November 21, 2026

ICT chair recusal explanation deferred

The war crimes tribunal chief will issue an order on the matter next week

bdnews24.com News Service

bdnews24.com

Published : 23 Nov 2011, 08:42 AM

Updated : 10 Aug 2022, 05:50 PM

Dhaka, Nov 23 (bdnew24.com) - International Crimes Tribunal justice Nizamul Huq will issue an order on Monday on the petition seeking his removal. Previously, the tribunal had fixed Wednesday for the order in the form of a ruling, as sought by defence lawyers of Jamaat-e-Islami leader Delwar Hossain Sayedee. The court officials said on Wednesday it would come on Monday. The lawyers of Sayedee had appealed that Huq remove himself from the tribunal given his prior involvement with a people's inquiry commission in 1993 and 1994 when the tribunal chairman allegedly collected evidence against Sayedee. Sayedee is being tried on 20 counts of war crimes charges that include genocide, murder, rape, arson and loot during Bangladesh's Liberation War of 1971. The defence lawyers held that the justice had already formed an opinion against the accused which compromises his neutrality to the extent that he would not be able to give a judgement independently and fairly. The two other tribunal judges, Justice A T M Fazle Kabir and judge A K M Zaheer Ahmed, said in their ruling that the tribunal did not have such a provision that empowered them to remove a fellow judge. At the end they left it 'to the good conscience' of the tribunal chief. This triggered the defence to file another application demanding that the tribunal chief explain his decision. Justice Huq had then fixed Wednesday for the ruling after having heard both sides regarding this application on Sunday. On Nov 16, Sayedee's lawyers had stormed out of the court after the tribunal chief joined proceedings. They also filed the two applications before walking out of the tribunal. The tribunal fixed Nov 20 for disposing of that application, but when urged to continue with the scheduled hearing of a review petition of Sayedee's indictment, the defence refused to proceed and walked out demanding that the tribunal chief explain himself first. The tribunal said the conduct of the defence lawyers had been "unwarranted" and "unbecoming". As for the review petition, the court said it was rejected since it was 'not pressed'. The defence had told the press later that they would wait until the disposal of application was disposed of on Sunday. On the other hand, the prosecution claimed that the defence had violated all ethics, code of conduct and customs that behove lawyers. The prosecution raised a legal point and said the petition was not maintainable or in form. The prosecution further pointed out that the commission in question was not in any way part of the ongoing trial. Nor did it have any legal coverage. The other two judges of the tribunal, ATM Fazle Kabir and AKM Zaheer Ahmed, held a hearing of that petition on Nov 13 in a crowded courtroom. They ruled the following day that the laws did not provide for the tribunal judges to remove a co-judge. They also pointed out that the previous cases cited by the defence counsel Abdur Razzaq where judges were recused had the privilege of such laws. In conclusion, they left the matter of recusal to the 'good conscience of the judge' in question. bdnews24.com/ta/jr/1427h.
Related Stories