Published : 31 Oct 2024, 07:46 AM
Updated : 28 Aug 2026, 01:13 AM
The investigative and judicial processes face risks following attacks, arson, and looting at police stations across Bangladesh, where case files were either destroyed or lost.
Although some documents may be recoverable from other official locations, crucial evidence may still be missing, which experts say could jeopardise fair trials.
Copies of case files are stored not only at police stations but also at local circle offices and courts.
While these can be retrieved, doing so is time-consuming, labour-intensive, and incurs additional costs. The most significant issue impacting justice is the loss of evidence.
Most evidence items stored at police stations and nearby locations have either been stolen or destroyed, leaving no answers for those whose valuable assets, such as cars or motorbikes, are missing.
Experts have expressed concerns regarding the future of numerous cases.
Supreme Court lawyer Barrister Jyotirmoy Barua told bdnews24.com: “The core issue is the confiscated evidence in cases. This could delay proceedings, lead to varied investigative conclusions, and potentially deny victims fair trials.”
He said: “While investigators can often re-interview witnesses or recreate scenes, material evidence, such as a blood-stained knife in a murder case, poses a problem. Without it, what will the court be shown?”
Following the Aug 5 anti-government protests that led to the ousting of the Awami League administration, violent clashes erupted between police and protesters, resulting in widespread attacks on police stations and outposts. Several police vehicles were set ablaze, while weapons and ammunition were looted amid the unrest.
Police stations under Dhaka Metropolitan Police, or DMP, have been among the hardest hit, with 22 out of 50 stations suffering significant damage.
Key stations, such as Jatrabari, Shyampur, Mohammadpur, Adabar, Badda, Bhatara, Khilgaon, Paltan, Khilkhet, Sher-e-Bangla Nagar, Tejgaon Industrial, and Wari, have been left in ruins.
At least 16 police outposts have also been attacked, with numerous traffic boxes damaged. Almost every affected police station has seen furniture, computers, and records burnt or stolen. This destruction has forced many investigations to restart, requiring new efforts to gather documents and collect witness statements.
Hasan Md Shaukat Ali, DMP’s additional police commissioner (logistics, finance, and procurement), told bdnews24.com: “We are still estimating the amount of lost or destroyed case files and other documents from the affected stations.”
On the impact of these incidents on investigations and trials, former police chief Nurul Huda said the absence of evidence would certainly complicate proceedings.
“While it’s possible to continue the investigations, as many records were stored in systems, some cases may face complications. Material evidence may not be recoverable, but we can proceed with alternative steps,” he said.
Huda also emphasised the need for special initiatives to expedite the reconstruction of destroyed documents.
“We need to reconstruct the case files and inform the court about those that cannot be salvaged,” he added.
Regarding the challenge of recovering destroyed documents, Huda said: “The status of a case determines the recovery process. Copies of cases are stored at police stations and sent to magistrates as first information reports, or FIRs. Copies of diary reports are also available at circle offices, making it possible to recover these through investigations.”
THE CHALLENGES OF OBTAINING DUPLICATES
A sub-inspector recently transferred from a police station in Dhaka to the Rajshahi Range shared his experiences regarding the bureaucratic hurdles.
“Before a transfer, all officers must hand over their case responsibilities to another officer. For the cases whose papers were burnt, we had to visit the court to obtain the records. The case copies are preserved at the court, from where I collected the required documents,” he explained.
When asked about the difficulties in gathering these documents, he said: “There are costs associated with photocopying and the travel expenses, along with the additional hassle of multiple officers searching for the same documents at court, resulting in delays and queues. This has required extra time and effort, not to mention added expenses.”
The current Khilgaon Police Station chief Md Daud Hossain, said: “Recovering a document incurs time, effort, and costs. For instance, if a case file has been burnt, I now need to go to the court to find the PR (personal record) of the accused, and based on that, I have to locate the case documents.”
Police officials said some documents, including the case summary, are stored in the Criminal Database Management System, or CDMS, which can be retrieved from the court.
However, many details regarding evidence, seizure lists, and other critical information remain with the investigating officer at the police station.
