What are the options for Palestine?
The Palestinian Liberation Organisation (PLO) will go before the United Nations on Friday to apply for full statehood at the international body.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
23 Sep 2011, 12:57 PM
Updated :
10 Aug 2022, 05:30 PM
Dhaka, Sep 22 (bdnews24.com) — The Palestinian Liberation Organisation (PLO) will go before the United Nations on Friday to apply for full statehood at the international body.
Aljazeera on Thursday published an analysis of the different courses of action that the nation could take, and their various possible outcomes.
Strategy 1: Go before the security council for full UN membership
Requirements:
To become a state, at least nine of the 15 members of the security council will have to vote for the resolution, with no vetoes from the council's five permanent members. After that, the council would recommend Palestine for UN membership at the general assembly. Two-thirds of the assembly, or 129 countries, must then vote in favour. The process is longer, because it involves applications, committee meetings and deliberations.
Success:
The Obama administration has vowed to veto a security council recommendation for Palestinian statehood. Without this recommendation, the general assembly is not empowered to allow Palestine a full UN membership.
However, such a veto can be overthrown through the 'Uniting for Peace' resolution, or Resolution 337. The resolution permits collective action in order to maintain international peace and security, if the security council is crippled by a veto. If the case is made that obstructing Palestine's statehood would threaten international security, the general assembly could invoke Resolution 337 by two-thirds of the Assembly vote.
Then, the general assembly would have to vote again - also by a two-thirds majority - to accept Palestine as a full member state.
Strategy 2: Go to the general assembly to gain the status of a 'UN non-member observer state'
Requirements:
Since 1988, the UN has categorised Palestine under the heading "Entities Having Received a Standing Invitation to Participate as Observers in the Sessions and the Work of the General Assembly and Maintaining Permanent Observer Missions at Headquarters".
This approach would mean requesting the general assembly to replace the word "Entity" with "State" in the categorisation above.
Palestine would therefore be on a list of observer states. At the moment, the Holy See is the only observer state at the UN.
This upgrading from "Entity" to "State" would allow the Palestinians to join several international organisations and sign onto human rights treaties. The power of the upgrade would be dependent on the exact text of any such resolution.
Success:
The advantage of this strategy is that it would require only a simple majority of the 193-nation general assembly. Abbas said on Sep 16 that more than 126 states already recognise the state of Palestine, meaning that the PLO could probably win such a vote easily.
Strategy 3: Request the general assembly to adopt a resolution 'recommending' the recognition of Palestinian statehood based on 1967 borders
The UN routinely passes such resolutions, for example, it has already passed several resolutions on Palestinians' right to self-determination, their right of return and for changes to Israel's settlement policies.
This option would not significantly advance Palestine on the path to statehood; however, it would help to further highlight the Palestinian cause.
It is unlikely that the PLO would decide to withdraw its bid, but could take place if the US, Israel or certain European countries can convince the PLO at the last minute to pull back from any UN effort. US state department has said that it is engaged very intensively upon such negotiations.
bdnews24.com/sh/bd/1846h