November 20, 2026

Make or Break

In a study for the London-based Institute of Commonwealth Studies, former BBC correspondent in Dhaka Frances Harrison has said the next general elections could turn out to be a 'make-or-break struggle' for Bangladesh's identity, the world's third largest Muslim country.

News Desk

bdnews24.com

Published : 05 Oct 2013, 03:55 PM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 11:10 AM

"Political Islam and the elections in Bangladesh" by Harrison, who also worked for BBC in Sri Lanka and Iran, suggests that the 'ideological clash between secular Bengalis and Islamists has already spilt onto the streets'.

In this report, Frances Harrison, examines the ideological and political differences between the various Islamic parties, alliances and militant groups in Bangladesh, with special focus on Jamaat-e-Islami.

The report examines allegations about the extent of Jamaat infiltration into the country's economic life and educational system but also looks the creeping Islamisation at village level, as well as charting recent attacks on religious minorities.

"Many describe this as a make-or-break struggle for the heart of the nation, still to be resolved forty years on. The pending elections are adding an extra degree of urgency to these debates. All agree this vote is of the utmost importance for the country's future," says Harrison.

"So uncertain and fluid is the situation that it's possible elections won't happen on time at the end of this year. Much hinges on finding an alternative for the abolished caretaker government system," observes Harrison.

She says several Bangladeshis confided they had never been so worried about Islamists gaining ground because of the confrontation between the two main political leaders.

"They are creating a Frankenstein's monster in the Islamic fundamentalists and they can see it but they are still addicted," is how one observer described the power struggle between Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina and her rival, the opposition leader, Khaleda Zia.

Again and again, Harrison says, commentators have repeated to her that both ladies would prefer the army to come to power than their rival. "However, nobody believed the military actually wanted to seize power." Harrison paints an uncertain scenario if the convicted 'war criminals' are executed before the polls. "A key unknown is whether some of the convicted Jamaat-e-Islami war criminals will be hanged before the elections and what the impact might be on the already volatile political situation... Executions could lead to a groundswell of popular support for the Awami League among those Bangladeshis who feel those responsible for terrible crimes have never faced justice. However it's a huge gamble because executions could push Jamaat-e-Islami to violent extremism and destabilise the whole country."

Harrison says many analysts see strong international pressure as the only way to force a compromise between the feuding political leaders.

The possibility exists of deals between the governing party and potential breakaway factions of the various opposition parties because so much is at stake.

Harrison says the economic damage to the country from frequent political strikes is significant. A former finance adviser to the caretaker government, AB Mirza Azizul Islam told her he believed the country's GDP would be reduced by 0.5 to 0.6% because 9 of political instability. "It hampers exports, it hampers production, it hampers transport," he said.

The association representing the country's largest export industry, the readymade garment sector, the BGMEA, estimated factories were losing approximately £17 million daily in 2013 as a result of strikes. The garment sector is particularly vulnerable to unrest because of the time sensitivity of exports that need to feed modern supply chains.

Related Stories