do well if we have good understanding with India," he said. In 2010-2011 India exported $ 4.5 billion to Bangladesh while the latter could export only $ 512 million. The figure was $ 3.2 billion and $ 302 million in 2009-2010. He said the debate should be whether India is fair or unfair in imposing tariff and non-tariff barriers and suggested looking into the non-tariff barriers as there was no problem with tariff barriers now. "We have BSTI. But we don't trust it. When we don't trust our own testing institute, how will other countries trust it?" he asked. "I have to ensure that it is standard," he said, 'fault lies with us, so let us understand the fault first." He said, "We have simplified our systems quite a lot and even our banks give us good services. If we don't have electricity, gas supply, how we will be able to attract investment," he said emphasising supply-side infrastructure. Deputy Managing Director of Pran Group Ahsan Chowdhury pointed out that a lack of functional ports was hampering trade facilitation. "We have 126 land ports of which 18 ports are functional for trade," he said, "but those are not in a shape to handle big volume of trade." "For instance", he said, "If we want to export worth Tk 2 billion to India in a month, we will need to send 5,000 trucks But the highest capacity of our major land ports are 2000 trucks a month." He added facilitating trade through different ports can increase business with different states of India. "Each and every state of India has different potentials like Bangladesh," he said. Dr M Rahmatullah, a transport expert said, said infrastructure was the key to facilitating trade. "We have no connectivity with northeast India as there is no functional rail connection," he said. "Even our roads are in poor shape." bdnews24.com/nih/bd/1813h
Related Stories