Published : 21 Sep 2025, 08:14 AM
Updated : 28 Aug 2026, 01:27 AM
Tahidul Alam spent almost his entire adult life in Mumbai. He had gone there as a young man in search of work, taking his newlywed wife with him. In that bustling city, they had two children -- a boy and a girl -- and over 46 years, they became part of the fabric of local life.
But the world they had built unravelled in weeks. After the May attack on tourists in Kashmir’s Pahalgam renewed India–Pakistan tensions, and a steady souring of India–Bangladesh relations, Mumbai police arrived at their home without warning.
The family were detained and never allowed to return to their flat.
Held for weeks, they were eventually transported to Agartala in Tripura state and handed to the Border Security Force (BSF).
At dawn on Jun 26, the BSF marched Tahidul, his wife Hajara Khatun, son Shoaib and daughter Shabnam to the Joarkachar border in Feni and pushed them across into Bangladesh.
Border Guards Bangladesh (BGB) immediately detained them and turned them over to police.
Officers contacted relatives in their ancestral village of Purbo Maizbhandar in Chattogram’s Fatikchhari, who came to take them home.
Under Indian law, anyone arrested must be produced before a court within 24 hours. Tahidul says they never saw a judge, nor were they given any legal recourse.
Rights activists call these mass expulsions a blatant breach of international law. The Indian authorities, they say, are unmoved.
Since May, the BSF has been detaining Bengali-speaking residents -- not only Bangladeshis but also Indian citizens -- from states as far apart as Maharashtra, Gujarat, Rajasthan, Haryana, Kerala and West Bengal, and sending them across the border.
Indian media have reported the existence of detention camps for “illegal immigrants”.
Exact numbers are elusive. Indian officials have said nothing. The BGB, however, has counted 1,880 people forced over between May 7 and Jul 3, at 22 border points.
The largest numbers came via Moulvibazar and Sylhet; smaller flows through Naogaon, Brahmanbaria and Kushtia.
Some of those pushed in were born in India. West Bengal’s Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee has accused BJP-ruled states of targeting Muslims. The matter has reached Indian courts.
The BSF has even returned Myanmar nationals, the Rohingya, to Bangladesh, about 200 of them.
Dhaka has lodged formal protests with New Delhi, but the expulsions continue. In some Indian border districts, more Bengali-speaking residents are being gathered for deportation.
For the returnees, life is stripped bare. Whatever cash, documents or belongings they had in India are gone. Many jobless and penniless people cannot find work in Bangladesh.
On May 23, nine members of two related families from Kurigram’s Bhurungamari were pushed in through the Sonahat border. The men, Ziaur and Abdul Jalil, and their wives had gone to India 22 years earlier, working at a brick kiln in Rajasthan. They had married and raised children there.
On May 3, police detained them along with 70–75 other Bengali speakers.
After 22 days in custody, they endured a nine-hour bus ride, then were flown to a Guwahati airbase in Assam and handed to the BSF.
The two women recall that their plane carried around 200 Bengali-speaking men, women and children, bussed to the border in four convoys. They do not know what became of the others.
In Fulbari, Nabi Hossain and his family were expelled on May 27 after two decades in India, part of it in a detention camp.
Others are now turning themselves in voluntarily, fearing arrest.
Hassen Ali, who had worked for 20 years at a brick kiln in Haryana’s Bawari district, fled with his family after security forces raided the site and took many Bengali-speaking workers to unknown locations. Travelling for three days by train, he surrendered at a BSF camp, joining dozens of others.
After confirming their identities with the BGB, the BSF handed 24 people -- men, women and children -- through Fulbari’s Balatari border on May 24.
Three days later, 17 more were forced across at Gomostapur in Chapainawabganj. They had lived in Haryana for 10–12 years; all were from Fulbari in Kurigram.
One, Bulu Chandra Sen, says: “The Modi government will not let Bangladeshis stay. They harassed us. So we surrendered to the Delhi police. From Howrah’s Kuchber station they bused us to a BSF camp.
“At 11.30pm on May 27, they pushed us across the border. In the dark, we sat huddled until morning, when local fishermen ferried us across the river to the BGB.”
Others have evaded official channels, like Sirajul Islam, a resident of Dashiarchhara, who slipped past BSF controls with his family.
“I came to India a decade ago. We lived and worked without problems. Suddenly, the authorities tightened controls and wouldn’t let us stay. We had to flee, or face jail,” he said.
Tajul Islam, Manob Ali, and Abdul Qader from nearby areas escaped similarly.
On May 31, BGB arrested 11 people, including women and children, crossing illegally near Sherpur’s Nalitabari border. A BGB official said they caught the group suspiciously roaming in hilly terrain inside Bangladesh near Panihata at dawn. The group claimed they had come to see the hills, but gave conflicting statements.
After interrogation, they admitted to being from different areas in Narail and Khulna districts and having entered Bangladesh illegally from India. Indian rupees, two mobile phones, and SIM cards were seized.
HUNDREDS STILL DETAINED
While some families have breathed a sigh of relief after safely returning to Bangladesh, anxiety runs deep among relatives of hundreds still detained in Indian police stations and detention centres. They are urging swift government intervention for their safe repatriation.
Almina, daughter of Afzal, said Indian police arrested seven members of her family, including her father, on the day after Eid-ul-Fitr from Munna Bhagji Bhata, under the Rampura Police Station in Haryana.
“We have had no news of them since. We don’t know what fate has befallen them.”
At the home of Chan Mia, son of Salimuddin from Bakbanda village, Roumari Upazila, his wife Monwara Begum broke down recounting their plight.
Chan Mia is the sole breadwinner of their six-member family, working as a fisherman.
