Analysis: VoIP debacle waits in the wings
Abu Saeed Khan, bdnews24.com Technology Editor, says the telecoms ministry and the BTRC, in dealing with VoIP licenses, ignore the fact that the BTTB is simply nothing but an operator like others in the market governed by the common law.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
05 Oct 2006, 06:00 PM
Updated :
17 Aug 2022, 06:42 PM
Dhaka, Oct 6 (bdnews24.com) -- The telecoms regulator BTRC has recently announced that it will grant licences to the incumbent providers of VoIP technology that makes the overseas phone calls possible a lot cheaper. One might well relish the prospect of calling overseas at the rate similar to what it takes now to make a local call once the private sector launches competitive Voice over Internet Protocol technology services.
Wait! That's unlikely to happen as the consumers' benefit is nonexistent in the VoIP license. The regulator rather intends to firm up the state-owned BTTB's monopoly over the international voice business. In other words, the government wants to keep the ailing BTTB artificially alive through VoIP licensing.
The Clause 5.4 of the licence compels the private operators to use the BTTB's VoIP platforms. Recently, the prime minister turned down the US$3.6 million VoIP platform purchase proposal on the grounds of irregularities. But an apparently undaunted BTTB remains keen to slice off public funds in the name of re-tendering its VoIP platform project.
The private operators, according to the BTRC's licence document, will be connected with "BTTB's submarine cable and or BTTB's satellite, for international VOIP service". It demonstrates BTRC's absolute ignorance about the fundamental operating issues of international telecoms circuits.
Imagine a country's road and rail networks without bridges over the major rivers. Travelling from one place to another becomes painstakingly longer if one has had to use the ferries. Similarly, instead of media gateway equipment or bridges, few enterprise routers or ferries run the BTTB's network.
Ignoring this gross technical drawback, the regulator dictates, "The (VOIP) licensee will conclude an operational agreement with BTTB which will inter alia provide for payment to BTTB by the licensee for use of BTTB's facilities."
This move will deal a massive blow to the private VoIP operators. Because the BTTB never guarantees how long its submarine cable or satellite link remains functional. The VoIP operators will not get compensated for the beyond-permissible downtime either. Yet they have to make six months' down payment to start using the BTTB's defective network!
Therefore, platform or no platform, the BTTB's unreliable infrastructure defies all logic to be the lifeline of the VoIP businesses. The VoIP operators have to deploy respective international gateway, regardless of what the BTRC says.
The regulator's prejudice for the BTTB is an open secret. It has been allowing the BTTB to pump VoIP calls using the 012 access code since 2003 without any licence. It has, undoubtedly, relieved the BTTB subscribers of exorbitant overseas tariff. Simultaneously, such regulatory concession has injected uncontrollable arrogance into the BTTB's institutional ignorance. That's why the state-owned operator now dares to behave like a regulator.
Clause 10.2 of the BTTB's submarine cable capacity sales agreement says: "BTTB shall have the right to apply monitoring facility over any service extended to IPLC (International Private Leased Circuit)."
The next clause proclaims, "BTTB will have the right of unrestricted access for monitoring & inspection of the premises of the IPLC customer, without prior notice or delay, for obtaining data/current configurations of the equipment installed."
The telecoms ministry and the BTRC have vetted these unlawful demands of BTTB.
It is illegal because the Sections 61, 62, 63 and 64 of the telecoms law have explicitly empowered only the BTRC, a first class magistrate or a metropolitan magistrate to conduct any "inspection and compulsory enforcement." So, the BTTB lacks any lawful authority to adjudicate the industry.
The telecoms ministry and the BTRC have also ignored the fact that the BTTB is simply nothing but an operator like others in the market governed by the common law. Evidently, the extra-regulatory indulgences have made the BTTB more defiant to stipulate the libellous terms in its submarine cable's capacity sales.
The government has carefully embedded these asymmetric provisions in VoIP licence to establish a prolonged monopoly in the country's international telecoms business. Once the BTTB is corporatised and its shares are off-loaded, the public telecoms monopoly will get more monstrous with reinforced private sector profile.
Offshore giants, powered by multibillion-dollars capital, are likely to take over the BTTB, as has been the case with the recent privatisation of the PTCL, Pakistan's public telecoms entity. There is absolutely nothing wrong about it. However, unlike Pakistan, the BTTB's acquirer will inherit its historical monopoly over the international voice gateway.
Subsequently, the preachers of reforms and even competition will suffer from amnesia. Bilateral and multilateral lenders, including the Breton Woods institutions, will aim their political guns at our government's head to protect the newly converted private sector monopoly as they did for WorldTel, where Bangladesh government owns 10 percent stakes.
This private sector international Trojan horse entered Bangladesh's telecoms market with a monopolistic 300,000-lines fixed-phone licence in Dhaka at the twilight of previous government. The UN affiliate, International Telecommunications Union, backs WorldTel. It is yet to launch services while other fixed-phone operators' entry into Dhaka remains uncertain due to the legal tangles created by this foreign-owned private sector monopoly. The present government, also at its fag end, is paving the way for another debacle to happen through the VoIP licence.
It is imperative to foil the move by lawfully splitting the BTTB's overseas telecoms division. It shouldn't be a tough ask since subsection C under Section 49 of the telecoms law prohibits the BTTB's ownership over the submarine cable or satellite link in the first place.
The deterrence would mean the BTTB can no longer exclusively own and operate the overseas telecoms facilities. According to the law, all public and private operators deserve equitable access to the BTTB's yet-to-be segregated overseas telecoms unit. The regulator has to ensure fast enforcement of this legal provision while processing the VoIP licence applications.
Otherwise, despite paying hefty amounts in licence fees, the private VoIP operators will be primarily enslaved thanks to the state-owned telecoms watchdog's eccentricity. Ultimately, they will sink into the quicksand of uncertainty as have the fixed-phone operators with regards to the Dhaka zone licence.
They will bid goodbye to good luck, for good.
Abu Saeed Khan is Technology Editor of bdnews24.com
bdnews24.com/2000 hrs.