November 20, 2026

Jamaat counsel ordered to explain 'misconduct'

An ICT order asks M Tajul Islam why he should not face action for walking out of the courtroom. Updates

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 22 Oct 2012, 06:02 AM

Updated : 09 Aug 2022, 04:24 PM

Dhaka, Oct 22 (bdnews24.com) – The first war crimes tribunal of Bangladesh on Monday asked a Jamaat-e-Islami defence counsel to explain why legal action should not be taken for his 'misconduct'. A member of Jamaat's core defence team for the war crimes trials, M Tajul Islam, had refused to obey the tribunal and walked out of the courtroom in protest. The defence counsel was referring to Misbahur Rahman Chowdhury, head of a faction of the Islami Oikya Jote, and supposedly a former member of Islami Chhatra Sangha, the first prosecution witness against Jamaat-e-Islami chief Motiur Rahman Nizami. The three-judge International Crimes Tribunal-1, set up to try crimes against humanity during the 1971 Liberation War, had said at the outset of the day's proceedings that no one other than the conducting lawyer was allowed to speak. Neither would anyone else be allowed to stand up. This was presumably to avert recurrence of Sunday's chaos when the prosecutor, defence counsels and the witness shouted at each other almost entirely drowning the judges' loud orders asking everyone to quiet down. However, after the court asked senior defence counsel Mizanul Islam to begin his cross-examination of the first prosecution witness against Nizami, Tajul Islam stood up to reiterate his demand for some sort of measure from the court saying that the witness had insulted him and that the dignity of an officer of the court was at stake. Tajul Islam said he would simply have to leave the court if the tribunal did not give him protection. "I cannot perform my duties as a lawyer with dignity as long as this witness is being cross-examined." He turned around and marched out of the court, without even the hint of the customary bow showing is back to the tribunal. The tribunal had had enough by then and passed an order. The order said that M Tajul Islam seemed to have been angry in the court. The order noted that there was a dispute between the counsel and the witness. "We also saw during the dispute that the counsel stood every three to four minutes." Justice Huq was issuing the tribunal's order and observed that the counsel seemingly wanted to create a problem in the proceedings. At one point, the order noted, "The [witness] could not contain himself and made a comment, which enraged the counsels. We are of the view that Tajul Islam is responsible for the dispute." The order also said that the court had told Mizanul Islam that since he was the counsel conducting the cross-examination, he would be the only one allowed to speak. Even after that Tajul Islam kept saying that he wanted the tribunal to take action. "If action is to be taken, it should be taken first against Tajul Islam for unruly behaviour." Justice Huq continued with the order that although the counsel was cautioned about misconduct and asked to remain in the court, "he left the courtroom in a rough way". The court then ordered Tajul Islam to show cause why legal action should not be taken against him for professional misconduct within 15 days. After receipt of the reply, the tribunal will decide what action may be taken in this regard. The judge then added, "A similar show-case was issued before but recalled at the request of Mizanul Islam." Mizanul Islam, who had also pleaded the court that it take some action, said, "This is even more unfortunate." Justice Huq said, "Something more will be added to the order later." The point was first raised by Munshi Ahsan Kabir who also prayed that there be some measure, perhaps an apology from the witness. The tribunal would not budge and asked the lawyer to sit down and told the defence counsel to begin his cross-examination. Mizanul Islam was at first given half-an-hour to cross-examine the witness but instead he began with a prayer for action from the court to caution the witness and went on to say how the witness' behaviour had insulted an officer of the court. After the senior defence counsel had continued for almost 10 minutes justifying his demand, the court stiffly reminded him that he was losing from his allotted time for cross-examination. "We will stop you at 11:10am positively." Seeing that his colleagues had failed to elicit a desirable response, Tajul Islam himself stood up to address the court even after the court had ordered that only the conducting lawyer would be allowed to speak. It was almost 11am by the time the tribunal passed the order and Mizanul Islam got around to ask his first question. He was allowed almost a full hour and Misbahur Rahman Chowdhury, whose cross-examination had been in the centre of the chaos of Sunday, was allowed to leave the stand a few minutes before noon. Even the tribunal chair was relieved. As soon as the defence counsel indicated that he had finished with his cross-examination, Justice Huq said, "Okay, that is the end of it. Thank God!" bdnews24.com/eh/ta/nir/1608h
Related Stories