In early November last year, while fishing in the Kalapani River in Assam, Chan was detained by the BSF near Kalayerchar.
Later, the BSF handed him over to the Mahendraganj police in India, who imprisoned him in Dhubri district jail. He was released in April and told his family by phone about his detention and that he was being held near the border, awaiting pushback.
But since then, he has not returned, leaving his family deeply worried.
Residents of Dasiarchhara say over a hundred from their community, including Shahjahan Ali, Erina Begum, Mohammad Ali, and Swapna Begum, are trapped in India after leaving for work. Their families await word of their whereabouts.
Abdul Mannan, former UP member of the Dasiarcharra enclave, said although some families returned after the enclave’s integration into Bangladesh, over a hundred remain in Delhi, Haryana, and other Indian areas.
Abdul Mannan, former UP member of the Dasiarchhara enclave, said although some families returned after the enclave’s integration into Bangladesh, over a hundred remain in Delhi, Haryana, and other Indian areas.
While many travelled to India through brokers with their families seeking work, many were caught on entry and sent directly to jail. Others who had earned for years were detained on their return trips, losing everything and enduring harsh jail life with spouses and children.
Yet, most poor workers continue to toil in brick kilns in fear. Harun Or Rashid, chairman of Fulbari Union Parishad, explained that 20–25 years ago, the porous enclave borders enabled many to settle in India without returning. But now, due to changed conditions, many willingly surrender to authorities for return. Those who return undergo identity verification before being sent home.
Rehnuma Taranmum, executive officer of Fulbari Upazila, said those returning have homes in Bangladesh. If anyone is jobless or helpless, they will be enrolled in social safety programmes.
Rohingya refugee Zahed Alam, expelled by India’s BSF, accused the force of confiscating his money, documents, and belongings, leaving them destitute.
Speaking from Kutupalong camp in Cox’s Bazar, Zahed said: “We had some money, clothes, and prison documents from India, but the BSF took everything and sent us here with just one set of clothes.”
Zahed said the family fled Myanmar in the early 1990s, registering as Rohingya refugees in Kutupalong. He later went to India for throat treatment but stayed there after recovery.
In 2017, amid a renewed influx of Rohingya refugees, Zahed and 30 others attempted to return to Bangladesh from India. At Agartala, Indian police detained them as Myanmar nationals and held them as “guests” for nearly seven years, repeatedly assuring eventual repatriation.
Zahed recalled, “Indian police said the situation in Myanmar was unstable and kept us detained, promising to send us back once conditions improved. We protested and went on hunger strikes for release.”
Eventually, India agreed to deport them via an unofficial route, without informing them of the border crossing point.
“We were taken from prison to a police station and then driven to the border at night. We had no idea where we were going,” Zahed said.
At 1:30am, the BSF opened the gate on the Bangladesh side, pushed them across, and warned that any return attempts would be met with gunfire.
Zahed said, “Once we crossed, we faced no obstruction. We changed vehicles several times and reached the refugee camp without seeing police or BGB officers.”
Now living with his sister’s family in Kutupalong camp, Zahed struggles without official registration.
In total, 31 Rohingya were deported to the camp with him.
The Office of the Refugee Relief and Repatriation Commissioner says over 200 Rohingya have been pushed back from India, many holding UNHCR refugee cards.
Asked whether India’s actions violate the law or if international measures can be taken, Commissioner Mohammed Mizanur Rahman said: “That is the foreign ministry’s responsibility.”
He noted, “Since Rohingya are Myanmar nationals, pushing them back to Myanmar is logical. Sending them back to Bangladesh is not.”
Mizanur added the UN could act, “UNHCR cardholders coming here is their responsibility. I don’t know what action they have taken.”
He said when the BGB pushes the Rohingya back to Myanmar, the UN writes letters to Bangladesh, which implies concern over those pushed back from India, too.
‘BANGLADESH NEVER WENT TO INTERNATIONAL COURT’
Rights Jessore, an NGO working with undocumented migrants between India and Bangladesh, provides legal aid to those arrested or sentenced for illegal entry.
Binay Krishna Mallick, its organisation's executive director, said the Border Control Act exists to prevent pushbacks, but the BSF violates this law by forcibly pushing people back.
He explained that legal deportation requires verification through the high commission, confirmation via the home ministry’s Sashastra Seema Bal report, and issuance of travel passes by the foreign ministry. Without these steps, the process breaches the law.
Despite opportunities, Bangladesh has never approached an international court over pushbacks, Mallick said. He added that India does not push back many people at once, usually just five to 10 individuals at intervals, which complicates any legal case internationally.
Mallick said he is unaware of any confirmed “pushback” cases so far.
International law lacks a precise definition of “pushback” or “push-in”, but it generally violates the principle of non-refoulement, which forbids sending individuals to countries where their life or freedom would be at risk.
Article 33(1) of the 1951 Refugee Convention enshrines this principle, also reflected in other human rights treaties.
Pushback involves deporting people without due legal process, directly contradicting this fundamental norm.
The European Convention on Human Rights, Protocol 4, Article 4, prohibits the collective expulsion of refugees.
Human rights groups Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch have repeatedly condemned South Asia’s pushback practices as severe violations, pointing to legal breaches and the risk of rendering people stateless.
A 2018 Human Rights Watch report said India’s pushback policy violates international law and endangers individuals with statelessness.
bdnews24.com’s requests for comment from the Indian High Commission went unanswered.
[Reporting by Dhaka’s Prashanta Mitra, Kurigram Correspondent Ahsan Habib Nilu, Chapainawabganj Correspondent Abul Hayat Shahin, Sherpur Correspondent Abdur Rahim Badal, Cox’s Bazar Correspondent Sourav Deb; Writing in English by Syed Mahmud Onindo]