Nizami indictment hearing begins
All pleas of Salauddin Quader Chowdhury rejected, Ghulam Azam hearing deferred. Full story
bdnews24.com News Service
bdnews24.com
Published :
13 Mar 2012, 10:11 AM
Updated :
09 Aug 2022, 03:32 PM
Dhaka, Mar 13 (bdnews24.com) — The war crimes tribunal began indictment hearing against Jamaat-e-Islami chief Matiur Rahman Nizami on Tuesday after the lunch recess.
Prosecutor Altaf Uddin Ahmed began reading the formal charge and got through 23 pages of the 72-page report before the close of proceedings. It will continue on Wednesday.
Earlier, the International Crimes Tribunal rejected all petitions by BNP MP Salauddin Quader Chowdhury including one for discharging him and another to grant him bail.
The three-judge tribunal then fixed Mar 20 for indictment order against the six-time MP from Chittagong.
The Tribunal, set up to deal with the crimes against humanity during the 1971 Liberation War, also adjourned the hearing in former Jamaat chief Ghulam Azam's case to Mar 19.
Jamaat guru Azam's defence was supposed to present their arguments against his indictment on Tuesday. But M Tajul Islam prayed for an adjournment saying that Abdur Razzaq, the senior counsel defending the entire Jamaat leadership, had not been able to prepare fully due to personal difficulty.
The tribunal granted the prayer deferring the case but cautioned that there would be no further adjournments in the case.
Assistant secretary general Abdul Quader Molla's case was deferred by one day to allow prosecutor Mohammad Ali more time to prepare for the queries of the tribunal and present his arguments in support of the formal charges against him.
SQ CHY ORDER
In its first case of the day, the tribunal began with issuing orders on the applications of the BNP policymaker.
Regarding an application to invoke the Collaborators Act, the tribunal said that offences under the tribunal's laws and those under the Collaborators Act were different.
Tribunal chairman, Justice Nizamul Huq, said in his order that there was no scope to transfer cases from the tribunal elsewhere or bring other cases to the tribunal and stated that application was not maintainable.
Another petition, requesting certain documents was also denied since, the tribunal ruled, the prosecution would not rely upon them for building its case. Justice Huq clarified, as he has done many times before, that the defence would be provided with all documents that the prosecution will rely upon.
As regards Salauddin Quader's review petition to abide by international standards, the tribunal noted that while Bangladesh may be a signatory to certain international statutes and covenants, parliament had not passed any binding laws that obligate the court to abide by them.
The order also noted that the crimes against humanity and crimes against peace and genocide were defined quite clearly in the act without ambiguity. The order noted that the law framed was during a period when the concept of the offences was quite clear and there was no reason to borrow from more recent laws. However, the tribunal may enlighten itself with recent jurisprudential development and material elsewhere.
Salauddin Quader's second discharge petition with additional grounds was also rejected.
The court explained its position regarding six other cases, three of which had been filed under the Collaborators Act and three under the Bangladesh Penal Code.
The defence counsel had argued that that the Chittagong MP was vulnerable to double jeopardy citing Article 35.2 stipulating that no person can be 'prosecuted and punished' for the same offence twice.
As such, the defence petitioned that these charges be dropped. However, prosecutor Zead-Al-Malum said that it was constitutional matter and completely beyond the purview of the tribunal.
The tribunal ruled that the 'and' of 'prosecuted and punished' was an inclusive or, meaning that an individual had to be both prosecuted and punished for an offence on two instances to suffer double jeopardy.
But there was no material in front of the tribunal from either the prosecution or the defence indicating that Salauddin Quader had been prosecuted and punished in any one of the six cases. As such the application for omission of six cases did not stand in this case, the court observed.
As for amendment of the law incorporating 'individual' only to include Salauddin Quader, as the accused had claimed, the tribunal ruled that it could only take the law as it stood. Further, the order stated that this matter was not within court's jurisdiction. As such, the discharge petition was rejected.
The war crimes tribunal also rejected Salauddin Quader's petition for bail saying that it would not be considered at this time of the proceedings since formal charges had been submitted, and the court had taken cognisance of the charges. Also, the court was about to give an indictment order in the case, thus the petitioner's claim of arbitrary detention did not hold.
As for the petition that he be transferred from Kashimpur Central Jail (2) to any other jail, the court ruled that it deemed the matter to be one that should be settled by the jail authorities. The petition was rejected for the time being.
Tribunal member, Judge A K M Zaheer Ahmed, added his dissent after the order stating that it was his opinion that the order for discharge petition should been given in the presence of the accused. "The petitioner has right to know why his petition is being rejected."
Judge Zaheer Ahmed said that he did not think a discharge petition was at all necessary but since there was one, it should have been disposed of in the presence of the accused.
He said that the order should been put on hold while the other orders could well be given out.
The prosecution submitted formal charges against Salauddin Quader on Nov 14, 2011 and the tribunal took them into cognisance three days later.
The Chittagong MP was shown arrested for war crimes charges on Dec 20, 2010 five days after his arrest.
The investigating agency submitted a 119-page report with around 8,000-page data report to the chief prosecutor on Oct 3 in a bid to prove allegations of war crimes during the 1971 Liberation War.
Besides the BNP MP, Jamaat executive council member Delwar Hossain Sayedee whose case is the most advanced, Jamaat chief Nizami, secretary general Ali Ahsan Mohammad Mujaheed and assistant secretaries general Mohammad Kamaruzzaman and Abdul Quader Molla have been detained on war crimes charges.
The tribunal has also sent Ghulam Azam to jail on Jan 11.
The court granted conditional bail to former BNP lawmaker and minister Abdul Alim on March 31 last year. The bail was extended further on Jan 16, ordering him to be present in the court on Mar 15 when the prosecution has been directed to submit formal charges against the BNP leader.
bdnews24.com/ta/bd/1721h