November 21, 2026

In Afghanistan, the past is back

In Afghanistan, the past is back
Afghan women wait to receive free wheat donated by the Afghan government during a quarantine, amid concerns about the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) in Kabul, Afghanistan April 21, 2020. Reuters

Syed Badrul Ahsan Syed Badrul Ahsan

Published : 16 Aug 2021, 07:17 PM

Updated : 21 Jun 2022, 08:16 PM

The Taliban have taken back Afghanistan. So what happens now? For starters, the Taliban leadership, not much about them known though, have promised to be different from what they were 20 years ago. But even as the world hopes the old repressive order will not be restored, there are reports of the ill treatment the Taliban have been meting out to girls and women in the regions they have so swiftly overrun in just 10 days. That is cause for concern, for the lesson of history is that men who have once exercised ferocity in politics do not change much in the behavioural sense. To what extent the Taliban will now treat women, a large number of whom have in these two decades asserted themselves through education and many of whom occupy key positions in Afghan society, is to be observed.

An incontrovertible fact about the Taliban is that they are a band of fighters steeped not only in medievalism but are also profoundly wedded to the concept of misogyny. That raises the natural worry of whether, if at all, the men who today have retaken Kabul will at all be willing to accord the respect the women of Afghanistan have been recipients of in the last twenty years. And where the question is one of how the Taliban treat the country's male citizens, one goes back to the mid-1990s and early 2000s when they imposed a dark code of conduct — ranging from the length of their beards to the attire they would wear — on Afghan men.

The Taliban will impose Sharia law all over Afghanistan, which again would be a perfect recipe for the isolation of the country from the international community. The harsh form of Islam which these radical men exercised in Afghanistan in the past, an Islam that had little room for tolerance or acceptance of views at variance with those of the Taliban, has never been jettisoned by the Taliban. That will be a stumbling block in the country's dealings with the outside world. Of course, governments in the West have already begun talking of sanctions should Afghanistan fall foul of international standards of governance, a point the Taliban in their new avatar, if indeed it is a new avatar, ought not to ignore. The twenty years which have gone by should have been a sobering lesson for the Taliban. Have the Taliban learnt that lesson?

Speaking of lessons being learned, what lessons have the West — the United States and member-states of NATO — have learned in their occupation of Afghanistan since 2001? George W. Bush and his administration went marching into Kabul with dreams of building a nation out of a country historically resistant to foreign invasions. By all accounts, invasion was what happened in Afghanistan in 2001, but as benign invasions sometimes are, it was an operation aimed at establishing civil order in the country. But that point about nation-building quite ignored the historical lesson — that tribalism of the kind which has been the Afghan heritage has little or no space for modern concepts of government. The Soviets tried to push Afghanistan to modernity through communism. It did not work. The Mujahideen attempted governance through Islamic rule, but was destroyed from within by the warlords who constituted its core.

And now, as Taliban fighters occupy the presidential office in Kabul and hundreds of Afghans try desperately to board aircraft at the airport and leave the country, the stark lesson is here for the world: America and the West have failed the people of Afghanistan. The rapidity with which the Taliban have seized the country, despite a 300,000-man army the West built for Afghans, reveals a couple of factors. In the first place, in these past twenty years the Taliban were never defeated. Ousted from power in 2001, they simply retreated into the mountains. In the second, the Afghan army, for all the excitement about its coming into shape, remained a ragtag band of uniformed men who had little capacity to keep the Taliban at bay when the moment of reckoning came. That moment came in the last ten days. Nowhere was the army in sight. And everywhere was the spectacle of soldiers dropping their weapons in the face of the Taliban onslaught and running for cover.

Now Ashraf Ghani, the lapsed President of Afghanistan, too has scampered off to safety, probably in Tajikistan. But can one blame him for such a demonstration of cowardice? There is, after all, the horrible tale of what the Taliban did to Dr Najibullah, the last communist leader of Afghanistan, when they seized the country in 1996.

The Soviet Union could not save its communist clients in Kabul. And now the United States has once again shown — think back on Vietnam — that its presence in a country is a castle in the sand, waiting to be blown away by the sea. And the sea, in unstoppable waves, is the Taliban. The pity is not that the Taliban have marched triumphantly back to power. The pity is that Afghanistan has been abandoned, with all insensitivity, by those nations which promised Afghans that the past did not matter, that the future was all. Now the past is back. The future has suddenly become intensely blurred for Afghanistan's people.

It would be easy to wish the people of Afghanistan well. But given the record of how much they have suffered, beginning with the Saur Revolution of 1978 through the Soviet invasion through Mujahideen chaos through Taliban horror through Western dominance and wobbly governments — Hamid Karzai and Ashraf Ghani — not much light can be spotted at the end of the tunnel. Indeed, the tunnel has in these past ten-plus days become longer and the darkness appears impenetrable.

This is the harsh reality — that fingers be kept crossed about Afghanistan's future. And, as a former Canadian ambassador to Afghanistan emotionally noted the other day, watch must be kept on those who have, before and in these twenty years, sponsored the rise and survival of the Taliban. He pointed to Pakistan's ISI. That is okay, but that the West failed miserably in neutralising the Taliban is the bigger shame in Kabul today.

Afghanistan is in a state of turbulence today. The rest of the world is not in happy circumstances either. With the Taliban freeing prisoners across the country and long incarcerated ISIS and perhaps al-Qaeda elements walking free, the planet is once again a bleak place. Men swearing by medievalism do not represent hope. And nations abandoning with alacrity countries they have long patronised simply have no space for morality in a pursuit of their politics. Hypocrisy is what such politics is often defined as.

Related Stories