November 21, 2026

Am I terrorist, a Kafir or a Samosa?

Afsan Chowdhury

Published : 10 Sep 2010, 09:01 PM

Updated : 21 Jun 2022, 08:38 PM

A terrorist, a Kafir or a samosa? Who am I? And who decides who I am?  They are all my identities but I play no part in choosing them or becoming one.  I am made and unmade in the eyes of others who decide who I should be.

The West insists that I am a Muslim and nothing else. And while that's not officially stated, it's obvious that what comes to most Western mind when the word Muslim is uttered is 'terrorism'.  On the other hand, the Muslim 'Ummah' insists that I must have only one face, the Islamic one. But I am a Bengali, a Bangladeshi, a South Asian and many other names. They don't matter to those who decide who I am.

***

The latest controversy around the building of a new mosque funded by a wealthy Arab family near Ground Zero is a good example. Over 70 percent of Americans are against the building of a mosque there because they blame Muslims for the 9/11 attack. As an American said, letting a mosque being built near ground zero is like letting the Japanese build a triumphal monument near the Pearl Harbour. In the Western mind, all Muslims are one and guilty no matter how they feel or stand on the issue of terrorism.

But will building this mosque make Americans feel more positive towards Muslims in the US, make them safer or as it has done already, generate more hatred towards them?     Wouldn't a hospital for poor Muslims in the US serve them better?  It seems more of a fight between Americana bigotry and ignorance versus Islamic/Arab ego and arrogance forgetting the human cost of this clash.

***

Muslims barely existed in the Western world till 9/11. Having never experienced insecurity, most Americans reacted in astonished fear to 9/11. That fear turned into socially acceptable bigotry. But history shows that bigotry has always been a way of life in the West with the Nazi persecution of the Jews being the ultimate extreme example.

The actions of the victorious Allied forces that defeated the Nazis must be read in the context of the collective refusal of the Allies to allow any African/black soldiers to be part of the victory parade to liberate Paris at the end of WW ll. Allied leaders made sure that only white people were seen as liberating soldiers of the West. Fighters from the French colony of Ivory Coast in particular who were in the forefront of many French battles and supposed to be part of the parade were shunted away. Victory belonged to the white people though brown, white and black together fought to end Nazism.

***

The Western world view and their comfort zone are unsettled when a Muslim woman wears a burqa. In France, it's illegal to wear a burqa. It's considered a security threat and those wearing it are thought of as victims of a human rights violating culture. Yet France has deported impoverished Roma refugees from its borders, an act for which even the EU has condemned it. France and Europe's anxiety is about the wrong kind of immigration. It doesn't want African Muslims and European Roma people to come but such poor people are the ones who want to immigrate to Europe the most. Arguments feed its racism.

***

We see arbitrary state impositions in private matters in at least two other countries; Saudi Arabia and Iran. Both are socially intolerant with the monarchy in power in one and theocracy in another, advertising medievalism as a form of governance. In both these countries, human rights barely exist and dress codes just like the French have are in place with hijab, shawl and other variations forced upon the people. Iran, slightly more open politically than Saudi Arabia, has had huge spells of dissent and protest with bloody put downs while in Saudia Arabia, even fake parliaments and rigged elections are absent. Totalitarianism has been justified through religious anointment.

It's these powers and their lackeys in different parts of the world who decide who qualifies as Muslims. In 1971, we saw the best example of that as Pakistani soldiers killed Bangladeshis at will comforted by the fact that they were killing kafirs.  The Arab friends of Pakistan approved such acts and no Arab countries ever condemned this mass killing or apologised since then for supporting mass killing. In recent years, Arabiana has surged high riding the horse of 'holy causes' and Arab cultural practices have peaked making Arabs and Islam syno-cultural rather than putting global humanity and Islam together. However, Arabs are less than 20 percent of global Muslims.

***

But now in this name calling culture, South Asia's favourite snacks, the humble Samosa, too have entered. Several Pakistani Muslim youths have been arrested recently in Canada on charges of planning terrorist attacks. But what is also interesting is what the police operation was called: Operation Samosa. In a single stroke, the entire population of South Asia has been captured, identified and demonised. We have become samosas in the eyes of the West. The burqa and the samosa have become prolific cultural symbols of a people who deserve suspicion.

***

In Saudi Arabia and France, wearing or not wearing the burqa is not a matter of choice. But in Bangladesh, no one can be forced to wear the burqa, nor prevented from wearing one. It sums up in many ways, the different cultural level and description of the West, the Middle East and deltaic South Asia.

Yet, when it suits whoever that may be, we are a terrorist or a kafir or as we are now, a samosa.  They are all names of the enemy.

We didn't give us a name but we were told who we are. The Bangladeshi man knifed while driving a cab in New York by a fanatic didn't need an identity. He was given one by the attacker.

Just like the many killed in 1971.

Related Stories