Canada judge slams US in terrorism extradition case
A judge refused on Wednesday to extradite a Canadian man wanted on US terrorism charges and whose brother is detained at Guantanamo, saying the United States violated his rights.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
05 Aug 2010, 07:19 AM
Updated :
24 Apr 2022, 05:34 PM
VANCOUVER, April 05 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - A judge refused on Wednesday to extradite a Canadian man wanted on U.S. terrorism charges and whose brother is detained at Guantanamo, saying the United States violated his rights.
The judge ruled Abdullah Khadr's rights, including access to Canadian diplomatic counsel, were violated after he was detained in 2004 by Pakistani intelligence officials, acting on a US offer of a C$500,000 bounty.
"In this case, the sum of the human rights violations suffered by Khadr is both shocking and unjustifiable," Ontario Superior Court Justice Christopher Speyer ruled in Toronto.
Khadr was held secretly in Pakistan for 14 months but allowed to return to Canada in 2005. Canada later arrested him at the request of the United States, which accuses him of supplying weapons to al Qaeda in Pakistan.
Khadr's younger brother, Omar, is being held at the Guantanamo Bay US naval base on charges of murdering a US soldier in Afghanistan. The US Supreme Court has been asked to halt his trial set for next week.
In requesting Khadr's extradition from Canada, the United States was "seeking a benefit from this court, committal, based on evidence derived from its own misconduct," Speyer wrote in the 62-page ruling.
Khadr has alleged he was tortured in Pakistan. Speyer said he believes Khadr was mistreated, and the United States knew that this would happen, but the mistreatment was likely not as bad as Khadr claims.
"I want to just start anew now," Khadr told reporters outside the Toronto court. He has been held in Canadian jails for more than four years.
The Canadian government, which represented the United States in the extradition case, said it has not decided if the ruling would be appealed.
bdnews24.com/bcs/1319 h.