November 21, 2026

Three years on, Indian PM struggles to break shackles

An honest, intelligent but mild-mannered man, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh completes three years in office this week having failed to live up to his promise, political analysts said.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 21 May 2007, 05:43 AM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 03:12 PM

NEW DELHI, May 21 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - An honest, intelligent but mild-mannered man, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh completes three years in office this week having failed to live up to his promise, political analysts said. Considered the father of Indian economic reforms during his spell as finance minister in the 1990s, there is no doubting the ideals of the economist-turned-politician. But in the rough and tumble of Indian politics, the soft-spoken Singh has often seemed out of his depth, unable to provide the strong and inspiring leadership which analysts say his unruly coalition government needed. "While his personal record remains completely unblemished, he could have shown a little more grit and leadership. Today, his prestige is not as high as it was when he took over," said former editor and veteran analyst Inder Malhotra. Part of the problem is that Singh was installed by Congress party leader Sonia Gandhi, who led her party to a surprise election victory in 2004 but declined the top job, to deflect critics trying to exploit her foreign origin. The Italian-born widow of assassinated prime minister Rajiv Gandhi continues to pull many of the strings behind the scenes, and has not always pulled in the same direction as Singh. "People talk about exercising power without responsibility," said Malhotra. "In Manmohan Singh's case, he has been asked to carry all the responsibility with very little power." With national elections due in two years and his party already on the back foot because of rising prices, few, if any, bold policy initiatives are expected. Singh's legacy could be more what he did not achieve than what he did, analysts said. A former academic, bureaucrat and Reserve Bank of India (RBI) governor, the 74-year-old came to power with a fractured mandate, heading a coalition dependent on communists for support. On the one hand, economic reforms in the past had helped lay the foundations of India's economic boom. On the other, the poor had voted the previous government out of office, partly because faster growth was not helping them. Singh's solution was to promise more inclusive growth, or as he called it, "reforms with a human face". Three years on, the rhetoric has not changed, nor the earnest way in which Singh promotes it. But it is not clear how much the country has to show for it. The communist parties have taken some of the blame, for blocking economic reforms and privatisation that might have freed up resources for investment elsewhere. Singh has ridden on the crest of a wave of growth of between eight and nine percent, but his government has arguably failed to provide the investment in infrastructure and education which could have built a more solid foundation for the future. Already the economy is overheating and inflation is ringing alarm bells. Ambitious programmes to help farmers and create hundreds of millions of jobs in the countryside have raised hopes, but many of these have foundered on poor implementation. Hundreds of indebted farmers commit suicide each year, and poverty hardly seems to have been dented. "A darker shadow is the growing realisation that alongside what is happening to corporate India there is a great deal of distress in very large sections of society," said Pran Chopra, another political analyst. "Now, expectations are very high". The critics of liberalisation have even found allies from within Congress. Gandhi herself has often sided with those cautious voices, and when challenged, Singh has backed down. Within his cabinet, too, his control has looked shaky. Ministers announce policies apparently without consultation, others squabble in public or question their government. "There is a feeling that is growing as if it has overdosed on hormones, that this government is at best led ineffectually," the Indian Express said. Foreign policy was one of Singh's unexpected early successes. But a peace process with Pakistan inherited from the previous government appears to have lost steam. Singh might still claim one big victory before the next election -- a landmark nuclear cooperation deal with the United States that would cement a strategic alliance and usher India to the nuclear top table. Yet that deal too, announced with fanfare in 2005, appears to be running into trouble as the two sides struggle to pin down the fine print and assuage critics in both nations. One reason for the lack of dynamism could be that Singh and close ally Montek Singh Ahluwalia -- head of the Planning Commission -- had been "bureaucrats all their life", in the words of a former official from the Prime Minister's Office of a previous government. "They are trained through their lives to do the minimum, because the minimum is safe," he said. bdnews24.com/srs/1140 hrs
Related Stories