November 21, 2026

Security Council expansion: No compromise yet between G-4 and AU

The diplomatic battle for the expansion of the UN Security Council got prolonged as the Group of 4 and the African Union failed to arrive at a compromise.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 17 Jul 2005, 06:00 PM

Updated : 18 Aug 2022, 11:43 AM

Washington, July 18 (BDNEWS)- The diplomatic battle for the expansion of the UN Security Council got prolonged as the Group of 4 and the African Union failed to arrive at a compromise. However, neither side was willing to let the G-4 initiative collapse at this stage. They decided to hold further negotiations. This saved New Delhi an embarrassment on the eve of the Indian Prime Minister's meeting with President George Bush because the G-4 resolution was vigorously opposed by the US in the General Assembly. A promise of further negotiations was better than the collapse of the talks, according to wire services. India, Germany, Japan and Brazil will resume discussions with the 53-member African Union. Since the ministerial-level discussions failed to resolve the differences, the progress may not be smooth. They have decided to set up a joint working group to continue negotiations at the level of ambassadors in New York. On July 25, G-4 foreign ministers will again meet their African Union counterparts in Geneva. In the worst-case scenario, the G-4 may not like to press for a vote. India is especially keen to see that the African Union joins in this initiative rather than falling prey to those who want to divide the developing countries with a view to sabotaging any move to reform the Security Council. The opposition to the G-4 resolution has been led by the US, China, Italy and Pakistan. Barring Pakistan, others are not opposed to the candidature of India as such but they are against the expansion of the council at this stage. On this issue there is nothing further to be discussed between India and the US. While the US support was important but that by itself would not have seen the resolution through since it would require two-thirds majority in the General Assembly. However, the US campaign against the resolution is making G-4's task a bit difficult. If the two sides arrive at a compromise, they could merge their separate resolutions. As Natwar Singh said an agreement would pave the passage of the resolution by the required majority. The G-4 draft provides that the seats of the council would be expanded to 25 from the current 15 by adding six new permanent seats and four nonpermanent ones. The draft also proposes a 15-year freeze on the veto power for new permanent members. But the African Union proposes increasing six new permanent members, all with the veto power, and five non-permanent members, two from Africa, on the council. The present council consists of five permanent veto-wielding members -- France, China, Britain, the United States and Russia -- and 10 elected members with two-year terms. BDNEWS/1857 hrs
Related Stories