November 20, 2026

Five defeats for anti-terror bill

Peers have inflicted five defeats on the anti-terrorism bill, backing a "sunset clause" to quash new government powers on 30 November.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 08 Mar 2005, 06:00 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 08:18 PM

London, Mar 9 (BDNEWS)- Peers have inflicted five defeats on the anti-terrorism bill, backing a "sunset clause" to quash new government powers on 30 November according to wire services. Tony Blair had personally opposed the sunset clause but peers voted for it by 297 votes to 110. Ministers are understood to be planning to concede judges should oversee all control orders on terrorist suspects. But they wish to keep "reasonable grounds for suspicion" as the standard of justification for issuing orders. On Wednesday, the government will table a series of amendments on three areas, including the role of judges in the process. It is not clear as yet what position it will take on the Lords' amendment to introduce a time limit to the bill. On Monday peers had voted to ensure control orders issued against terror suspects were made by judges, not by ministers. On Tuesday, defeats were on the right of suspects to have state benefits and peers insisted any control measures used against terror suspects must be listed on the bill. They also backed an amendment that said the rules of court in control order proceedings should be made by the lord chief justice after consulting the lord chancellor. And they voted for a Tory amendment prohibiting the use of evidence against suspects obtained under torture abroad. The sunset clause amendment was tabled by Tory shadow lord chancellor Lord Kingsland and backed by the Lib Dems. Former Lord Chancellor Lord Irving, Mr Blair's old boss when he was a trainee at the Bar, was among the 24 Labour rebels who backed it. After the vote Home Office Minister Hazel Blears said: "We are determined over the next 24 hours or so to do everything we can to make sure we get the legislation to protect national security and also is within the rule of law and compatible with the European convention." Conservative leader Michael Howard said if there was no legislation on the statute book at the end of the week it would be the "result of Mr Blair's decision" not to compromise on the sunset clause. The government tabled new legislation after the Law Lords ruled in December that current provisions for detention without trial were unlawful. Current laws expire next Monday, and if some legislation is not in place by then, the men held under anti-terror laws in Belmarsh and Woodhill prisons will have to be released. BDNEWS/0940hrs.
Related Stories