These are essential for presenting cases or bringing in witnesses, and unfinished investigations will encounter difficulties in concluding.
Barrister Jyotirmoy said: “Case copies are usually sent to the court within 24 hours, and they can be obtained from the GR section. However, various pieces of evidence related to case dockets remain with the investigating officer, which poses a risk.”
ANOTHER TROUBLE: OFFICER TRANSFER
In a case involving the theft of nearly Tk 400,000 worth of goods from his business establishment in Khilgaon, Zafar Ahmed filed a lawsuit in Dhaka on May 18.
He named fugitive employees Arman Molla and Abir Molla as defendants.
Expressing his frustration over the lack of progress in the investigation, Zafar told bdnews24.com: “I have visited the homes of the accused several times upon the police's advice, but they have not arrested anyone. Out of options, I had decided to approach the Detective Branch. Just before that, this trouble began.”
He added, “Since then, there has been no update on the investigation. In the meantime, the on-duty Sub-Inspector called me to say that a charge sheet would be filed. I heard he will be transferred elsewhere. After that, I haven't heard anything. I’m thinking of visiting the officer in charge to see what happens.”
Despite the claimant’s uncertainty, the investigating officer, SI Abdur Rahim Mia, said that he submitted the case report to the court. He has been transferred from Khilgaon Police Station to the Sylhet Armed Police Battalion, or APBn.
The officer said, “We have conducted numerous operations to apprehend the accused but have failed. I later informed the claimant that I would leave after filing the charge sheet. Filing the charge sheet would be beneficial for the claimant, as summons will be issued by the court. Therefore, based on my investigation, I submitted a charge sheet accusing both individuals.”
He clarified that many of the documents that had been burnt were stored on servers, and they had to retrieve reports from the medical department as well.
“We have managed to recover information from all cases,” he added.
However, he acknowledged that while documents were recovered, evidence was not completely intact, saying: “Some evidence will never be found, and the court is also aware of this. Although it may take some time, there will be no issue with the investigation.”
In connection with the attack, looting, and arson at Khilgaon Police Station, SI Mohammad Golap Uddin Mahmud has filed a case against 5000 to 7000 unknown individuals. The report indicates that 342 pieces of evidence were lost.
This loss of evidence could disrupt the investigation and prosecution of around three hundred cases.
According to the complaint, 96 firearms were among those looted that could not be recovered, and approximately 11,000 bullets are also missing.
OC Daud said, “We are recovering the lost documents from the court and various sources. We have started anew for the registrars that were lost or destroyed. However, evidence cannot be recovered.”
He claimed that these issues would not impede the investigation of the cases.
When asked about the difference in the number of reports submitted to the court before and after the protests, he replied: “It’s not possible to specify a set number. The process has continued according to the number of cases being filed. All activities are normal; cases are ongoing, investigations are underway, and we are filing charge sheets as investigations conclude.”
WHAT WILL HAPPEN TO THE EVIDENCE?
This question remains unanswered by the police.
A sub-inspector transferred from Khilgaon to the Barishal Range said, “I have handed over the recovered documents related to my cases. However, many pieces of evidence, including motorcycles, were left at the station, which may have been burnt or looted. We do not know what will happen to them.”
OC Daud said, “As of now, no one has contacted us individually regarding the burnt evidence. We have informed the court about the situation, and measures will be taken according to the court's directives.”
DMP's Additional Commissioner (crime and operations) Md Israel Hawladar told bdnews24.com: “We are filing a case at each police station regarding the destruction of case documents and evidence, along with the attacks and looting. Other cases are ongoing. There is usually an alternative provision for case documents, so there shouldn't be much issue with that. However, evidence such as vehicles and motorcycles has been destroyed and cannot be retrieved. We have informed the court about this.”
When asked whether the change in investigating officers would hinder the investigations into cases with lost documents and evidence, he said: “There will be some issues, but we are looking into how to manage this. Overall, we are taking all necessary legal measures to prevent complications.”
[Writing in English by Arshi Fatiha Quazi]