November 21, 2026

How much is Murdoch willing to pay for Dow?

When Rupert Murdoch discusses News Corp's fiscal third-quarter financial report next week, earnings will be the last thing on anyone's mind. Investors are hoping for details of his audacious offer to buy Dow Jones & Co and how he sees the venerable Wall Street Journal fitting into a company that introduced the scantily clad "Page 3 Girls" and a TV network whose "American Idol" show enthralled a nation.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 04 May 2007, 05:59 AM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 03:02 PM

NEW YORK, May 4 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - When Rupert Murdoch discusses News Corp's fiscal third-quarter financial report next week, earnings will be the last thing on anyone's mind. Investors are hoping for details of his audacious offer to buy Dow Jones & Co and how he sees the venerable Wall Street Journal fitting into a company that introduced the scantily clad "Page 3 Girls" and a TV network whose "American Idol" show enthralled a nation. Investors -- and potential bidders for all or part of Dow Jones -- will be keen to hear why Murdoch believes that investment returns from buying another traditional media company would be higher than snapping up the next MySpace. The bid is priced at a 65 percent premium to the Dow Jones stock price the day before it was announced. Even so, some News Corp shareholders worry the 76-year-old mogul will raise his $5 billion offer, after it was all but rejected by Dow Jones' board due to opposition from the company's controlling shareholders, the Bancrofts. "If the initial bid was not sufficient for the Bancrofts, I don't think it's a great deal for News Corp to keep pursuing," said analyst Dave Novosel of Gimme Credit, an independent research firm. "At some point, you wonder if it's worth it, based on the types of earnings you get from Dow Jones." Unlike the fast-growing online teen hangout MySpace.com, which Murdoch bought for $580 million to be the cornerstone of News Corp's Web strategy, Dow Jones is considered by Wall Street to be "old media" with only modest growth potential. Still, some analysts are keeping an open mind, saying Murdoch has a record of turning around investments that surprised investors initially. Consider those who bet against Murdoch when he started the fourth free US television network Fox in the 1986. Fox ratings for some of its shows now routinely trounce the big three. There was similar skepticism surrounding his Fox News cable channel, which is now the top-rated cable news network. "Historically, they've done things like this and there have been negative reaction," Bernstein Research analyst Michael Nathanson said. "These deals end up being positive." For now, analysis on Murdoch's $60 per share offer for Dow Jones has barely risen beyond back-of-the-envelope calculations by analysts or imaginative conjectures by investors. Broadly, Dow Jones is seen to lend financial clout and a rich trove of online content to Murdoch's media empire, possibly aiding the launch of the new Fox Business Channel in the fourth quarter, which will compete with General Electric's CNBC. But the impact of an acquisition on News Corp's balance sheet is yet unknown. Most analysts expect minimal dilution of 1 percent to 6 percent of 2008 profit, before any cost cuts or asset sales. Pali Research analyst Richard Greenfield estimated News Corp could comfortably digest a bid of up to $65 per share. Investors are hoping for more details from Murdoch next Wednesday on estimated cost savings. They also want to know if Murdoch plans to sell off any of Dow Jones newspaper, Internet and newswire assets, which could help shareholders better stomach the cost of a deal should the price go up. Meanwhile, other media and Internet executives are also looking for such details to decide if they want to bid against Murdoch, or vie for the scraps off his table should he successfully strike a deal with the Bancrofts. "People expect he'll go higher," said portfolio manager Larry Haverty of Gamco Investors Inc, a News Corp investor. The speculation is that Murdoch could top his bid for Dow Jones by anywhere from $5 to more than $10, to lock in a deal before incurring the wrath of investors. "About $70 is when you get a lot of resistance," Gimme Credit's Novosel said. That would value Dow Jones at $5.75 billion, or 17.2 times estimated 2007 cash flow, putting it nearly on par with Yahoo Inc for a business "that has little upside and more downside," he added. By contrast, newspaper company Tribune Co trades at a 6.5 multiple to 2007 cashflow, while the New York Times Co trades at 7.3, according to Reuters Estimates. Bernstein's Nathanson said a price hike of $5 to $10 per share was unlikely to sway sentiment: "If this (current offer) hasn't made you made mad and sell the stock ... $10 won't really change minds." Haverty said "a couple of bucks above $60 -- just to be civil" could be a reasonable outcome. Others would like to hear more before passing judgment. "Can this relationship help move the business channel on a faster launch track with more success in the near term?" Nathanson asked. Or, how would owning the Wall Street Journal help News Corp extract savings in the United States and in Europe? The only certainty is that Murdoch has not given up on Dow Jones, even though its board said it would not take any action on his bid. The newspaper industry is "in his blood," Time Warner Inc Chief Executive Richard Parsons said on CNBC on Thursday. "This is tailor made for Mr Murdoch and he'll keep coming." bdnews24.com/srs/1155 hrs
Related Stories