November 21, 2026

UK government under fire over paedophile's release

A British judge freed a convicted paedophile on Thursday partly because the government warned that prisons were too full, igniting a political firecracker over law-and-order under Prime Minister Tony Blair's government.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 26 Jan 2007, 06:32 AM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 02:17 PM

LONDON, January 26 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - A British judge freed a convicted paedophile on Thursday partly because the government warned that prisons were too full, igniting a political firecracker over law-and-order under Prime Minister Tony Blair's government. Home Secretary John Reid had already drawn attacks from right-wing mass-circulation newspapers for writing to judges to warn of overcrowding and urge light sentences for non-violent offenders. "John Reid's brain is missing", the Sun, Britain's biggest- selling daily said in Thursday's front-page headline. That was before a senior judge said Reid's note had helped persuade him to free a man who downloaded pornographic images of children and might otherwise be jailed. "As of yesterday, I have to bear in mind a communication from the home secretary," Judge John Rogers told Mold Crown Court in North Wales as he gave Derek Williams, 46, a suspended sentence and released him. Politicians are not supposed to be involved in sentencing in Britain and the judge's decision to refer directly to Reid's views when freeing a convicted offender was seen as highly unusual. The head of the English judiciary, Lord Chancellor Charles Falconer, acknowledged that the judge had taken into account government warnings about prison overcrowding, but insisted legal guidelines were followed. "There's a problem about the number of jail places. That's got to be coped with in a practical way. I think one's got to bear it in mind when making sentencing decisions," he told Sky News. "The judge would have considered what to do within the guidelines. That would have given him a choice." The Home Office insisted Reid's letter, which it has refused to publish, did not lean on judges to set criminals free. "It simply reminds judges of the options available to them," a spokeswoman said. "Sentences are a matter for the courts. In the statement that was made yesterday there was no change in sentencing policy." Opposition politicians leapt at a chance to bash a government hurt by a succession of law-and-order scandals over the past year. Cabinet heavyweight Reid became home secretary last year when Blair sacked his predecessor for mistakenly freeing foreign criminals who should have been deported. "We now have a situation where sentences are being dictated by the prison capacity and not the severity of the crime," opposition Conservative Home Affairs spokesman David Davis said. bdnews24.com/mi/1046 hrs.
Related Stories