SC verdict creates confusion: Mahbub
The annulment of the 13th Amendment without giving any clear decision may heat up politics, says the SCBA president.
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
10 May 2011, 11:25 AM
Updated :
10 Aug 2022, 04:47 PM
Dhaka, May 10 (bdnews24.com) -- A pro-BNP lawyer fears that the Supreme Court verdict on the 13th Amendment may create a political instability in the country.
"Confusion has created due to the verdict. I think that it's impossible to reach a correct decision following the verdict," president of the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) Khandaker Mahbub Hossain told reporters on Tuesday following the court verdict.
Mahbub, also the advisor to BNP chief Khaleda Zia, said, "The annulment of the 13th Amendment without giving any clear decision may heat up politics."
Another BNP leader, Moudud Ahmed, said the verdict would push the country towards 'further constitutional and political crises'.
Parliament in 1996 amended the constitution to introduce the caretaker government system, which prescribes installation of a non-party and non-elected caretaker government for overseeing general election at the end of the tenure of an elected government.
BNP, however, has recently threatened to launch a movement if the caretaker system is repealed.
In response to a petition filed challenging the legality of the amendment, the Supreme Court on Tuesday rescinded the amendment but said "the next two general elections could be held under unelected governments".
Mahbub said one hand the High Court declared the amendment unconstitutional and on the other hand it (the court) said the 10th and 11th general elections could be held under the caretaker system.
"It's unclear what it (the court) really wants to say through the verdict."
After the verdict, attorney general Mahbubey Alam said that the court verdict came to preserve law and order and sequence.
In this regard, Mahbub said: "When the amendment is nullified, how the Appellate Division can say that the two elections can be held under the repealed system?"
The apex court in its judgment said parliament may amend the charter deleting provisions that require the former chief justices or the judges of the Appellate Division to head the caretaker governments.
He also criticised part of the verdict that gave parliament the authority to annul the provision allowing former chief justices or judges to head caretaker governments. "If the court thus directs parliament, then that question comes again: what is sovereign – parliament of court?"
He also claimed that the elected public representatives had been undermined with the verdict.
The BNP chief's advisor said the court could have referred to the politics over the appointment of former chief justices as chief advisors.
Mahbub also focused on the Election Commission's weakness and called for restoration of the caretaker system.
bdnews24.com/sn/mi/skb/pks/mr/1710h