November 21, 2026

Wal-Mart's early holiday blitz pressures rivals

Like death and taxes, holiday season price cuts by Wal-Mart are inevitable, but this year the big retailer's US rivals may find it even tougher to avoid a profit-crunching price war.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 15 Nov 2006, 06:00 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 06:51 PM

CHICAGO/NEW YORK, November 16 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - Like death and taxes, holiday season price cuts by Wal-Mart are inevitable, but this year the big retailer's US rivals may find it even tougher to avoid a profit-crunching price war. Companies that successfully compete with Wal-Mart Stores Inc, the world's biggest retailer, have long since learned to focus on convenience, service, selection or style, rather than trying to go head-to-head on price. But nerves often fray during the holiday shopping season, which typically accounts for one-fourth of annual sales, and rival executives have been known to panic when sales are sluggish and start slashing prices. Wal-Mart began marking down prices in October this year, much earlier than usual, and it has added more name-brand goods to its arsenal, which may make it even tougher for competitors to stick to their pricing plans. "Wal-Mart is going for the holiday jugular, going right after toys and electronics and small appliances," said Richard Hastings, an analyst at Bernard Sands, a company that rates US retailers. Hastings said Wal-Mart's aggressive discounts in those holiday gift categories piled pressure on rivals such as Target Corp, Bed Bath & Beyond Inc, Sears Holdings Corp, Toys 'R' Us, Circuit City Stores Inc and Best Buy Co Inc. Most chains declined to comment on a competitor's strategy, but Target executives called Wal-Mart's price-cutting campaign "business as usual", and said it would respond aggressively. The day after Thanksgiving -- known as Black Friday because it used to mark the date when retailers turned a profit for the year -- is still seen as the traditional start to the holiday shopping season. But Wal-Mart and others have begun advertising earlier and earlier, hoping to lure customers before the last-minute clearance sales, which tend to generate smaller profits. For holiday shoppers, fierce competition means bigger bargains, and this year's Black Friday sales shouldn't disappoint. Several Web sites have posted advance copies of sales circulars -- much to the dismay of retailers, who will not verify their authenticity. Goldman Sachs analyst Matthew Fassler said a review of Black Friday ads showed Wal-Mart's 42-inch plasma TV for $988 among the best deals, although Best Buy had the lowest price on a 32-inch LCD model and Circuit City was not far behind. Wal-Mart's price cuts appear to be getting consumers' attention. A holiday shopping survey of 1,000 adults by America's Research Group between Nov 8 and Nov 10 found that 89 percent planned to shop at Wal-Mart. Some 72 percent planned to go there for electronics. Wall Street has been watching anxiously to see whether electronics chains Circuit City and Best Buy would flinch after Wal-Mart announced steep markdowns on hot items such as Panasonic plasma televisions. Panasonic is a key brand for Wal-Mart because it has consistently ranked among the top-rated for plasma televisions in the influential Consumer Reports magazine. Carter Cast, chief executive officer of Walmart.com, told Reuters in a recent telephone interview that those larger Panasonic plasma TVs were selling particularly well online, singling out the 50-inch model that costs $2,348. Wal-Mart has a lot riding on this holiday season. The retailer posted back-to-back months of disappointing sales growth in September and October, and has forecast flat sales at its US stores open at least a year in November. If sales remain sluggish in December, fourth-quarter profits would likely suffer. Wal-Mart has remained optimistic that its aggressive discounts will draw people to its stores this holiday season. Its first set of discounts in October focused on toys, which are a perennial holiday-season target. "It's not 'if', it's a matter of 'when'" Wal-Mart will lower toy prices, said BMO Capital Markets toy analyst Gerrick Johnson. Wal-Mart is the largest toy seller in the United States, and several of its rivals have either gone bankrupt or private. The biggest competitor in the industry, Toys 'R' Us, will likely aim to beat Wal-Mart with a wider selection, while staying as close as possible on price. Johnson said rival toy retailers tend to do well later in the holiday season because Wal-Mart often runs out of the hottest items early. But this year, Wal-Mart has gone out of its way to stress that it intends to have adequate supplies. The retailer even released a tongue-in-cheek press release quoting 'sources close to Elmo' promising to do whatever it takes to keep the hot TMX Elmo doll in stock. "I think it's worrisome for the other guys if Wal-Mart keeps these price cuts in place and then also has good selection and in-stock levels on toys," Johnson said. Still, Wal-Mart's Cast acknowledged that it will be tough to keep especially popular items on the shelves. "There's a few cases where there's just not enough manufacturing availability in the market -- like PlayStation 3 or Nintendo's Wii or Tickle Me Elmo, I think all retailers are in the same boat there," he said. bdnews24.com/mhb/srs/1820 hrs
Related Stories