Telenor says no quarrel with Yunus
Norwegian telecom group Telenor is in no fight with Nobel Peace Prize winner Muhammad Yunus and his Grameen Bank for control of Bangladesh's biggest mobile phone operator GrameenPhone, Telenor said on Tuesday.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
05 Dec 2006, 06:00 PM
Updated :
17 Aug 2022, 06:58 PM
OSLO, December 6 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - Norwegian telecom group Telenor is in no fight with Nobel Peace Prize winner Muhammad Yunus and his Grameen Bank for control of Bangladesh's biggest mobile phone operator GrameenPhone, Telenor said on Tuesday.
Fortune magazine said earlier on Tuesday that Yunus, who will receive his Nobel prize in Oslo on Dec. 10, would come prepared to fight for control of GrameenPhone which non-profit Grameen Telecom -- a unit of the bank -- owns with Telenor.
"We have been discussing the future of GrameenPhone for 10 years, and it has been a fruitful cooperation and a good partnership," Telenor's spokesman Esben Tuman told Reuters.
Fortune magazine quoted Yunus as saying that Telenor "agreed to give us majority ownership within six years."
But Telenor Chief Executive Jon Fredrik Baksaas denied that such a deal ever existed. "We have never committed to reducing our share in the company," he told Fortune.
Telenor, which co-founded GrameenPhone 10 years ago with Grameen Telecom and two small minority stakeholders who were subsequently bought out, owns 62 percent of the company and Grameen Telecom 38 percent.
GrameenPhone was Bangladesh's first mobile operator and has seen its subscriber base swell to 10 million since it launched operations in 1997 -- doubling almost every year recently -- for a market share of about 63 percent.
Fortune quoted Yunus, who with his bank won the 2006 Nobel Peace Prize for pioneering microcredit in a bid to lift millions out of poverty, as saying that there was a "philosophical difference" with Telenor over how Grameen Phone should be run.
"They're oriented towards profit maximisation. We're oriented towards social objectives," Yunus told Fortune, which also said Yunus had asked for a meeting with the Telenor board during his visit to Oslo, but had been denied.
Telenor told Reuters it has not recouped its investment of about $87 million in GrameenPhone, and almost all of $1.08 billion earned by GrameenPhone over the past eight years has been reinvested.
Telenor said in a written statement to Reuters: "As a long-term, industrial actor, Telenor contributes substantially to the development of the society in Bangladesh."
Telenor said it welcomed discussing future development of GrameenPhone with Grameen Bank but added: "We believe that it is in all parties' interest to avoid a hasty process."
"We have already invited Professor Yunus and Grameen Bank to discuss the relevant topics, and we are convinced that we will reach an understanding," Telenor said.
In an interview with Reuters this week, Telenor's head of Asian operations, Arve Johansen, said mobile services were "a blessing" that helped people make better lives for themselves -- in line with Grameen Bank's self-help philosophy.
GrameenPhone has provided 260,000 "village phones" to private entrepreneurs, mainly women, in Bangladesh as part of the bank's microcredit scheme of tiny loans to the poor.
The village phone women make money by charging villagers to use the phones while they pay a discounted wholesale rate.
"It is not charity. It is ordinary business," Johansen said.
He predicted that the mobile phone penetration rate in Bangladesh, which is now 12-13 percent, could rise to around 50 percent in three to five years and approach western rates later.
"This undertaking, which was set up as a business project from day one, has probably helped more people than all other development aid programmes together," he said of Grameen Phone.
bdnews24.com/mhb/1248 hrs