Published :
28 Jan 2013, 01:38 PM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 10:09 AM
Jamaat’s chief defence counsel Abdur Razzaq ended his part saying that the court should find Delwar Hossain Sayedee “not guilty of all 19 charges”.
Also an Assistant Secretary General of the Islamist party, Razzaq said that the prosecution had failed to prove any of its charges.
“It has failed to prove the elements of crime. And since the investigator’s credibility has been destroyed, the case has also been destroyed.”
The three-judge International Crimes Tribunal-1, set up to try crimes against humanity during the 1971 Liberation War, indicted the Jamaat executive council member for 20 war crimes charges on Oct 3.
His charges include murder, rape, arson and loot in and around Sayedee’s native Pirojpur’s Parerhat area.
The tribunal decided to hear the closing argument a second time after the former Chairman stepped down following a controversy while the defence filed for retrial.
Besides Jamaat’s allegation of collusion between the former Chairman and the prosecution, it was also pointed out that with the resignation of Justice Nizamul Huq, the Chairman, there was no judge left who had heard the entire case.
The tribunal had at first given the prosecution two days and the defence three days to complete their arguments. However, although the defence was supposed to finish summing up the case by the end of Jan 23 it was allowed to run for almost three extra days.
Abdur Razzaq spoke on legal points until around 3:30pm on Monday followed by Prosecutor Syed Haider Ali who came up to counter the points of his Jamaat counterparts.
At the very onset, tribunal Chairman Justice ATM Fazle Kabir said the judges would like the prosecutor to answer how it establishes that Sayedee was a member of the local Peace Committee and the Razakar unit.
The Razakar, along with Al Badr, Al Shams and Al Mujaheed, were vigilante militia groups allegedly mobilised by the Jamaat-e-Islami and other right wing parties who opposed Bangladesh’s independence and backed Pakistan during the Liberation War.
The Peace Committee is said to have been a social front of their fight against the liberation effort.
Over the last few days, Abdur Razzaq has largely reiterated the points he made the last time. He argued over the last few days that the law under which Sayedee was being tried was meant to try army officers and not collaborators for whom there was a separate Collaborators Order of 1972.
The senior lawyer also argued that the government had forgiven — 195 Pakistani officers identified to have committed crimes against humanity in the early 1970’s through the Simla Agreement — the principal offenders and could not now go after the alleged accomplices.
The chief defence counsel of Jamaat also pointed to the elements of crimes against humanity and said the prosecution had not at all established whether Sayedee’s crimes were part of an organised, widespread and systematic attack on a certain group and whether the accused had knowledge that his alleged crimes were part of a larger picture of persecution of a certain group.
Prosecutor Haider Ali is expected to conclude countering Razzaq on Tuesday following which the tribunal will fix a date for verdict. Thus far, however, both the first and second tribunals have refrained from fixing dates for judgement and merely said that the judges required further time to consider the matter.
The standard order at the conclusion of trials has been “Judgement CAV”. CAV, or curia advisari vult, is a Latin term literally meaning ‘court requires further assistance’.
There has been one judgement so far. Abul Kalam Azad, tried in absentia, was given a single death sentence for six charges including murder, rape, abduction, confinement and torture. He was acquitted of one charge.
Another case – of Jamaat Assistant Secretary General Abdul Quader Mollah — still awaits verdict. Sayedee’s case had been wrapped up earlier on Dec 6 and the tribunal had kept the judgement pending.