November 21, 2026

US frets over Afghan graft, Karzai: WikiLeaks

The US envoy to Afghanistan calls President Hamid Karzai a "paranoid," "weak" and "overly self-conscious" leader who may never stop America-bashing, in the latest US diplomatic cables made public on Thursday.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 03 Dec 2010, 12:46 PM

Updated : 24 Apr 2022, 05:49 PM

WASHINGTON, Dec 3 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - The US envoy to Afghanistan calls President Hamid Karzai a "paranoid," "weak" and "overly self-conscious" leader who may never stop America-bashing, in the latest US diplomatic cables made public on Thursday. The disclosure of the private comments by Karl Eikenberry in documents released by the WikiLeaks website could add strain to Washington's already tense relationship with Kabul, nine years into an unpopular war that critics say cannot be won. Both governments have so far played down any impact of previously released cables on their relationship -- which analysts say is born of necessity, not choice. It was unclear whether the latest revelations will do any obvious damage, despite the blunt remarks by the US envoy. In one document, Eikenberry accuses Karzai of failing to grasp the "most rudimentary principles of state-building." "And his deep seated insecurity as a leader combine to make any admission of fault unlikely, in turn confounding our best efforts to find in Karzai a responsible partner," Eikenberry wrote in a July 2009 cable detailed by The New York Times. State corruption was portrayed as the norm. A January cable detailing the likely lineup of Karzai's new cabinet described the agriculture minister as "the only minister that was confirmed about whom no allegations of bribery exist." The New York Times and Britain's The Guardian newspaper are among the media outlets given advanced access by WikiLeaks to over 250,000 diplomatic cables. Both newspapers focused on Thursday on deep U.S. anxiety over the partnership with Kabul. The Afghan government brushed off a similar dump of leaked U.S. cables on Monday, with Karzai's spokesman saying they would not strain ties with Washington. Those cables also included disparaging portrayals of the Afghan leader. Around 1,400 U.S. soldiers have died in the fighting since the war began in late 2001. The U.S. strategy rests on creating enough security so the Afghan state can win the loyalty of the people, who otherwise could turn to the Taliban movement. The latest documents, like the earlier ones, included accusations about Karzai's half-brother, Ahmad Wali Karzai (AWK), who has been linked to Afghanistan's booming drug trade and is a major power broker in the southern city of Kandahar. "The meeting with AWK highlights one of our major challenges in Afghanistan: how to fight corruption and connect the people to their government, when the key government officials are themselves corrupt," Eikenberry wrote in October 2009. Ahmad Wali Karzai has strongly denied any involvement with narcotics and the Afghan president says the accusations against his half-brother have never been proven. PARANOID, WEAK The Guardian detailed a cable in which Eikenberry identified two competing personalities in Karzai. "The first is a paranoid and weak individual unfamiliar with the basics of nation-building and overly self-conscious that his time in the spotlight of glowing reviews from the international community has passed," Eikenberry wrote. He said Karzai was also an "ever-shrewd politician who sees himself as a nationalist hero." Eikenberry wrote it was unclear whether Karzai would ever refrain from a "blame America" tactic he uses to deflect criticism of his administration. The envoy describes trying to "refocus" Karzai away from his "anti-U.S. conspiracy theories" in conversations. Questions about weak governance and corruption have long driven a wedge between Karzai and many of the Western leaders who have nearly 150,000 soldiers in Afghanistan but many of the faults highlighted in the U.S. documents are well known. Afghanistan ranked 176th, ahead of only Somalia, in Transparency International's corruption index issued last month. The Pentagon, in a report to the U.S. Congress, noted there was a "questionable" commitment by Kabul to prosecuting corruption. The Times quoted a former Afghan vice president denying accusations in one of the cables that he flew to the United Arab Emirates with $52 million in cash. "Yet while his official salary was a few hundred dollars a month, (he) lives in a waterfront house on Palm Jumeirah, a luxury Dubai community that is also home to other Afghan officials," the Times wrote. Eikenberry reported "vast amounts of cash come and go from the country on a weekly, monthly and annual basis," according to the Guardian. Before last year's presidential election, some $600 million in banking system withdrawals were reported. Another cable detailed how the transportation ministry collects $200 million a year in trucking fees but only $30 million is turned over to the government -- information sourced to a former Afghan commerce minister. "Individuals pay up to $250,000 for the post heading the office in Herat, for example, and end up owning beautiful mansions as well as making lucrative political donations," Wahidullah Shahrani, now the mines minister, was quoted as saying. bdnews24.com/lq/1847h.
Related Stories