November 21, 2026

British row reveals internal divisions in Iran

Iran's capture of 15 British sailors and its handling of the standoff reveal as much about internal divisions in the Islamic state as they do about its relations with the West. Antagonising Washington's closest ally when two US aircraft carriers are stationed in the Gulf and as the UN imposes fresh sanctions on Iran over its nuclear programme would not appear to serve the Islamic Republic's best interests.

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 30 Mar 2007, 03:13 PM

Updated : 17 Aug 2022, 02:48 PM

LONDON, March 30 (bdnews24.com/Reuters) - Iran's capture of 15 British sailors and its handling of the standoff reveal as much about internal divisions in the Islamic state as they do about its relations with the West. Antagonising Washington's closest ally when two US aircraft carriers are stationed in the Gulf and as the UN imposes fresh sanctions on Iran over its nuclear programme would not appear to serve the Islamic Republic's best interests. But hardliners, particularly in the Revolutionary Guards, may have wanted to send a stern message to pragmatists within the Iranian power elite who have been arguing for Tehran to adopt a less confrontational international stance. "As is so often the case when dealing with Iran, the rationale for what has happened here is just as likely to be internal as external," said a senior European diplomat who has spent several years following Iran closely. "We know from past experience that hardliners are often prepared to act deplorably in order to win the initiative back from pragmatists and that's what seems to have happened again," he said, speaking on condition that he not be identified. President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has vigorously supported Iran's right to build a nuclear industry. His unwillingness to compromise has led to two sets of sanctions being imposed by the UN Security Council, of which Britain is a permanent member. But analysts said it would be wrong to view the present standoff with Britain through the prism of the nuclear dispute which has dominated relations between the West and Tehran for the last four years. An almost identical incident in 2004, when Iran seized eight British sailors and marines and held them for three days, was widely regarded at the time as an internal power play by the Revolutionary Guards against the more moderate government of then President Mohammad Khatami. The Guards, which operate in parallel to the regular armed forces and have responsibility for border security, have assumed a greater political and economic role since the election of former Guardsman Ahmadinejad as president in 2005. But they have been put increasingly on the defensive in recent months by a more aggressive US stance against Iranian activities in Iraq. US forces detained five men who US officials said were linked to Iran's Revolutionary Guards (IRGC) in a raid on an Iranian consulate in northern Iraq in January. Iran protested that those detained were diplomats and demanded their release but their detention has been taken hard by the Guards, said Ali Ansari, director of the Institute of Iranian Studies at the University of St Andrews. "I think this (the sailors' arrest) was an attempt by the IRGC to retaliate against the abduction of their officials in Arbil and elsewhere, and to make a point both at home and abroad that they will not be pushed around," Ansari said. Most analysts say the capture could not have happened without sanction from the top of Iran's power structure. In a speech just two days before the British sailors' capture, Iran's ultimate authority Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei said Iranian officials would use "all they have in their power" against those who attacked them. The timing of the sailors' detention in the midst of Iran's extensive New Year holidays appears to have taken some Iranian officials off-guard. Mixed messages coming from Tehran over the issue further illustrate the internal divisions, analysts said. "It's clear that the Iranian Foreign Ministry is not in charge here," said Mark Fitzpatrick, senior fellow for Non-proliferation at the Institute for Strategic Studies. Iran's wish for the standoff to be dealt with bilaterally, without recourse to the Security Council, may be driven partly by a desire not to lose face, regarded by Iranians as of paramount importance, analysts said. "They're having to work out a face-saving diplomatic solution, but I don't think the Revolutionary Guards want a diplomatic solution," said Fitzpatrick. "So it's going to be hard to choreograph something when you have internal friction about the way forward," he said. bdnews24.com/srs/2110 hrs
Related Stories